Merit, promotion or market raise?
Three kinds of raise, three different questions. One label on all of them hides what you are paying for.
Short answer: A merit raise pays for how well someone did their current job. A promotion pays for a bigger job. A market adjustment pays because the market moved for the role. Keep them apart on the letter and in the record, or nobody can tell what the company paid for.
One raise, three reasons
A senior analyst at a 120-person fintech company in Denver gets a 9% raise in January. Her manager knows why. About 3% is for a strong year. About 3% is because analysts' pay has moved and hers sat low against the market. The rest is because she now leads two people. The letter says "merit increase: 9%".
A year later there is no market move and no new role. She has another strong year and gets 3%. She reads it as a verdict on her performance. Her manager cannot explain the drop without admitting that last year's letter was wrong. The company and its numbers are an illustration, not data.
Three raises, three questions
Merit answers: How well did this person do the job they have? US employers paid a mean merit increase of 3.1% in their 2026 cycles, against a total increase of 3.4%. Only 4% gave everyone the same raise [1]. Most base raises on some mix of individual performance, position against the market and position against peers [1]. So merit already looks at position in the range. That is fine, as long as it is a rule that applies to everyone.
A promotion answers: Is this now a bigger job? It should follow a move to a higher level, not a good year. A compensation software provider reported a median increase of 8.6% for promoted employees in the first half of 2026 [2]. That is almost three merit raises in one.
A market adjustment answers: Has the market moved for this role? It is about the job, not the person. It usually applies to everyone in a role or family whose pay has fallen behind, whatever their rating.
What mixing them hides
The message. Each raise tells the employee something different. A market fix labeled as merit tells someone they had an exceptional year. A promotion paid as a large merit raise skips the new title and level, so the person is paid for a bigger job they do not formally hold.
The data. A pay review should be checked after the cycle: Did higher ratings get higher raises? Did women and men with the same rating get the same? If market fixes and promotions sit inside "merit", those checks compare unlike things. A team that needed a market fix looks generous. A team that promoted three people looks like it rated everyone highly.
The criteria. In the EU, employers must make the criteria used to set pay, pay levels and pay progression easily accessible to workers. Member states may exempt employers with fewer than 50 workers from the progression part [3]. Each kind of raise has its own criteria: Performance for merit, a level change for promotion, market data for an adjustment. A raise with one label and three reasons has no single criterion to point to. In a dispute, an employer that has not met these transparency duties has to prove there was no pay discrimination [3].
What it means for a company of 50 to 500 people
At this size the mixing is rarely a policy. It happens because one budget pays for everything and one letter template has one line. The fix is mostly labels and records. Each part of a raise gets its own name on the letter and its own reason in the payroll or HR system. A promotion comes with the new level. A market adjustment is decided for a role, not negotiated for a person. Our guide How should you split the salary budget? covers the budget side of the same problem.
Our view
Mixing them hides what you are paying for. Name every part of every raise, even when the total is the same. It costs nothing at the time and saves the hardest conversations later: The strong performer whose next raise looks like a demotion, the review that cannot show performance drove pay and the question from a worker or an inspector that the record cannot answer. Our guide Merit matrix or manager judgment? covers how the merit part itself is decided. This is general information, not legal advice.
Where we help
Our pay review cycle design sets the kinds of increase your review pays, the rules for each and how each is recorded and explained to staff. It is quoted within one business day. Book a free call.
Sources
- Mercer, 2026 actual increase budgets, US (27 April 2026; 756 employers, March 2026 survey), checked 2026-10-27
- Pave, merit increase data for the first half of 2026 (26 June 2026), checked 2026-10-25
- Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Articles 6 and 18 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-26
Changelog: 27 October 2026, first published. The Denver company and its 9% raise are an illustration, not data.