Guide · Incentives

Commission on revenue, margin or ACV?

Pay on what the rep controls. Protect price some other way.

Short answer: Pay sales commission on the measure your reps control most directly. For most subscription sales that is revenue or annual contract value. Margin fits only where reps really set the price and can see the costs. Whatever the base, reps get exactly the behavior it pays for, so the price and contract terms it ignores need their own protection.

A record quarter that lost money

Picture a 140-person software company in Denver. It sells scheduling software to clinic groups on annual subscriptions, plus paid setup and training. Its eight account executives earn a base salary and a commission on the first-year value of every contract they sign, software and services together. The sales commission structure is simple and the reps like it: Every dollar a customer agrees to pay earns them the same share.

The fourth quarter is the best the company has had. Bookings beat the target and five of the eight reps pass quota. Then finance closes the books. Gross margin on new deals is down sharply. Two patterns explain most of it. Reps closed late deals with deep software discounts, because a lower price still earned a commission and the deal counted before year end. They also sold large setup and training packages, which are priced close to cost, because those dollars paid the same commission as software dollars.

The finance lead proposes paying commission on gross margin from January. The head of sales objects. Reps cannot see what the services team costs. They have no say over how long a setup takes. A rep who signs a clean deal could lose commission months later because a project ran over. The CEO asks a fair question: Is the problem the commission base or the fact that nobody but the rep decides the price?

This is a composite of a common situation at companies this size, not a client. The details are illustrative. The pattern is not rare. The base a commission is paid on decides what reps chase and every base rewards something the company did not mean to pay for.

Why choosing a commission base is hard

The commission base is the number the payout is calculated from. Revenue is what the customer pays. Gross margin is revenue minus the direct cost of delivering what was sold. Annual contract value, or ACV, is the yearly value of a contract, usually for recurring subscription fees only. Each one is a reasonable answer to the question "what is a good deal worth to us?" Each one is also a set of instructions to the sales team about what to ignore.

Two good goals pull against each other. The first is a measure reps can see, understand and influence. A rep who can work out what a deal will pay before signing it sells with confidence and spends no time checking the payroll. The second is a measure that reflects what the company actually wants: Profitable deals, at sound prices, on terms that hold up after signing. The closer a measure gets to true profit, the more it depends on things the rep does not control or cannot see. The closer it gets to what the rep controls, the more it leaves out.

The choice also has a short half-life. In a recent industry survey, 97% of companies said they changed their sales compensation plans for 2026 and 66% said they were leaning further into pay for performance. Only about one in five rated their previous year's plan as very effective [1]. Plans change every year because the base that fit last year's strategy rarely fits this year's.

And trust is thin. In a 2026 survey of 500 US sales professionals published by a CRM software provider, 74% of reps said they wished there were more transparency in how their pay is calculated and 47% said their compensation does not always seem fair [3]. A base that is closer to the company's goals but harder to calculate can cost more in trust than it saves in margin.

Finally, the base sits inside a written promise. Some US states require commission plans to be written down and to state how commissions are calculated [5] [6]. A base that cannot be described plainly in a plan document is a poor choice for that reason alone.

Three bases, side by side

This table sets the three bases against each other. It shows trade-offs only and is not a plan design. Real plans often combine a primary base with one or two other measures.

BaseWhat it rewardsWhat it can reward by accidentFits best when
RevenueVolume: Every dollar the customer paysDiscounts, low-margin add-ons, deals that cost more to deliver than they bring inPrices are set centrally and margins are similar across what reps sell
Gross marginProfitable deals and holding priceArguments over cost allocation, delayed and disputed payouts, avoiding strategic but thin productsReps set the price, can see the cost and the cost is known at signing
ACVRecurring value in year oneLong contracts at deep discounts, ramp deals that look large, neglect of setup fees and renewalsSubscription sales where year-one recurring value is a fair proxy for the deal

Two other choices change what any base means in practice: When a deal counts (at signing, at invoice or when the cash arrives) and which revenue counts (new customers only, or expansion and renewals too). Those choices matter as much as the base itself. They are part of the same decision.

