Note · Job evaluation · Updated on

How long does evaluating 100 jobs take?

About 60 hours of work. Most of it goes into the job content, not the scoring.

Short answer: With 20 to 25 benchmark jobs and a trained scorer, 100 jobs take about 60 hours of work over two to three weeks. Roughly 60% of that goes into getting accurate job content. Scoring and slotting take about a quarter. The calendar is set by how fast managers answer, not how fast anyone scores.

Six weeks in, nothing scored

A 260-person manufacturing software company in Milwaukee decides to evaluate its 100 jobs before its first EU pay report. HR books two days for scoring. Six weeks later, nothing has been scored. Half the job descriptions were written for hiring ads years ago. A quarter of managers have not returned the questionnaire. Three teams say their job description is wrong but cannot agree on what is right.

The company and its figures are an illustration, not data.

Where the time goes

Here is our working estimate for 100 jobs, with 25 benchmark jobs scored in full and the other 75 slotted against them:

StepHoursShare
Job content: A 1-page questionnaire per benchmark job (about an hour of manager time each), then review and follow-up questions3660%
Scoring 25 benchmark jobs on every factor, at about 20 minutes each813%
Slotting the other 75 jobs against the benchmarks, at about 5 minutes each610%
Calibration: A 90-minute call with a 4-person panel, then fixes1017%
Total60100%

The hours are our estimate, not a survey. The shape is the point: Scoring is the short step.

Why job content takes the longest

Most job descriptions do not describe the job. Korn Ferry reported in October 2025 that 79% of employees say their role differs substantially from its job description [1]. A description written for a job ad lists tasks and wish lists. Scoring needs something else: The knowledge the job needs, the decisions it makes, who it affects and its working conditions. The EU pay directive names the same four things as the criteria for comparing jobs: Skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions [2].

So the first pass is a short questionnaire, not a rewrite of every description. Only the benchmark jobs need one. The rest can be slotted from a few lines once the benchmarks are settled.

Why every-job panels slow down

Some large employers send every job through a panel. In the NHS, the most common panel has four people: Two managers and two staff representatives [3]. One Welsh health board ran two 2-hour panel sessions a week and built a 12 to 14 week backlog in 2022. It moved to four 1-hour sessions a week to clear it [3]. Its audit counted 365 job evaluation requests in just over a year [3]. A panel for every job makes sense at that scale and with unions at the table. At 100 jobs it mostly adds waiting. One trained scorer plus one calibration call gives the same check for far less time. Our guide on which job evaluation method to use covers which method fits your size.

What it means for a company of 50 to 500 people

Plan the calendar around job content. Send questionnaires for the benchmark jobs first and give managers a week. Pick benchmarks that span every level and the biggest job families. Include jobs mostly held by women and jobs mostly held by men, because those are the comparisons that get tested. Our guide on proving two different jobs are of equal value covers why. Keep the scoring notes: One line of reasoning per factor is what makes a result defensible later.

Our view

If a job evaluation project is late, it is almost never the scoring. Budget most of the time for job content, choose benchmarks with care and keep the panel for calibration, not for every job. Two to three weeks is realistic for 100 jobs when managers answer on time.

Sources

  1. Korn Ferry, This Week in Leadership: Not what I signed up for (20 October 2025; survey sample not stated), checked 2026-10-27
  2. Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Article 4(4) (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-25
  3. NHS Wales Shared Services Partnership, Swansea Bay University Health Board, Job Evaluation Final Internal Audit Report 2024/25 (signed off 12 May 2025), checked 2026-10-27

Changelog: 27 October 2026, first published. The Milwaukee company and its figures are an illustration, not data. The hour figures are our working estimate.

Will the EU make you evaluate jobs?

The EU pay directive never says job evaluation, but it asks the question job evaluation answers. Five traps and what a proportionate approach looks like.

Job family or level: Which comes first?

Levels first, families second. Why job architecture projects stall on family trees and what an order of work that pays back early looks like.

Buy a leveling framework or build one?

A bought leveling framework brings shared words, not decisions. Five traps in buying or building one and what a sound company level guide looks like.

See Resources for every guide and the self-check.