Guide · Pay bands

Equity or salary at seed and Series A?

Equity belongs in the offer. It does not replace a salary band.

Short answer: At seed and Series A, treat equity as a separate part of the offer, on top of a salary you could defend on its own. Equity is uncertain, slow to turn into cash and usually worth less to the person than it costs the company. Using it to fill a salary gap creates pay you cannot explain, post or keep fair as the company grows.

Thirty offers, thirty trades

Picture a 32-person software company in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. It sells scheduling software to home care agencies and raised a seed round 18 months ago. Cash was tight, so the founders made every offer the same way: A salary below what the candidate earned before, plus stock options to "make up the difference". The startup equity vs salary trade was settled one offer at a time. A senior engineer with savings took a large grant and a salary well below her last job. A product designer with a young family pushed for more cash and took fewer options. Two account executives hired a month apart signed very different packages because one of them asked.

The company has now closed its Series A. The board wants salary bands before the team doubles and the head of people is hiring in Washington and Colorado, where job ads must show pay. When she lines up salaries by level, the spread inside each level is wide. Two engineers at the same level are $38,000 apart. Every gap has the same explanation: "They took more equity."

That explanation no longer holds up well. The options were granted at different times and prices. Nobody wrote down which trade each person made. The engineer who took the large grant now earns less than a new hire at the same level, who is getting a market salary and a smaller grant. And none of the options can be sold until the company is bought or goes public, which may take many years.

This is a composite of a common situation at companies this size, not a client. The details are illustrative. The pattern is common because equity at seed stage is usually treated as a currency for closing offers, not as one part of a pay structure.

Why the equity and salary trade is hard

A stock option is the right to buy a set number of shares at a fixed price, the strike price, after they vest. Vesting is the schedule over which the person earns the right to those shares, often over four years. Restricted stock and restricted stock units are other forms of equity with the same basic promise: A share of the company's future value. This guide stays at the level of total pay. The tax and legal mechanics of equity are a matter for your counsel and tax adviser.

Two good goals pull against each other at this stage. The first is preserving cash. A seed or Series A company has a fixed amount of money and a long list of things to spend it on. Equity lets it offer more than it can pay in salary and gives early staff a real stake in what they are building. Many founders also want people who believe in the company enough to take that stake.

The second goal is pay that is fair and explainable. Salary is what people live on and what the law looks at. It is what a job ad must show in a growing number of places. It is the number a pay equity review compares. If salaries at the same level vary widely because of private trades made at the offer stage, the company has pay it cannot explain to its own staff, let alone to a regulator.

The two goals meet in an uncomfortable fact: Equity and salary are not the same kind of money. A dollar of salary is paid every two weeks and is certain. A dollar of option value on paper is uncertain, cannot usually be sold and may take a decade to become cash, if it ever does. Economists who study stock options have long pointed out that the cost of an option to the company is often higher than its value to the employee who receives it, because employees cannot spread the risk the way investors can [2]. In plain terms: A company that trades salary for equity at face value is usually giving up more than the employee feels they gained.

Candidates feel this too. In a 2024 survey of more than 5,000 newsletter readers in tech and product roles, 75% said salary was their top priority when negotiating an offer and 13% said equity [3]. People at early-stage companies were more likely to put equity first, but still a minority. A large stake is attractive to some people at some points in their lives. For most, it is a bonus that may come, not a replacement for pay.

Five traps in the equity vs salary trade

Most of these traps start in the same place. Equity is used to solve a cash problem in a single offer and nobody steps back to ask what it does to the pay structure as a whole.

"The equity makes up for the lower salary"

What it looks like: The company sets salaries well below what it believes the market pays and tells candidates the options more than cover the difference. The offer letter or the hiring conversation puts a dollar value on the grant, usually based on the last round's price or on a hoped-for exit.

Why smart teams fall into it: It solves a real problem. The company cannot pay market salaries yet and the founders genuinely believe the equity will be worth a great deal. Many of them took the same trade at an earlier company and some did well from it.

What it costs: The trade is rarely even. Employee options are typically worth less to the person holding them than they cost the company to grant [2]. They also take a long time to become cash. The median US company that went public in 2025 was 12 years old and the median in 2024 was 14 [1]. A seed-stage employee who joins today may wait that long for liquidity, or longer, or see the options expire unused. Meanwhile the salary gap is paid in full, every month. When the company later builds bands, the "discounted" salaries sit at the bottom or below them and there is no clean way to bring them up without a cost nobody budgeted for. People also remember what they were told the equity was worth. If the value never comes, the trust cost lands on the founders.

"Let every candidate pick their own mix"

What it looks like: Each candidate is offered a menu: More salary and fewer options, or less salary and more options. Some companies make it formal with two or three set packages per role. Most do it informally, one negotiation at a time.

Why smart teams fall into it: It looks flexible and respectful. People's needs really do differ. A candidate with savings and no dependents can afford risk that a candidate with a mortgage cannot. Letting them choose looks like treating them as adults.

