What is a good-faith pay range?
Good faith means you would really pay the bottom of the range you post. It is shown by evidence, not by intentions.
Short answer: A good-faith pay range is the range you really expect to pay a new hire for that one job at the time you post it. Most US posting laws use the idea without setting a number. In practice it is judged by evidence: Where each end of the range came from, whether recent offers fit inside it and whether you would hire at the bottom today.
This is general information, not legal advice. Laws are summarized as checked on 20 October 2026; each one links to its source below.
A range nobody could explain
Northwind Analytics is a fictional 120-person data company based in Denver. It hires across the US. In March its recruiter opened a requisition for a Customer Success Manager and posted it at $70,000 to $85,000. The numbers came from the previous year's requisition for the same title, which had come from an offer someone accepted the year before that.
By September the role had been filled twice. Both hires came in above the posted top, at $92,000 and $95,000, after counteroffers. The ad was still live on two job boards. A recruiting agency was running its own version of it with the same range. Nobody had changed a number since March.
Then two things happened in one week. A Customer Success Manager who works remotely from Boston, hired a year earlier at $78,000, asked HR for the pay range for her own position. And Northwind's employment lawyer, reviewing its postings ahead of a new state law, asked two simple questions about the ad: "Where did $70,000 come from? Would you hire anyone at it today?"
Nobody at Northwind had lied. Every number on the ad had been a real salary at some point. But nobody could say who had set the range, when, from what or whether the company still expected to pay it. The range was not a decision. It was an inheritance.
Northwind Analytics is fictional and its numbers are illustrative.
Why good faith is harder than it sounds
Most US pay posting laws ask for a range the employer expects in good faith to pay. The wording differs by state. California's Labor Commissioner describes the range the employer "reasonably expects to pay" for the position upon hire. New York's labor department asks for a range "believed to be accurate at the time of posting." Massachusetts defines the range as what the employer "reasonably and in good faith expects to pay for such position at that time." Illinois guidance asks for "the lowest to the highest pay the employer actually believes it might pay for the particular job."
Read side by side, the phrases agree on three things. The range is an expectation, not a list of everything the company could conceivably pay. It belongs to one position, not to a family of jobs. And it is judged at a moment in time: When the ad is posted, or when the person is hired.
That is where the difficulty starts. Good faith is a state of mind, but nobody can inspect a state of mind. In practice it is judged afterward, from evidence. Illinois says its labor department may examine employer records to decide whether pay was posted in good faith. Virginia and Delaware list the reference points a court weighs: A pay scale, a previously set range, the pay of people already in equivalent jobs or the budget for the role. So a range is in good faith when the company can show where it came from. Believing it is not enough.
Two good goals pull against that. The first is speed. Recruiters open roles every week. Rebuilding a range for every requisition feels like overhead, so last year's numbers get reused. The second is room to negotiate. Hiring managers want the freedom to pay more for a strong candidate. A range that captures today's honest expectation can feel like a promise the company may break next month.
Both goals are reasonable. Neither is an argument for a range nobody can explain. The rest of this guide is about the places where the two goals quietly win over honesty.
Five ways a range stops being in good faith
None of these starts as a decision to mislead. Each starts as a shortcut that made sense at the time.
"The range came from the last offer"
What it looks like: The posted bottom is what the last person in the role accepted. The posted top is that number plus a margin that felt generous. Ask where the range came from and the answer is a person, not a source.
Why smart teams fall into it: A real offer feels like the most honest number available. It actually happened. Many growing companies have no pay bands yet, so the last offer is the only data point in reach.
What it costs: One offer reflects one negotiation: One candidate's leverage, one month's market and one manager's urgency. It is not an expectation for the next hire. None of the reference points the newer laws name is "what we paid last time." When the last offer was low, the range is low for every future candidate. When it was high, the range invites everyone to ask for the exception. Either way the company cannot answer the question Northwind's lawyer asked.
"We set it when the role opened"
What it looks like: A range that was right in March still runs in September. The role has been reposted, refreshed on the job boards or copied into an agency brief. The numbers never moved.
Why smart teams fall into it: Posting systems make reposting effortless. Nobody owns the question "is this range still true?" once the ad is live. Recruiters change the text and the location tags. Pay feels like someone else's field.
