How wide can a posted pay range be?
A range wide enough to cover every possible hire can read as no answer at all.
Short answer: No US state we checked sets a fixed maximum, but Virginia now weighs the breadth of a range when judging good faith. Delaware will from 2027. A posted range should cover the pay you would really offer for that one job at hire. When a range feels too narrow, the ad is usually covering two jobs and should be split.
This is general information, not legal advice. Laws are summarized as checked on 20 October 2026; each one links to its source below.
A range that tried to cover everything
Northwind Analytics is a fictional 120-person data company based in Denver. It hires engineers remotely across the US. Its recruiter has one open role and three hiring managers with opinions about it. One wants a junior engineer who can grow. Another wants someone senior enough to lead a pipeline rebuild. The third wants to stay open to strong candidates in San Francisco and in Ohio at the same time.
The ad goes live as "Data Engineer, Remote (US): $95,000 to $175,000." Nobody had to compromise. The range covers every candidate any of them might hire.
Within two weeks three things happen. A candidate writes that a range that wide "tells me nothing" and withdraws. A senior engineer already on the team, paid $150,000, sees the ad and asks why a new hire could earn $25,000 more than she does. And the company's employment lawyer forwards a note on a new Virginia law that asks whether a range was set in good faith and weighs how broad it is. Northwind has applicants in Virginia.
The range was not dishonest. Every number in it was a salary Northwind might pay someone. That is exactly the problem. It answered the question "what could anyone in this area of work earn here" when the reader was asking "what would you pay me for this job."
Northwind Analytics is fictional and its numbers are illustrative.
Why width is harder than it looks
Width, often called spread, is how far the top of a range sits above the bottom, usually stated as a percentage of the bottom. A range of $100,000 to $140,000 has a 40% spread. That is the only arithmetic this guide needs.
The hard part is that two good goals pull against each other.
The first is coverage. A company wants one ad to attract the widest pool it can afford: People slightly more or less experienced than the profile, people in expensive and cheaper cities, people it might hire one level up if they are strong. Every one of those wishes adds width. Recruiters also worry, reasonably, about posting a range and then wanting to offer above it.
The second is credibility. A candidate reads a posted range as a promise about what this job pays. Current staff read it as a statement about what their own job is worth. Regulators in a growing number of places read it as a test of whether the company was honest about its expected pay. All three readers trust a narrow range more than a wide one.
There is a second source of confusion: Two different widths share one word. Your pay band is the full range for a level, built to hold everyone in that level for several years, from the newly promoted to the long-tenured expert. It is meant to be wide. Your posted range is narrower by nature. It describes what you expect to pay a new hire into one job. New hires rarely start near the top of a band. When a company posts its band as its range, it is answering a different question from the one the law and the candidate are asking. Our guide on grades, bands and levels covers the band side of this.
Finally, width means something different at different levels. A 20% spread is roomy for an entry-level support role, where the job varies little from person to person. The same 20% is tight for a senior engineering manager, where scope can differ a great deal between two people with the same title. A compensation software provider's long-standing rule of thumb runs from about 40% for nonexempt roles to 60% for executives (Payscale, 2018). Those figures describe bands, not posted ranges, which is precisely why applying them to a job ad goes wrong.
Five ways posted ranges go wrong
Each of these looks reasonable from inside the company. Each looks different from the outside.
"We put two levels in one ad"
What it looks like: A posting for "Senior or Staff Engineer" or "Data Engineer (L2 to L3)" with one range running from the bottom of the lower level to the top of the higher one. Northwind's ad was this trap plus the next one.
Why smart teams fall into it: The hiring manager genuinely does not know which level the best candidate will be. Two separate ads feel like extra work and a split pipeline.
What it costs: The range doubles in width without becoming more honest. Strong candidates anchor on the top and are disappointed when they are leveled at the lower step. Weaker candidates expect the middle. Both groups negotiate from the wrong starting point. The company has also told everyone that it does not know what the job is, which is rarely the impression it wants to give.
The fix is almost always two ranges in one ad, one per level, so each number stays tied to a job.
"The range has to cover every location"
What it looks like: A remote-anywhere ad whose bottom reflects pay in a low-cost area and whose top reflects a high-cost city, with nothing to tell a reader which applies to them.
Why smart teams fall into it: Location pay is a policy many growing companies have not finished deciding. One national range avoids the question.
