Virginia now weighs range width in good faith and Delaware will from 2027. Five ways posted ranges go wrong and what a defensible range looks like.
14 min read ·
Why it matters now
Virginia's law, in force since July 2026, weighs the breadth of a posted range when judging good faith. Delaware follows in 2027. The EU directive brings the same question to Europe.
All guides
Service areas
Themes
Type
Job architecture
Levels, job families and titles: The structure every pay decision sits on.
Start a first leveling from the roles, not the people or their pay. Five traps when a startup levels its team and what a sound first leveling looks like.
Levels drift from the work through exceptions, not age. Why a growing company's job architecture wears down and why the fix is one owner with written rules.
The EU pay directive never says job evaluation, but it asks the question job evaluation answers. Five traps and what a proportionate approach looks like.
Pick the lightest method that still defends equal value. Ranking, paired comparison or points at about 200 roles: Five traps and what a sound choice looks like.
Titles and job families do not settle equal value. The demands of the work do. Five traps in proving the comparison and what sound evidence looks like.
Salary surveys, live pay data and job ads answer different questions. Five ways teams misread their market data and what a sound source policy looks like.
Most companies aim for the median, but the market they pick matters more. Five ways the percentile choice goes wrong and what a sound target looks like.
More than 250 class actions followed Washington's job ad pay law. Why small misses became big claims and what the five-day fix changes until July 2027.
Eight states and DC put range rules on employers with 10 or fewer staff. The thresholds, what counts toward them and why a startup's first hire matters.
Most US pay range laws follow where the work could be done, not where you are based. Five ways remote ads go wrong and what a sound approach looks like.
A 5% gap in any category of workers can trigger an EU joint pay assessment. Five ways mid-size employers get caught and what a sound position looks like.
Most pay equity reviews run right after the pay cycle that created the gaps. Why a light check before each cycle works better and what the law rewards.
Every commission base pays for something you did not mean to buy. Five traps in choosing revenue, margin or ACV and what a plan reps can trust looks like.
A bonus no one can influence is a gift, not an incentive. Five traps in bonus plans for non-sales staff at small companies and what a sound plan looks like.
EU staff must be able to see the criteria behind their pay and progression. Five traps in writing them down and what sound, checkable criteria look like.
Every job is scored on six factors. Each factor has plain-language levels and each level carries a fixed number of points. The points add up to a total and the total places the job in one of 12 grades. Grades then link to your pay bands and to the career levels in your job architecture.
Five factors cover the four things equal pay rules compare jobs on (skill, effort, responsibility and working conditions): Expertise, judgment, impact, leadership and demands. The sixth, AI leverage, measures how far a job is required to direct, design and govern AI and automation. Each factor answers one plain question about the job, never about the person in it.
Expertise
What the job requires someone to know and be able to do.
7 levels, from basic routines learned in weeks to command of how the whole organization works and competes.
Share of the maximum score: 27%
Judgment
How hard the problems are and how much the job has to work out for itself.
7 levels, from clear instructions with a known answer to shaping strategy under high uncertainty.
Share of the maximum score: 23%
Impact
What results the job owns and how big they are.
7 levels, from own tasks, closely checked, to the results of the whole organization.
Share of the maximum score: 23%
Leadership and influence
Leading people and persuading people the job doesn't manage.
6 levels, from working mainly alone to leading the organization and representing it to boards and investors.
Share of the maximum score: 11%
AI leverage
How far the job is required to direct, design and govern AI and automation. We score the job, not the person.
6 levels, from no AI use required to setting AI strategy and governance for a function or the organization.
Share of the maximum score: 10%
Demands and working conditions
The effort the job demands (mental, emotional and physical) and the conditions it is done in.
4 levels, from normal office demands to constant exposure to distressing, hazardous or round-the-clock on-call conditions.
Share of the maximum score: 6%
AI leverage is weighted lightly on purpose: It rewards real responsibility for AI-driven work without lifting the grade of every job that uses a chat tool. The weight can rise for a client whose model depends on AI. Demands counts emotional load, such as a queue of upset customers, as fully as physical effort. Every job also gets an AI exposure tag (Low, Medium or High) for the share of its current tasks that AI can do today. The tag doesn't change the grade. It feeds workforce planning, reskilling and job redesign.
12 grades
Every total from 145 to 1,050 points lands in one grade, each 75 points wide. Smaller companies can merge neighboring grades.
Four built-in checks
A score gets a second look if judgment sits more than one level above expertise, if impact is high while leadership and judgment are both low, if AI leverage runs ahead of judgment, or if demands are scored at the top level without a written reason. Governing AI needs matching judgment.
Grade
Points
Typical level
Grade 1
145 to 219
Entry, support
Grade 2
220 to 294
Experienced support
Grade 3
295 to 369
Early-career professional
Grade 4
370 to 444
Professional
Grade 5
445 to 519
Experienced professional
Grade 6
520 to 594
Senior professional, team lead
Grade 7
595 to 669
Manager, lead expert
Grade 8
670 to 744
Senior manager, principal expert
Grade 9
745 to 819
Head of function (smaller organization), director
Grade 10
820 to 894
Senior director, VP
Grade 11
895 to 969
Senior VP, executive
Grade 12
970 to 1,050
C-suite
Six jobs, scored
Factor levels for six sample jobs, the points they add up to and the grade they land in.
Job
Expertise
Judgment
Impact
Leadership
AI leverage
Demands
Points
Grade
AI exposure
HR coordinator
2
2
1
1
1
2
255
2
High
Customer support specialist
2
2
2
1
1
3
305
3
High
Payroll manager
4
4
4
3
2
2
570
6
Medium
Senior software engineer
5
4
3
2
3
1
560
6
Medium
VP sales
6
6
6
5
3
2
850
10
Low
CEO, mid-size company
7
7
7
6
4
3
1,015
12
Low
Illustrative scores for typical jobs. Your jobs are scored from your own job descriptions.
How a project runs
CollectJob descriptions, or a 1-page job questionnaire, for 15 to 25 benchmark jobs across all levels.
ScoreEach benchmark job is scored on the six factors, with one line of reasoning per factor.
CalibrateYour panel reviews the ranking, not the points. Does the order look right?
LockScores are adjusted and the benchmarks locked. The remaining jobs are slotted against them.
DeliverA scored job list, the grade structure, the factor reasoning and AI exposure tags.
Already have grades?
Already have grades, survey levels or another method? We map our grades to yours, job by job, so everything you've built still works.
We work from what you own: Which job sits in which of your grades or survey levels. We score 15 to 25 anchor jobs spread across your grades, line them up by points and turn your grade breaks into points cut-offs on our scale. One of your grades may cover one or two of ours, or the reverse.
Grades from another evaluation method: Mapped from your current job list and grades.
Salary survey levels: Each survey track matched to our expertise and leadership levels, then confirmed with the jobs you have already matched.
Internal grades or titles: Mapped from your org chart and job list.
Any job that sits more than one of our grades away from the pattern is flagged with two possible readings: Its current grade under- or over-reads the job, or its job description is out of date. You decide at calibration. Once you sign off the crosswalk, every new job is scored once and lands in both grade systems.
A crosswalk, in practice
A fictional client with eight internal grades, L1 to L8, after nine anchor jobs were scored.
One job was flagged: The senior software engineer scores like the payroll manager (L5) but sits in L4. The client confirmed the scope with the engineering lead, then chose between moving the job to L5 or keeping it in L4 with a note.