Five traps when choosing a commission base

Most of these traps share a root. The base is chosen to fix last year's problem and nobody asks what new behavior it will pay for.

"Pay on revenue and let the reps set the price"

What it looks like: Commission is a share of revenue and reps have wide discount authority. At quarter end, discounts deepen. A rep who gives away 20% of the price loses only a fraction of a commission on that deal and may win a deal that counts toward quota.

Why smart teams fall into it: Revenue is the simplest base to explain and to calculate. Discount authority feels like trusting the people closest to the customer. Early on, when the company needs logos more than margin, the arrangement often works.

What it costs: The company pays full commission on revenue it gave away. Discounting also spreads. Customers learn that waiting until the end of the quarter pays. The next renewal starts from the discounted price. Research on pricing discretion shows why this is a design question, not a character question. A study of an auto lender found that salespeople's local price adjustments raised profit by about 11% on average, but that a well-optimized central pricing system could have raised it by up to a further 20% [4]. Field judgment on price can add value. It is not free and a revenue commission gives reps no reason to weigh what a discount costs.

"Switch to margin and the discounting stops"

What it looks like: After a quarter like the one in Denver, the company moves reps to commission on gross margin. Discounts do shrink. Within months the sales team is arguing with finance about how costs are allocated, why a services overrun cut a rep's payout and when the commission on a deal will finally be known.

Why smart teams fall into it: Margin is closer to what the business wants and it makes the cost of a discount visible to the rep at once. In businesses where reps negotiate price and the cost of goods is known at signing, such as distribution, it works well.

What it costs: Margin plans need three things many companies cannot give: Cost data the rep can see, costs that are known when the deal is signed and costs the rep can influence. Without them, the rep is paid on numbers set by other teams after the sale. Payouts become slower, harder to check and easier to dispute. Some companies will not share product costs with the sales team at all, which leaves reps paid on a number they cannot verify. That is the trust problem from the survey above, made worse. Margin plans can also steer reps away from products the company wants to grow but sells at a thin margin for now.

"ACV is the standard, so it must fit us"

What it looks like: The company sells subscriptions, so it pays on ACV because that is what other software companies seem to do. Then the definitional questions start. Does a three-year contract that rises each year count at its first year, its average or its last? Does a ramp deal, priced low in year one and high in year three, count at the low number or the high one? Do setup fees count? Do renewals?

Why smart teams fall into it: ACV is widely used for subscription sales and it removes the worst problem with paying on total contract value, which rewards long contracts regardless of price. Using a common measure also makes hiring easier, since experienced reps recognize it.

What it costs: Every definitional gap becomes a negotiation. If multi-year contracts count at their average value, reps can offer a long term with a steep discount to lift the number they are paid on. If setup fees are excluded, services stop being sold or are given away to close. If renewals pay nothing, account managers have no reason to protect them. The measure is only as good as its written definition. "ACV" with no definition is not a base. It is the start of an argument.

"One base for every sales role"

What it looks like: New-business reps, account managers and channel managers all earn commission on the same base, often revenue. The account manager earns commission on renewals that would have happened anyway. The channel manager earns on deals partners closed alone.

Why smart teams fall into it: One base is simple to run and feels fair: Everyone is paid on the same thing. Small sales teams often start with one role and the plan grows by copying.

What it costs: Different roles control different outcomes. A new-business rep controls whether a customer signs. An account manager controls whether the customer stays and grows. Paying both on the same base pays one of them for luck and gives the other no reason to do the work the role exists for. Most companies already avoid this. In the most recent public edition of a long-running US survey of sales compensation practices, 71% of organizations used two to three performance measures in their plans. Revenue was the most common measure for all sales roles, bookings came second and gross profit third for field and hybrid roles [2]. The point is not that every plan needs three measures. It is that the measure should follow the role.