What it costs: A candidate in the expensive city sees an offer at the bottom of the range and feels misled. A candidate in the cheaper area sees the top and expects it. If the company does pay by location, the range hides the very rule that decides the offer. If it does not, the bottom of the range is a number it will never offer, which brings in the third trap. Posting a range per pay zone is usually clearer than stretching one range across all of them.
"Nobody is really hired at the bottom"
What it looks like: A posted minimum that exists to look modest, or a maximum that exists to look generous, while actual offers land in a narrow middle. Ask the recruiter when anyone last received an offer at the posted minimum. If the answer is "never", the range is not an estimate.
Why smart teams fall into it: The range was set once, from a band or a guess. Nobody checked it against the offers that followed.
What it costs: Most posting laws ask for a good-faith estimate of what the employer expects to pay at hire, not a list of numbers it could conceivably pay. California's Labor Commissioner describes the required pay scale as the range the employer "reasonably expects to pay" for the position upon hire. Virginia and Delaware go further and name the reference points a good-faith range is set against: A pay scale, a previously set range, the pay of people already in equivalent jobs or the budget for the role. A bottom no one is hired at fails all of those tests at once. Our guide on what a good-faith pay range is looks at this standard in more depth.
"Wider feels safer"
What it looks like: A company that first posted narrow ranges, received a complaint about an offer above the top, then widened every range afterward so that no future offer could fall outside it.
Why smart teams fall into it: It feels like risk management. If every offer sits inside the posted range, surely the company is protected.
What it costs: The protection is weaker than it looks and getting weaker. Virginia's law, in force since 1 July 2026, tells a court to consider the breadth of the range when deciding whether it was set in good faith. Delaware's law says the same when it takes effect in September 2027. New Jersey's labor department has proposed a rule that would cap the gap between a posted minimum and maximum at 60% of the minimum; we found no record that it has been adopted as of 20 October 2026. The direction is clear: Width is becoming evidence. A range widened for comfort is the kind a regulator or a plaintiff's lawyer will point to. The narrower risk of an occasional offer above the posted top is usually better handled by a recorded exception than by a range that tells every reader nothing.
"We narrowed the ad and forgot the band"
What it looks like: A company does the right thing for its ads and posts a hiring range narrower than the internal band. Over the next year, offers creep above the posted range because the market moved, while the band and the posted range are never revisited. Six months later the posted numbers, the band and actual offers are three different stories.
Why smart teams fall into it: Ads are owned by recruiting and bands by compensation or finance. Each team updates its own number on its own calendar.
What it costs: Trust, mostly. Current staff compare what they earn with what the company advertises. Employees in several states can ask for the range for their own job. When the posted range has drifted away from the band, the company cannot explain either number without admitting it does not know which is real. Washington's labor department explicitly allows employers to post a narrower range when they do not intend to hire across the whole band, so the narrowing itself is fine. The drift is what does the damage.
What a defensible posted range looks like
A posted range is not judged by its spread alone. A 45% range that comes straight from a documented band slice can be stronger than a 20% range nobody can explain. In our view, a sound posted range has these qualities.
- It describes one job. One level, one location rule. If you find yourself defending the width by saying "the role could be either," the ad is covering two jobs.
- Both ends have a source. Each end of the range traces to a band, a budget or the pay of people already in the role. When someone asks where a number came from, there is an answer in one sentence.
- You would hire at the bottom. A qualified candidate who accepts the posted minimum would not be a surprise. If the minimum is aspirational, so is the range.
- Offers mostly land inside it. Over a year of hires into the role, almost every offer sits within the posted numbers. The rare one above the top is recorded with a reason.
- Current staff can read it without alarm. People already in the job mostly sit inside or above the posted range for reasons the company can explain, such as tenure or a wider scope. A range that would put a new hire well above a strong current employee is a pay-equity question to answer before the ad goes live, not after.
- It is wider where the job really varies. Width tracks how much the job's scope differs from person to person. It is narrower for well-defined roles and wider for senior roles where scope genuinely varies, never wider just because a manager wants room.
- It is reconciled with the band. At least once a year someone compares posted ranges, bands and actual offers and brings them back into line.
None of these is a formula. Each is a question a reviewer can ask of any ad. Each points to the decision behind the number rather than the number itself. Our guide on what a job ad's pay range should say covers the wording side.
