Guide · Job evaluation

Are two different jobs of equal value?

Different titles and different families do not settle it. The demands of the work do.

Short answer: Two different jobs are of equal value when their demands are equal, judged on factors such as skill, effort, responsibility and working conditions. Titles, job families and market rates do not decide it. In the UK and EU, the strongest proof is a sound, gender-neutral job evaluation done before anyone asks, plus a recorded reason for any pay gap between the jobs.

Two jobs, one question

Picture a 250-person medical imaging software company in Columbus, Ohio, with 45 people in Manchester. In Manchester it has two teams that never sit together. Customer support team leads, eight of them and seven women, handle escalations from hospital radiology departments by phone and screen share. Field service engineers, nine of them and all men, drive to hospitals to install and repair the scanner software on site.

The field engineers earn about 18% more in base pay. Nobody chose that gap on purpose. The engineer roles were set up when the company bought a small service firm and the pay came with them. The support leads came later and were placed in the customer success band.

One of the support leads writes to HR. She has trained two of the engineers on the software. She handles calls where a scan has failed and a patient is waiting. She thinks her job is worth as much as theirs and she wants to know why she is paid less.

HR's first answer is that the jobs are in different families, with different levels and different market data. That answer does not hold. Under UK law, a woman can claim equal pay with a man doing different work if the demands of the two jobs are of equal value [1]. The company now has to show either that the jobs are not of equal value or that something other than sex explains the gap.

This is a composite of a common situation, not a client. The pattern is the point. A company that has never compared two jobs from different families makes its first comparison after someone asks.

Why proving equal value is hard

Equal value is a different test from equal work. Two people doing the same job at different pay is easy to spot. Equal value asks whether two jobs that look nothing alike make equal demands on the people doing them. That is hard for four reasons.

The comparison crosses the structure. Pay structures group jobs by family and level, so they are built to compare jobs within a family. Equal value claims are usually about jobs in different families, often one mostly done by women and one mostly done by men. The structure has no answer ready.

The factors are broad. UK law speaks of demands such as effort, skill and decision-making [1]. The EU directive names skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions and calls these four "essential and sufficient" [3]. Each factor has to be defined and weighed for the jobs in question. The directive's recitals say each one is weighed by the employer depending on its relevance to the job [3].

The evidence is about the work, not the paperwork. Job descriptions are often old, written for hiring and silent on what the job really demands. A comparison built on them can miss half the work.

Few companies are ready. In an October 2025 survey of 391 HR professionals in Ireland, 25% named categorizing employees who do the same work or work of equal value as a main challenge in preparing for the directive [10]. The cases that reach court are large and slow, but they show where the evidence fails.

Five traps in proving two jobs are or are not of equal value

Most of these traps come from defending the pay structure as it is, rather than comparing the two jobs on their demands.

"Different families, so they can't be compared"

What it looks like: The company answers an equal value question by pointing to the job architecture. Support sits in customer success, engineering sits in service and each family has its own levels and pay.

Why smart teams fall into it: The architecture is how the company thinks about jobs. Comparing across families feels like comparing apples and oranges.

What it costs: The law does not care about the family. Under the EU directive, the comparison reaches any workers whose pay comes from a single source, such as one employer. It is not limited to people employed at the same time. Where no real comparator exists, a worker can rely on other evidence, including statistics or a hypothetical comparison [3]. In the UK, the largest cases compare store jobs with warehouse jobs. A tribunal found the mostly female retail roles at one retailer to be of equal value to its warehouse roles [6]. At another, it found that 12 of 14 lead claimants in store roles had shown equal value with some male comparators in distribution [8]. If you use separate families, you still need a way to compare across them. That is what job evaluation is for.

"The job descriptions prove they're different"

What it looks like: HR puts the two job descriptions side by side. The engineer's lists technical skills, travel and safety training. The support lead's lists customer communication and ticket handling. The difference looks obvious.

Why smart teams fall into it: Job descriptions are the only written record of the jobs. They feel like evidence.

What it costs: A comparison looks at the work people actually do. US federal rules on equal pay say the question depends on actual job requirements and performance, not on job classifications or titles [4]. The support lead in Columbus trains engineers and handles cases with patients waiting. Neither appears in her description. When the description and the work differ, the work wins and the company's evidence becomes the claimant's evidence.

"Physical effort counts, the rest doesn't"

What it looks like: The company scores the engineer higher on effort and working conditions because of driving, lifting and work in hospital plant rooms. It scores the support lead lower because she works at a desk.

Why smart teams fall into it: Physical demands are visible and easy to describe. Emotional and mental demands are not.