"A blend so precise nobody can work out their pay"

What it looks like: To fix the flaws of each base, the plan adds them up. Revenue pays a rate, a margin modifier adjusts it, multi-year deals get a kicker, renewals pay a different rate and services pay half. Each rule answers a real problem. Together, no rep can say what a deal will pay before it closes.

Why smart teams fall into it: Every rule is a response to a past case of bad behavior. Removing any one of them feels like reopening that door. The plan grows a little more complex each year and nobody steps back to read it as a rep would.

What it costs: A plan reps cannot calculate does not steer behavior, because people cannot aim at what they cannot see. It also has a legal edge. In California, a commission contract must be in writing and must set out the method by which commissions are computed and paid [6]. In New York, the terms for commission salespeople must be written, signed by both sides and include a description of how commissions are calculated. If the employer cannot produce them, the salesperson's account of the terms is presumed correct [5]. A plan that even the people who run it explain differently is hard to put on paper in a way that holds.

What a sound commission base looks like

A sound commission base is not the one closest to profit. It is the one that pays for what each role controls, with the gaps it leaves covered on purpose. Several qualities set it apart.

The rep can calculate it before signing. If a rep cannot work out what a deal will pay from the plan document and the deal terms, the base is too complex or depends on information the rep does not have. A good test is whether two reps, given the same deal, would arrive at the same payout.

It follows what the role controls. New-business roles are paid on what they win. Retention and growth roles are paid on what they keep and expand. Where a rep sets the price, price quality is part of the measure. Where price is set centrally, it does not need to be.

The gaps are covered by something other than the base. Every base leaves something out. Revenue ignores price quality. ACV ignores contract terms. Sound plans name what their base ignores and protect it another way: Discount approval rules, a price floor, a deal desk or a modest modifier the rep can see. The protection is chosen on purpose, not added after a bad quarter.

The definition is written and matches finance. The base is the same number finance reports, defined once in writing. What counts, when it counts and how multi-year, ramp and renewal deals are treated are written down before the year starts. Disputes are then about facts, not about what the plan meant.

It is tested against real deals before launch. A base that looks right in a spreadsheet can pay strangely on actual deals. Plans that hold up have been read against a sample of last year's deals, including the odd ones, to see who would have been paid what and whether that matches what the company would have wanted to pay for.

It survives a payout statement. A rep reading the statement can trace each line to a deal and a rule. Where the law entitles a rep to a statement of earnings on request, as in New York [5], that statement should be one the company is comfortable handing over.

None of this needs a large sales operations team. It needs the discipline to choose the base deliberately, write it down plainly and decide in advance what the base will not protect.

The calls only you can make

Some of the choices behind a commission base are not technical. They are statements about the business.

Are you buying growth or profit this year? A company winning its first hundred customers may accept thin deals for logos and references. A company with a profitability target cannot. The base should follow that choice and the choice should be stated, ideally in the same words as your compensation philosophy.

Who owns price? If reps set the price, the plan has to make them feel what a discount costs. If a central team sets it, the plan can pay on volume and leave price to the rules. Mixing the two, with reps holding wide discount authority and no reason to use it carefully, is the most common source of the Denver quarter.

How much cost data will you share? Margin plans only work when reps can see costs. Some companies are comfortable with that. Others see their cost structure as confidential. Both are legitimate positions, but the second one rules out a full margin base.

When does a deal count? Paying at signing rewards closing. Paying at invoice or on cash collection puts more of the risk of a bad customer on the rep. The right answer depends on how much of that risk the rep can see coming.

How much variation in pay will you accept? A base that tracks profit closely will make some reps' pay swing for reasons they did not cause. Some companies accept that as the price of alignment. Others decide that a predictable plan is worth a less precise one.