The calls only you can make
Some decisions about width are not technical. They reflect how a company wants to treat people. No adviser can make them for you.
How much room to promise in the role. A posted range that runs to the band midpoint tells candidates there is growth ahead in the same job. A range near the top suggests there is not much. Neither is wrong, but the choice says something about how the company thinks about progression and it should be made on purpose.
Whether to post the band or a hiring range. Some companies post the whole band because it feels more transparent and because it matches what they tell employees. Others post a narrower hiring range and explain that it is a hiring range. The first is simpler to maintain; the second is more accurate for candidates. Both can be defensible if the company says plainly which one it is doing.
What to do about people above the new posted top. Posting ranges often reveals employees paid above what a new hire would receive. Some companies treat that as earned and explain it. Others slow those employees' future increases. That is a values decision with real retention consequences.
How much risk to accept on outlier offers. A narrow, credible range will occasionally be too low for an exceptional candidate. Deciding in advance who can approve an offer above the posted top and how it is recorded is better than widening every range to avoid the conversation.
The law and the numbers
As of 20 October 2026, these are the rules that bear most directly on width. Each links to its source in the list below.
| Where | What it says about the range | Status |
|---|---|---|
| California | The pay scale is a good-faith estimate of the range the employer reasonably expects to pay at hire [3] | In force |
| Washington | A range runs from the lowest to the highest established pay; open-ended ranges are not allowed; a narrower hiring range is permitted [4] | In force |
| Virginia | Range set in good faith against named reference points; a court considers the breadth of the range [1] | In force since 1 July 2026 |
| Delaware | Breadth of the range is one factor in judging good faith [2] | Enacted; in force from 26 September 2027 |
| New Jersey | Proposed cap: The gap between minimum and maximum no more than 60% of the minimum [5] | Proposed rule; adoption not confirmed |
| European Union | Applicants have a right to the initial pay or its range, based on objective, gender-neutral criteria, before the pay negotiation [6] | Member states were due to apply it by 7 June 2026 |
Two points stand out. No US state we checked sets a fixed maximum width that is in force today. But the two newest state laws both make width part of the good-faith test, which turns a very wide range from a style problem into evidence.
The EU directive does not mention width at all. It does, however, ask for a range based on objective, gender-neutral criteria. A range stretched to cover several jobs is hard to describe that way.
Many employers are still catching up. In Aon's 2025 Global Pay Transparency Study of more than 1,400 organizations, 21% said they publish ranges on all job postings, 48% only where required and 31% not at all [7]. Companies posting thoughtful ranges now are still ahead of most of the market.
Our view
We think a posted range should describe one job at hire and that its width should be a consequence of that job rather than a hedge. When an ad feels like it needs a wide range, it is almost always covering two levels or two locations. Splitting it gives candidates a clearer answer than stretching it.
We also think companies should post a hiring range narrower than the band when that is what they really expect to pay and say so. That is permitted, more accurate for candidates and easier to defend. What it requires is the discipline to keep the posted range, the band and real offers in line with each other.
Widening ranges to stay safe is the one move we would argue against most. With Virginia already weighing breadth and Delaware following, a very wide range is becoming harder to defend, not easier.
Where we help
Our pay transparency work looks at every open ad side by side: Whether each range describes one job, whether its ends trace to a band or budget and whether similar roles are consistent with each other. The entry point is our Job Ad Pay Range Audit, which reviews up to 20 open ads. If you would like to talk it through first, Book a free call.
Sources
- Code of Virginia § 40.1-28.7:12, subsection B(6) (Virginia Legislative Information System), checked 2026-10-20
- Delaware Laws, Volume 85, Chapter 228 (formerly HB 105), § 709C, checked 2026-10-20
- California Labor Commissioner, Equal Pay Act FAQ (Labor Code § 432.3), checked 2026-10-20
- Washington Department of Labor and Industries, Equal Pay and Opportunities Act, checked 2026-10-20
- Jackson Lewis, proposed rules for New Jersey's pay transparency law (secondary summary of the New Jersey labor department's September 2025 proposal), checked 2026-10-20
- Directive (EU) 2023/970, Article 5 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-20
- Aon, 2025 Global Pay Transparency Study, checked 2026-10-20
- Payscale, salary range widths by profession (updated 2018; cited as a long-standing rule of thumb), checked 2026-10-20