What it costs: Good faith is tied to a moment. New York asks for a range that is accurate at the time of posting. Massachusetts asks what the employer expects to pay "at that time." A reposted ad is a new moment. If the company has since hired two people above the top, as Northwind did, its own offers show that it no longer expects to pay that range. The stale ad is now evidence against it.
"The ad is fine. The offers are where we flex."
What it looks like: Posted ranges look tidy, but actual offers regularly land above the top, sometimes below the bottom. Each exception has a story. Nobody has looked at them together.
Why smart teams fall into it: Recruiting measures time to fill and acceptance rates. Few teams measure how offers compare with the posted range. Every exception feels like a one-off.
What it costs: The pattern of offers is the clearest evidence of what a company really expects to pay. A regulator, a lawyer or a rejected applicant can compare the ad with the hires behind it. When most offers sit outside the posted numbers, the ad was not an expectation. There is also a cost inside the company. The people hired above the range are now paid more than colleagues who accepted the posted numbers. That is a pay equity question the company will meet later, usually at a worse moment. Our guide on auditing job ads for pay ranges looks at what a review of postings tends to find.
"We'll fix it if someone complains"
What it looks like: The company knows some ranges are rough. The plan is to correct them if an applicant or a regulator raises one.
Why smart teams fall into it: Some laws do soften the first mistake. Washington amended its law in 2025: Until 27 July 2027, an employer that corrects a posting within five business days of written notice avoids damages for it. Massachusetts gives a warning for a first offense. It is tempting to read those as permission to wait.
What it costs: The softening is narrower than it looks. Washington's correction window needs written notice first, applies posting by posting and ends in July 2027. After the first offense the costs climb: Illinois fines run up to $10,000 for a third offense on an active posting and Washington's statutory damages run from $100 to $5,000 per violation. The bigger cost is not the fine. A range published without a basis is a public record of what the company said a job was worth. Employees use it, applicants use it and so do lawyers in pay disputes that have nothing to do with the ad.
"We only wrote it for applicants"
What it looks like: The range was built with candidates in mind: Attractive at the top, modest at the bottom. Nobody asked how it would read to the people already doing the job.
Why smart teams fall into it: A job ad feels like marketing. Recruiting writes it for an outside audience.
What it costs: Current staff are now part of the audience by law, not only by curiosity. In Massachusetts an employee holding a position can ask for its pay range. Illinois counts the pay of people already in equivalent jobs among the reference points for the range itself. When the posted range would put a new hire well above a strong current employee, as it would have for Northwind's Boston manager, the ad raises a question the company has to answer for that person. Ranges that cannot survive an internal reader rarely survive an outside one. Our guide on what to do when an employee asks about pay covers that conversation.
What a good-faith range looks like
A range is not in good faith because of its width or its wording. It is in good faith because of what stands behind it. In our view, a sound range has these qualities.
- Each end has a named source. The bottom and the top both trace to something the laws recognize: A band, an approved budget or the pay of people already in the job. A past offer can inform the range. It should not be the range.
- You would hire at the bottom. A qualified candidate accepting the posted minimum would surprise nobody. If the minimum exists to look modest, the range is not an expectation.
- It has a date and an owner. Someone set it on a known day and can explain it. When the ad is reposted, that person is asked whether it is still true.
- Offers mostly land inside it. Across a year of hires, almost every offer falls within the posted numbers. The rare one outside it is approved by a named person and recorded with a reason.
- It moves when the facts move. A market shift, a change in scope or a run of offers above the top is a reason to revisit the range, not a reason to keep making exceptions.
- It is the same everywhere the job appears. The company's careers page, the job boards and any agency running the role all show one range. Massachusetts counts recruitment done through a third party as a posting by the employer.
- Current staff could read it without alarm. People already in the job mostly sit inside the range, or above it for reasons the company can explain.
Each of these is a question a reviewer can ask of a live ad. None needs a formula. Together they turn good faith from a feeling into something a company can show. Our guide on how wide a posted pay range can be covers the width side of the same question.
The calls only you can make
Good faith sets a floor for honesty. Above that floor, several choices are about what kind of employer the company wants to be. No adviser can make them for you.
How much room to keep above the posted top. Some companies post a range and treat the top as a hard ceiling. Others post honestly but allow a small number of approved offers above it. The second is more flexible. It also creates the pattern of exceptions described above unless someone watches it. Decide in advance who may approve an offer above the top and how often that is acceptable before the range itself should change.