What it costs: Over time, salaries at the same level spread according to each person's wealth, risk appetite and willingness to negotiate, not according to the job. Those factors are not neutral. Who can afford to take less cash often tracks family circumstances, age and existing wealth. A salary gap explained by "she chose more equity" is only as sound as the choice was. If the choice was offered to some people and not others, or framed differently for different candidates, the gap becomes hard to defend. US equal pay guidance treats stock options as part of compensation, not as something outside it [7]. The EU pay transparency directive also defines pay to include any consideration "in cash or in kind" [8]. A review that looks only at salary may miss the equity side of the trade. A review that looks at both will ask why the trades differed. Our guide on which pay gaps you can defend covers why an explanation is not the same as a defense.

"Grant sizes come out of the negotiation"

What it looks like: The number of options in each offer is set by whatever it takes to close that candidate. There is no grant range by level. The founders decide each one, often on the day, based on how much they want the person and how hard the person pushes.

Why smart teams fall into it: At ten people, each hire is a big decision and the founders know every candidate. A grant guide seems like bureaucracy the company does not need yet. Equity also feels like the founders' own to give, which makes it feel personal rather than structural.

What it costs: Two people at the same level end up holding very different stakes, for reasons nobody can repeat a year later. Early grants tend to be large and later ones small, which can be fair, since the early staff took more risk. But when grant size depends on who asked, the pattern is noise rather than a principle. The company also cannot plan refresh grants or promotion grants, because there is no baseline to refresh from. When the board asks how much of the option pool is committed and why, the answer is a list of individual deals.

"Post the lean salary and sell the equity"

What it looks like: The company starts hiring in states with pay range laws. Its job ads show salary ranges well below market, with a line about "meaningful equity" to compensate. Recruiters spend the first call explaining why the posted number is not the real offer.

Why smart teams fall into it: The law asks for the salary range and the company has one. The equity is real and it feels honest to mention it. Founders expect the right candidates to look past the posted number.

What it costs: A posted range is read as the offer. Candidates who compare ads see a low number and many never apply. Current staff see it too and read it as what the company thinks their job is worth. The equity line does not change what the law requires. California asks for a good faith estimate of the salary or hourly wage range and does not require bonuses or other pay to be listed, though employers may add them [5]. Washington asks for a salary range or wage scale, along with a general description of benefits and other compensation [4]. Colorado's guidance asks for a general description of other compensation, which summaries of the guidance take to include equity [6]. In none of them does equity stand in for the salary range. A vague promise of "meaningful equity" next to a lean salary range draws attention to the salary. Our guide on which pay range laws reach small companies covers why a startup's first hire in a new state matters.

"Set the trade at seed and never revisit it"

What it looks like: The company raises its Series A and starts paying new hires something closer to market salary, because it now can. Grants for new hires are smaller, because the shares are worth more. The early staff stay on the salaries they accepted when cash was scarce.

Why smart teams fall into it: The early employees agreed to the trade and nobody has complained. Raising their salaries costs money the round was meant for. The founders also see the early staff's larger grants as already rewarding them.

What it costs: Within a year, the people who took the most risk earn the lowest salaries at their level. New hires notice the gap in the other direction: They see colleagues with far larger stakes doing the same work. Both groups have a grievance and both are right. The salary gap is visible every payday. The equity advantage is invisible until an exit that may be years away. Early staff who leave at this point often take their vested options with them or let them lapse. The company loses the people it most wanted to keep. The seed-stage trade was a reasonable answer to a cash problem. Once the cash problem is gone, the trade needs a decision of its own.

What a sound equity and salary offer looks like

A sound offer at seed and Series A is not one with a particular ratio of cash to equity. It is one where each part does its own job and the company could explain both to the person, to their colleagues and to a reviewer. Several qualities set it apart.

The salary stands on its own. Each level has a salary band set for the market the company actually hires from, at the stage it is at. Our guide on first salary bands at 40 people covers why simple bands work at this size. A company may choose to sit below the market on salary while it is small, but it does so by placing the whole band lower, on purpose, for everyone at that level. It does not discount one person's salary in exchange for their grant. Where benchmarking is part of the work, we do not provide market data. We use the data the client has or buys.

Equity has its own range by level. Grants follow a range for each level and stage, set by the founders and the board. Inside the range there is room for judgment. Outside it, there is a recorded reason. Early grants can be larger to reflect early risk, but the size follows the stage, not the strength of the negotiation.

Any choice is offered on the same terms. If the company lets people trade some salary for more equity, the trade is offered to everyone at a level, on the same terms, in writing. The salary never goes below the band minimum, whatever the person chooses. The choice and its terms are recorded, so a later review can see that the gap came from an offer made equally.

The offer explains equity without selling it. The offer says what the person is getting: The number of shares or units, the vesting schedule and what has to happen for them to be worth anything. It does not put a dollar value on the grant based on a hoped-for outcome. People who join knowing what equity is and is not are less likely to feel misled later.

Each funding round triggers a review. When cash arrives, the company looks again at the early salaries and decides, on purpose, what to do about them. Some bring early staff up to the band. Some phase it in over a year. Some decide the early grants cover it and say so. What matters is that the decision is made and explained.

Pay reviews see both parts. When the company reviews pay for fairness, it looks at salary and equity together, at the same level, with the trades that explain them. Salary alone is the part the law looks at most often. Equity is the part that explains or undermines it.