The data, the law and the numbers

  • Plans change every year. An industry survey of hundreds of companies across 11 industries reports that 97% changed their 2026 sales compensation plans, 66% are leaning further into pay for performance and 65% say governance and program management need to improve. About one in five rated the previous year's plan as very effective [1].
  • Revenue still leads. In the most recent public edition of WorldatWork's survey of sales compensation programs (693 responses, fielded June 2022), revenue was the most used measure for all sales roles, bookings second and gross profit third for field and hybrid roles. 71% of organizations used two to three measures [2]. A newer edition was not publicly available when we checked.
  • Reps want to see the math. A CRM software provider's 2026 report, based on a survey of 500 US sales professionals from August to September 2025, found 74% of reps wish for more transparency in how their pay is calculated and 47% say their pay does not always seem fair [3]. These are the provider's own figures.
  • Pricing discretion has a value and a cost. A peer-reviewed study of an auto lender found that salespeople's price adjustments raised profit by about 11% on average, while well-optimized central pricing could have raised it by up to 20% more [4]. It is one industry, but it is a rare look at real pricing decisions.
  • New York. Terms for commission salespeople must be in writing, signed by both sides, kept for at least three years and include how commissions are calculated, the reconciliation of any recoverable draw and payment on termination. On written request, the employer must give a statement of earnings [5].
  • California. A commission contract for work performed in the state must be in writing, set out how commissions are computed and paid and be given to the employee signed, with a signed receipt [6]. Some bonus and profit-sharing plans fall outside the definition.
  • Commissions are pay for equal pay purposes. US equal pay guidance treats commissions as part of compensation. Paying men and women the same commission rate is consistent with the law even if totals differ, but the guidance also asks whether lower-paid employees were given less support to produce revenue [8]. Who gets the best accounts and territories matters. Our guide on which pay gaps you can defend covers why.
  • EU pay includes variable pay. The EU pay transparency directive defines pay to include complementary and variable components, so commissions count in the pay gap figures employers will report [7].

This is general information, not legal advice. Commission rules differ by state and country and change over time. Check the rules where your reps work.

Our view

We think the commission base should follow what each sales role controls most directly. For most subscription sales that means revenue or a clearly defined ACV for new-business roles, a retention and growth measure for account roles and a separate protection for price, such as discount rules or a modest modifier the rep can see.

We are cautious about full margin plans in companies where reps neither set the price nor see the cost. They make pay harder to check and slower to arrive, for an alignment the company could get more cheaply by controlling discounts. Where reps really do negotiate price on goods with known costs, margin is often the right base.

We would argue hardest against two things: A base with no written definition and a plan so layered that reps cannot calculate their own pay. Both turn a pay plan into a monthly argument. A plan reps can calculate and finance agrees with will beat a cleverer plan nobody trusts.

Sources

  1. Alexander Group, 2026 Sales Compensation Trends research briefing (hundreds of companies across 11 industries), checked 2026-10-26
  2. WorldatWork, 2022 Sales Compensation Programs and Practices Survey, press release (22 August 2022; 693 responses), checked 2026-10-26
  3. Salesforce, 2026 Trends in Sales Compensation report (500 US sales professionals, surveyed 7 August to 24 September 2025), checked 2026-10-26
  4. Phillips, Şimşek and van Ryzin, The Effectiveness of Field Price Discretion: Empirical Evidence from Auto Lending, Management Science 61(8), 2015, checked 2026-10-26
  5. New York Labor Law § 191(1)(c), commission salespersons (NY Senate), checked 2026-10-26
  6. California Labor Code § 2751, commission contracts, checked 2026-10-26
  7. Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Article 3 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-25
  8. US EEOC, Compliance Manual Section 10: Compensation Discrimination, 10-IV.C and 10-IV.F.2.f, checked 2026-10-26

What pay mix fits each sales role?

One base-to-variable split for every sales role pays some people for luck. Five traps in setting the sales pay mix and what a sound split looks like.

Which market percentile to target?

Most companies aim for the median, but the market they pick matters more. Five ways the percentile choice goes wrong and what a sound target looks like.

EU pay gap reporting: When and what?

The first EU pay gap reports cover 2026 pay. Who files when, what the seven figures count and why the data year is already almost over.

See Resources for every guide and the self-check.