Cleaning up founder-set salaries
Every salary made sense on the day it was agreed. Fix the rules first, then the people.
Short answer: Founder-set salaries are rarely wrong one by one. They are inconsistent, because each one was agreed as a separate deal. Fix the system first: Levels and ranges built from the jobs, everyone placed against them and one rule for each kind of case. Then handle individuals. Fixing the loudest cases first turns a cleanup into a round of negotiations.
The spreadsheet with a notes column
Picture an 85-person company in Madison that makes inventory software for independent pharmacies. For its first five years, the founder set every salary. Each one was agreed in a conversation, usually over coffee, with whatever the founder knew about the person, the market and the bank balance that week. Some people got more cash and less equity. Some got less cash and a promise.
The company has just closed its Series B and hired its first head of people. On day three she opens the payroll export. Two customer success managers with the same job and similar results are paid $68,000 and $94,000. The first engineer, who wrote most of the product, earns $118,000. Two engineers hired last quarter earn $150,000 each. A sales lead the founder knew from a previous company earns more than the vice president he reports to. The spreadsheet has a notes column. It contains entries like "promised review after the round" and "agreed to revisit when we hit $5M".
The founder's instinct is to fix the three most obvious cases this month, quietly, before anyone notices. The head of people's instinct is to start with the people most likely to leave. Both instincts are reasonable. Both make the problem harder to solve.
This is a composite of a common situation at companies this size, not a client. The details and figures are illustrative.
Why founder-set salaries are hard to clean up
The cleanup sets two good goals against each other. The first is consistency. People doing the same job at the same level should be paid on the same basis and the company should be able to say what that basis is. The second is loyalty. The people with the oddest salaries are often the ones who took a risk on the company early, trusted the founder and were told things in good faith. A cleanup that treats them as data points will lose them.
The salaries are not random. Each one has a history and a reason that made sense at the time. The early engineer may have taken less cash for more equity. The sales lead may have left a secure job and asked for a guarantee. The lower-paid customer success manager may simply never have asked. That is what makes the work delicate. Almost every number can be defended on its own. What cannot be defended is the pattern.
The pattern is also not neutral. When pay is set one deal at a time, it follows whoever bargained and how hard. Federal guidance on equal pay says investigators should consider whether an employer bargains differently with men than with women and that a claim of having to pay more to compete only holds if the employer can show it assessed the market [5]. A company with no ranges and a history of individual deals has very little to show.
The market keeps moving under the old numbers. In one equity platform's data, median salaries for individual contributors at startups rose 6.4% in the two years to February 2026 [8]. A compensation data provider's 2026 analysis of 10.2 million employees found new hires paid up to 12% more than tenured people in the same job in some roles. It called that gap one of the clearest signals of retention risk [1]. At a startup that hired a wave of people after a round, the newest salaries are usually the highest. The people who were there first are the ones most likely to sit below them.
And people already suspect it. The same provider's analysis of more than 327,000 salary survey responses found that 63% of people paid at market believe they are paid below it [2]. In a startup where salaries were never explained, that belief has had years to grow.
Two terms will help. A range is the minimum and maximum a company will pay for a job at a given level. A level is a step in the size of a job, from entry to senior, that applies across teams.
Five traps when cleaning up founder-set pay
"Fix the worst cases first"
What it looks like: The company spots the three or four most obviously unfair salaries and raises them straight away. A structure can come later, once the urgent cases are handled.
Why smart teams fall into it: It feels responsible. The gaps are real, the people are known and leaving them for months while a structure is built feels like choosing paperwork over people.
What it costs: Each fix is made against nothing. Without levels and ranges, raising the customer success manager to $85,000 is just a new number. It is no easier to explain than the old one. The next person who hears about it asks why that case was fixed and theirs was not. The company has no answer except that someone noticed. The worst cases are also rarely the ones picked first. The ones picked first are the ones someone complained about, which repeats the problem that created the mess: Pay follows who speaks up. Early fixes also tend to be too small or too large, because nobody yet knows what the right number is. A raise given before the range exists often has to be revisited once it does, which means a second awkward conversation with the same person.
"The founder will still sign off on each one"
What it looks like: The company builds ranges, but every individual salary still goes back to the founder for approval. The founder knows everyone, so the founder decides where each person lands.
Why smart teams fall into it: It respects the founder's relationships and history. Many early employees joined because of the founder and would hear any change best from them. A new head of people may also not feel able to overrule decisions the founder made personally.
