Note · Pay bands · Updated on

How much should pay bands overlap?

Too little overlap forces promotions for pay. Too much makes a promotion worth less than a good merit year.

Short answer: Pay bands should overlap enough that a strong performer can keep growing in their band for several years, but not so much that a promotion barely changes pay. The right amount differs by level and should be set on purpose, not left to fall out of band width and midpoint spacing.

What two public pay structures show

Pay band overlap is the share of one band's range that sits above the starting point of the band above it. Two large public employers publish their structures and they sit at opposite ends.

The US federal General Schedule overlaps heavily. In 2026, a GS-12 employee at the top step earns $99,404, while a GS-13 starts at $90,925 [1]. More than a third of the GS-12 range sits above the next grade's starting rate. Reaching that top step takes time: Step increases come after one, two and then three years of service, so the top step is about 18 years from the first [2]. The overlap is the reward for staying in the job and doing it well.

The NHS in England has almost none. In 2026/27 the top of band 5 is £39,043 and band 6 starts at £39,959. A band 5 employee reaches the top of the band after four years [3]. After that, more base pay means a different band. In February 2026 the government committed to reviewing the role and band of every band 5 nurse, with funding for any resulting salary uplifts [4]. The causes go wider than band design, but in a structure like this the only answer to "I am worth more" is a regrade.

What it means for a company of 50 to 500 people

Too little overlap turns raise requests into promotion requests. When a solid performer reaches the band maximum after a few years, the manager's only tool is a promotion. Titles inflate, levels lose meaning and the next band fills with people doing the work of the band below. Our note on merit, promotion and market raises covers why that label matters.

Too much overlap empties promotion of meaning. If a newly promoted person can land below people in the level they just left, the promotion reads as a title change. People notice when a promotion is worth less than a good merit year.

Overlap is usually an accident. It falls out of two other choices: How wide each band is and how far apart the midpoints sit. Companies set those two and discover the overlap later, often when a promotion would put someone below a peer they now outrank.

The right amount differs along the ladder. Entry levels, where people move up within a year or two, need little overlap. Senior professional levels, where people stay for years and grow in place, need more. One figure applied to every level fits neither.

Heavy overlap puts more weight on each pay decision. Where two levels overlap a lot, the level explains less of the pay gap between two people, so each gap needs its own reason. That matters when pay is compared by group. Our guide on grade, band and level explains how the three pieces fit together.

Our view

We set overlap level by level, from how long people should be able to grow at each level, rather than accepting whatever the band arithmetic produces. Then we test it against one behavior: How many of last year's promotion requests were really pay requests. If most were, the bands are too tight. If promotions barely moved pay, they are too loose. People who outgrow the top of a band are a separate question, covered in paid above the band maximum.

Sources

  1. US Office of Personnel Management, Salary Table 2026-GS (effective January 2026), GS-12 step 10 and GS-13 step 1, checked 2026-10-31
  2. 5 CFR 531.405, Waiting periods for within-grade increases, paragraph (a)(1) (Legal Information Institute), checked 2026-10-31
  3. NHS Employers, Pay scales for 2026/27 (12 February 2026, effective 1 April 2026), annual pay scales table, bands 5 and 6, checked 2026-10-31
  4. UK Government, Nurses to benefit from boost to graduate pay and job progression (11 February 2026), checked 2026-10-31

Grade vs band vs level: What does each one do?

Grade, band and level sound alike but decide different things. Five ways the three get mixed up and what a structure you can explain rests on.

Broadbands: When do they help?

Wide bands move pay decisions to managers. Five traps with broadbands and when they are worth the cost: Levels underneath, reference points inside.

Paid above the band maximum: Now what?

When pay sits above the band maximum, the answer depends on why. Five ways companies mishandle it and four honest options that hold up.

See Resources for every guide and the self-check.