None of this needs a compensation team. It needs the founders to decide what equity is for at their company and to stop using it as a way to close one offer at a time.

The calls only you can make

How a startup splits pay between equity and salary says a lot about what sort of company the founders want. These decisions belong to the founders and the board.

How far below market will salaries sit and for how long? Some companies pay market salaries from the start and use equity purely as upside. Others accept a discount while cash is scarce. Both are legitimate. The choice should be one decision for the whole company, with an end date, not a different discount for each person.

How much of the company is for employees? The size of the option pool and how it is spread across levels and stages is a founder and board decision. It sets the limits of every grant range.

Will people get a choice? Offering a cash or equity choice respects different needs but adds risk if it is not run evenly. Not offering one is simpler but less flexible. Decide which before the next offer, not during it.

What will you say about value? Founders are optimists and candidates ask what the equity is worth. Decide in advance what the company will and will not say, so that every candidate hears the same thing.

What do early staff get when the cash arrives? Decide whether early salaries move to the band after a round, how fast and how the decision will be explained to the people who made the original trade.

All of these belong in your compensation philosophy. A short paragraph on what equity is for and how it is shared does more for trust than a generous grant nobody can explain.

The numbers and the law

  • Liquidity takes years. The median age of US companies at their initial public offering was 14 years in 2024 and 12 years in 2025, against 9 years for 1980 to 2025 as a whole. The 2025 figure covers 90 offerings that met the dataset's criteria [1].
  • Options cost more than they are worth to staff. A widely cited study of stock options argues that their cost to the company is often higher than their value to the employees who receive them, because employees cannot diversify the risk [2]. It is a standard reference on public companies. The logic applies with more force to private ones, whose shares usually cannot be sold.
  • Salary comes first for most candidates. In a 2024 survey of 5,035 newsletter readers, 75% named salary as their top negotiation priority and 13% named equity. Respondents at early-stage companies were more likely to name equity [3]. These are the publisher's own figures from a self-selected sample.
  • Washington. Employers with 15 or more employees must include the wage scale or salary range in each job posting, plus a general description of all benefits and other compensation [4].
  • California. Postings must include a good faith estimate of the salary or hourly wage range. Bonuses and other pay beyond salary or wage need not be listed, though employers may include them. Where pay is based on commission or piece rate, that range must be included [5].
  • Colorado. Guidance from the state's labor division asks postings to include a general description of benefits and of any other compensation, such as bonuses and commissions. A 2026 summary of the guidance lists equity among them [6]. This is a secondary reading of the guidance.
  • Equity counts as pay. US equal pay guidance lists stock options among the forms of compensation it covers [7]. The EU pay transparency directive defines pay as the basic salary plus any other consideration, in cash or in kind [8].

This is general information, not legal or tax advice. The rules on equity, wages and job postings differ by state and country and change over time. Check the rules where you hire.

Our view

We think equity belongs in a startup offer and should be explained well. It should not be used to discount a salary. The salary for each level should be one a company could defend on its own, set on purpose for everyone at that level. Equity should sit on top, with its own range by level.

We are cautious about letting each candidate pick their own mix. It feels generous, but over time it spreads salaries by personal circumstance rather than by job, which is the opposite of what a pay structure is for. If a choice is offered, it should be offered to everyone on the same terms and recorded.

And we would argue for revisiting the seed-stage trade at every funding round. Early staff took the most risk. Leaving them on the lowest salaries at their level once the company can afford better is the most common way we would expect a startup to lose the people it most wants to keep.

Sources

  1. Jay R. Ritter, University of Florida, Initial Public Offerings: Median Age of IPOs Through 2025, Table 4 (updated 24 December 2025), checked 2026-10-27
  2. Brian J. Hall and Kevin J. Murphy, The Trouble with Stock Options, NBER Working Paper 9784 (June 2003); Journal of Economic Perspectives 17(3), 2003, checked 2026-10-27
  3. Lenny's Newsletter, Why cash is king (8 October 2024; 5,035 responses), checked 2026-10-27
  4. Revised Code of Washington 49.58.110, as amended by 2025 c 383 (subsections 1 and 3), checked 2026-10-27
  5. California Labor Commissioner, Equal Pay Act FAQ (questions 83, 85 and 87), checked 2026-10-27
  6. Cantrell Law Firm via Mondaq, Colorado-based employee pay transparency laws 2026 (20 July 2026; summary of the Colorado labor division's guidance), checked 2026-10-27
  7. US EEOC, Compliance Manual Section 10: Compensation Discrimination, 10-IV.C, checked 2026-10-27
  8. Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Article 3 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-25

When does a startup need job levels?

Startups raise a Series B with about 45 people now, so headcount is a late signal. Five signals that it is time for levels and what waiting costs.

Which market percentile to target?

Most companies aim for the median, but the market they pick matters more. Five ways the percentile choice goes wrong and what a sound target looks like.

What should a job ad's pay range say?

Candidates read the top as the offer and staff read it as a verdict on their own pay. Five ways a correct range says the wrong thing.

See Resources for every guide and the self-check.