Whether to use the full band or the hiring slice. A band covers everyone in a level for years. A hiring range covers what a new person is expected to start at. Posting the full band is simpler to maintain. Posting the hiring slice is often the more accurate answer to the question the law asks. Either can be defended if the company is clear about which one it posts.
What current staff hear first. When a posted range would put new hires above people already in the role, the company can adjust those people, explain the difference or wait to be asked. The choice affects trust far beyond one ad. It should be made before the ad goes live.
One standard or the minimum per state. A company hiring across states can meet each law's wording separately, or apply the strictest reading everywhere. A single standard is easier to run and easier to explain. It is a policy decision, not a legal one.
The law and the numbers
As of 20 October 2026, this is how the laws we checked describe the range. Each links to its source in the list below.
| Where | How the range is described | Enforcement noted |
|---|---|---|
| California | The range the employer reasonably expects to pay for the position upon hire [1] | In force |
| New York | Minimum and maximum believed to be accurate at the time of posting [2] | In force |
| Illinois | What the employer reasonably expects in good faith to offer; may reference a prior range, people in equivalent jobs, a compensation model or the budget; no open-ended ranges [3] | Fines up to $500, $2,500 and $10,000 for first, second and third offenses on active postings [3] |
| Massachusetts | What the employer reasonably and in good faith expects to pay for the position at that time; also given on request to employees in the job [4] | Warning, then up to $500, then up to $1,000; postings within 48 hours count as one offense [4] |
| Washington | The wage scale or salary range; a fixed wage may be stated alone [5] | $100 to $5,000 per violation; five-business-day correction window until 27 July 2027 [5] |
| Virginia | A range set in good faith against named reference points; a court considers its breadth [6] | In force since 1 July 2026 |
| Delaware | Good faith judged against similar reference points; breadth is one factor [7] | In force from 26 September 2027 |
| European Union | Applicants are told the initial pay or its range, based on objective, gender-neutral criteria [8] | Member states were due to apply it by 7 June 2026 |
Two things stand out. The newer laws say more about where a range comes from than the older ones do. Illinois, Virginia and Delaware all name the sources a good-faith range is set against. And enforcement is moving from the ad to the evidence behind it: Records, offers and the pay of people already in the job.
Many employers are still early. In Aon's 2025 Global Pay Transparency Study of more than 1,400 organizations, 21% said they publish ranges on all job postings, 48% only where required and 31% not at all [9]. A company that can explain every range it posts is still ahead of most of the market.
Our view
We think good faith is best understood as a habit, not a test an ad passes once. A range is in good faith when the company can say where each end came from, when it was set, who owns it and how recent offers compare with it. If any of those answers is "we don't know," the range is a guess, however reasonable its numbers look.
The single most useful question is the second one Northwind's lawyer asked: "Would you hire someone at the bottom of this range today?" If the honest answer is no, the range should change before the next ad goes live.
We would argue against treating correction windows and first-offense warnings as a strategy. They exist to forgive honest mistakes. They do not make a range without a basis defensible. They do nothing for the employee who reads it.
Where we help
Our pay transparency work puts every open ad next to the evidence behind it: Where each end of the range came from, whether recent offers fit inside it and whether the same job shows the same range everywhere it is posted. The entry point is our Job Ad Pay Range Audit, which reviews up to 20 open ads. If you would like to talk it through first, Book a free call.
Sources
- California Labor Commissioner, Equal Pay Act FAQ (Labor Code § 432.3), checked 2026-10-20
- New York State Department of Labor, pay transparency, checked 2026-10-20
- Illinois Department of Labor, Equal Pay Act salary transparency FAQ (questions 12, 13, 19 and 31), checked 2026-10-20
- Massachusetts General Laws c. 149 § 105F (Mass.gov), checked 2026-10-20
- Revised Code of Washington 49.58.110, as amended by 2025 c 383, checked 2026-10-20
- Code of Virginia § 40.1-28.7:12 (Virginia Legislative Information System), checked 2026-10-20
- Delaware Laws, Volume 85, Chapter 228 (formerly HB 105), § 709C, checked 2026-10-20
- Directive (EU) 2023/970, Article 5 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-20
- Aon, 2025 Global Pay Transparency Study, checked 2026-10-20