What it costs: Effort is not only physical. US federal rules count mental exertion as effort. They also say that where the amount of effort is substantially equal, a difference only in the kind of effort does not justify a pay difference [4]. The EU directive says relevant soft skills must not be undervalued [3]. Calls with distressed clinicians, time pressure and the cost of a wrong answer are real demands. A scheme that sees only the physical side is the kind of bias the EU guidance warns about, built in through factor definitions and weights [11].

"We'll score them when someone asks"

What it looks like: The company has no job evaluation. When the question comes, it plans to have a consultant score the two jobs and use the result.

Why smart teams fall into it: Scoring every job feels like a big project for a question that may never come.

What it costs: Timing matters. Under the UK Equality Act, where a job evaluation study has already given two jobs different values, the tribunal must find they are not of equal value. The exceptions are reasonable grounds to suspect the study discriminates because of sex or is otherwise unreliable [2]. A study done across all jobs, before any claim, is hard to attack. A study of two jobs built after a claim, by a company with a stake in the answer, invites exactly the challenge that it is unreliable. Without a study, the tribunal can ask an independent expert to report on the question [2]. Then the company no longer controls how the jobs are described. Sound evaluation is analytical, done by a panel and judges the job, not the person in it [9]. Which method to use is its own choice.

"The market pays them more"

What it looks like: The company accepts the jobs may be of similar value but says engineers cost more to hire. The market rate is the reason for the gap.

Why smart teams fall into it: It is often true. Engineers are harder to find and the company pays what it must.

What it costs: The market can be a defense, but only with evidence. In 2026 the UK's Employment Appeal Tribunal accepted that paying a warehouse market rate to recruit and keep enough staff can be a legitimate aim. It said the lower tribunal was wrong to treat that aim as being about cost only [6]. But it upheld findings against the same employer on a night premium and paid rest breaks, where the difference came from decisions to save costs [6]. Commentators note that market rates are not an automatic defense and cost saving alone will generally not be enough [7]. The lesson from that case is to record the reason at the time: Vacancies, turnover, agency use and hiring costs for the higher-paid group [6]. A market argument made only after a claim, with no records, is weak. The same test applies to other reasons for a gap, as our guide on which pay gaps you can defend explains.

What sound evidence of equal value looks like

Sound evidence is not a thick file. It is a comparison of the work that someone outside the company could check and reach the same answer. Several qualities set it apart.

It covers all jobs, not just the two in question. One method, applied to every job before anyone asks. A comparison made for one dispute looks like an answer chosen first.

It uses the four criteria, defined for your work. Skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions, each broken into factors that fit the company's jobs. Mental and emotional effort sits next to physical effort. People skills sit next to technical ones [3].

It rests on what people do. Current job content, checked with the people in the jobs and their managers, not copied from old descriptions [4].

It is scored by more than one person. A small panel with a mix of functions and genders, scoring the job, not the person who holds it [9].

It is checked for bias in its design. Factor definitions and weights are tested against how they treat jobs mostly done by women and jobs mostly done by men [11]. A scheme can be neutral in words and still tilt the result.

It keeps the reason for each pay gap. Where two jobs of equal value are paid differently, the business reason is written down when the pay is set, with the data behind it [6].

It is kept current. New and changed jobs are scored as they arise, so the evaluation still describes the company when a question comes.

A quick check: Pick one mostly female job and one mostly male job in different families with a pay gap between them. Ask whether you could show, from records that exist today, how their demands compare and why the gap exists. If either answer needs new work, the evidence is not ready.

The calls only you can make

Preparing this evidence forces decisions about how the company values work.

Which jobs do you compare first? Scoring every job is the goal. If time is short, start with jobs that are mostly done by one sex and paid differently from jobs of similar weight in other families.

How do you weigh the factors? The directive lets each employer weigh the four criteria by relevance to its jobs [3]. A company of engineers and a company of care workers may weigh them differently. The weights are a statement of what the company values and they will be read that way.

What do you do when a gap has no recorded reason? Close it over time, record a reason that is real or accept the risk. Each has a cost. Which one fits depends on the size of the gap and the evidence behind it.

Do you involve employees? Where workers' representatives exist, the EU directive expects the criteria to be agreed with them [3]. Elsewhere it is a choice. Involving them slows the work down and makes the result easier to accept.

Do you act on US law too? US federal law tests equal work, not equal value, so it reaches fewer comparisons [4]. California asks whether work is substantially similar as a composite of skill, effort and responsibility under similar working conditions. It counts bonuses, stock and benefits as pay [5]. One method that meets the UK and EU test usually covers the US questions as well.

The law and the numbers

  • UK equal value. Work is equal to a comparator's if it is like work, rated as equivalent by a job evaluation study or of equal value in terms of the demands made, by reference to factors such as effort, skill and decision-making (Equality Act 2010, section 65) [1].
  • The weight of a prior study. Where a job evaluation study has given the two jobs different values, the tribunal must find they are not of equal value, unless it has reasonable grounds to suspect the study discriminates because of sex or is otherwise unreliable. The tribunal may ask an independent expert to report (section 131) [2].
  • EU criteria. Pay structures must let employers assess equal value on skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions, agreed with workers' representatives where they exist. Relevant soft skills must not be undervalued (Article 4). The recitals call the four criteria essential and sufficient, weighed by relevance to the job (Recital 26) [3].
  • EU comparators. The comparison covers pay that comes from a single source, is not limited to workers employed at the same time and may use statistics or a hypothetical comparator where no real one exists (Article 19, Recital 28) [3].
  • US federal law. The Equal Pay Act requires equal pay for substantially equal work. Whether jobs are equal depends on actual job requirements and performance, not titles. A difference only in the kind of effort does not justify a pay difference (29 CFR 1620.13 to 1620.16) [4].
  • California. Equal pay for substantially similar work, viewed as a composite of skill, effort and responsibility under similar working conditions. Pay includes bonuses, stock and benefits (Labor Code 1197.5) [5].
  • Next. A tribunal found mostly female retail roles of equal value to warehouse roles, in a claim by more than 3,500 workers. In September 2026 the Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the employer's appeal on basic pay, accepting that recruiting and keeping warehouse staff can be a legitimate aim. It upheld findings on a night premium and paid rest breaks that came from cost saving [6] [7].
  • Asda. In February 2025 a tribunal found that 12 of 14 lead claimants in store roles had shown equal value with some male comparators in distribution, for August 2008 to June 2014. Two roles were found not of equal value. The claim involves more than 60,000 workers and moved to a third stage on the employer's reasons for the gap [8].

This is general information, not legal advice. Equal pay law differs by country and state. Check the rules where your people work.

Our view

We think equal value is proven before a claim, not during one. The evidence that holds up has two parts. The first is a gender-neutral job evaluation of every job, made when nobody had a stake in the answer. The second is a written reason for each gap between jobs of equal value.

We would not defend a gap with job families, titles or descriptions. They describe the structure, not the work. We would weigh mental, emotional and people demands as seriously as physical and technical ones, because that is where bias most easily enters a scheme.

And when two jobs turn out to be of equal value and the market really does pay one more, we would keep the data that shows it, year by year. A good reason with no record is hard to tell apart from no reason at all.

Sources

  1. Equality Act 2010, section 65: Equal work (legislation.gov.uk), checked 2026-10-26
  2. Equality Act 2010, section 131: Assessment of whether work is of equal value (legislation.gov.uk), checked 2026-10-26
  3. Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Articles 4 and 19 and Recitals 26 and 28 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-26
  4. 29 CFR Part 1620, The Equal Pay Act, sections 1620.13 to 1620.18 (eCFR), checked 2026-10-26
  5. California Labor Code 1197.5 (text via California.public.law), checked 2026-10-26
  6. Addleshaw Goddard, report on Next Retail Ltd and Next Distribution Ltd v Thandi and others [2026] EAT 130 (16 September 2026), checked 2026-10-26
  7. Littler, report on the Next appeal (28 September 2026), checked 2026-10-26
  8. Leigh Day, report on the Asda stage 2 equal value ruling (3 February 2025; the claimants' firm), checked 2026-10-26
  9. Equality and Human Rights Commission, Equal pay: How do I carry out job evaluation? (3 September 2020), checked 2026-10-26
  10. Law Society Gazette, report on Ibec's HR survey (23 October 2025; 391 HR professionals), checked 2026-10-26
  11. European Institute for Gender Equality, EU-wide guidelines on gender-neutral job evaluation and classification: Step-by-step toolkit (26 March 2026), checked 2026-10-26

What triggers a joint pay assessment?

A 5% gap in any category of workers can trigger an EU joint pay assessment. Five ways mid-size employers get caught and what a sound position looks like.

UK equality action plans: What to write

UK employers with 250 or more staff face gender pay gap and menopause action plans, mandatory from 2027. What a credible 100-word action says.

EU pay gap reporting: When and what?

The first EU pay gap reports cover 2026 pay. Who files when, what the seven figures count and why the data year is already almost over.

See Resources for every guide and the self-check.