What it costs: The old system survives inside the new one. The ranges become a backdrop and the founder's view of each person becomes the real rule again. People who have the founder's ear keep getting exceptions and new hires learn that the ranges are negotiable if you know whom to ask. The founder also ends up defending every number personally, which is the job the structure was meant to take off them. A founder still has a real role. The founder should own the principles: What the company pays for, where it aims against the market and how big a gap it accepts before acting. The founder should not own each person's place in the range.
"They took equity instead, so they're fine"
What it looks like: Early employees who sit low in their range are treated as a lower priority because they hold more equity than later hires. The cash gap is seen as part of the deal they made.
Why smart teams fall into it: It is often true that the trade was made. The founder remembers the conversation and the early employee agreed to it. Raising their cash now can feel like paying twice.
What it costs: The trade was made at a different company. An early employee who took less cash at 15 people did not agree to sit below every new hire at 85. Equity is uncertain, may take years to be worth anything and does not show on a pay range. The cash gap does. In California, any employee can ask for the pay scale for their own position and the employer has to provide it [7]. An early engineer who asks and finds she is $30,000 below the bottom of the range will not be reassured by her option grant. Early employees also carry the company's knowledge, so losing them costs more than losing almost anyone else. Equity can still count in the judgment. It cannot replace a cash salary that sits below the range for the job. Our guide on equity or salary at seed and Series A covers why equity belongs in an offer but should not fill a salary gap.
"Those promises were never written down"
What it looks like: The notes column is set aside. The cleanup deals with salaries as they are in payroll, not with what people were told about raises, titles or reviews after the next round.
Why smart teams fall into it: The promises are vague, often half-remembered and sometimes contradict each other. Nobody wants a cleanup to turn into an argument about what was said at a dinner three years ago. A new head of people may also not know most of them exist.
What it costs: The people who were promised something remember it exactly. If the cleanup ignores it, they learn that the founder's word did not survive the company's growth, which is a much bigger loss than a salary gap. Some promises will also surface anyway, at the worst moment, often in a resignation conversation. And promises are uneven. They were made to the people who asked, which links back to the pattern the cleanup is meant to correct. The answer is not to honor every promise in full. It is to collect them, decide openly which ones become policy for everyone, which ones are honored for one person and which ones are retired with an honest explanation from the person who made them.
"Clean it up quietly"
What it looks like: The company changes salaries without saying a cleanup is happening. Some people get unexpected raises. Others notice that new hires now arrive on ranges nobody told them about.
Why smart teams fall into it: Announcing a pay cleanup sounds like admitting that pay was unfair. Leaders worry it will start a wave of requests and they want to show results before they talk about the problem.
What it costs: Unexplained raises look like favoritism, because from the outside they are indistinguishable from the old system. People compare, especially at a company small enough for everyone to know everyone. Silence also leaves each person to explain their own number to themselves and most people already suspect they are underpaid [2]. Research on pay raise decisions found that the fairness of the process drives trust in the supervisor and commitment to the organization, separately from how people feel about the amount [3]. A cleanup is the one moment a startup can show people how pay will be decided from now on. Doing it quietly wastes that moment. Saying that a cleanup is happening, why and when people will hear about their own position does not admit fault. It shows there is now a system.
What a good founder-pay cleanup looks like
A good cleanup does not make every salary right at once. It replaces a set of individual deals with a system people can understand, then brings individual salaries into it at a pace the company can afford. At 50 to 500 people, the cleanups that hold up share these qualities.
The structure was built from the jobs, not the people. Levels and ranges describe what each job is worth, whoever holds it today. If the ranges were drawn around current salaries, they inherit the inconsistency they are meant to fix. Our guide on your first salary bands at 40 people covers why simple bands now beat a perfect structure later.
Nobody's number changed before the structure existed. Urgent cases can be flagged early, but the decision waits until there is a range to make it against. That wait is usually weeks, not months.
Cases are sorted before they are decided. Most founder-set salaries fall into a handful of kinds: Below the range, above the range, inside the range but out of line with peers and those carrying a promise. Each kind gets one rule and the rule is applied to everyone in it. Individual judgment comes after the rule, not instead of it.
Gaps are closed by raising, not cutting. Where an unfair gap exists between men and women doing equal work, federal law does not allow it to be fixed by lowering anyone's pay [6]. Even where the law does not apply, cuts are rarely worth the trust they cost. People above the range are handled by a written rule. Our guide on pay above the band maximum covers the honest options.
The cost and the timeline are set openly. Few startups can close every gap in one cycle. A good cleanup says how much it will spend, over how many cycles and in what order. Our guide on fixing pay gaps on a tight budget looks at why a known gap needs either a reason or a date.
The pattern is checked by group. Before anything is announced, the proposed changes are checked by gender and by team. A cleanup that mostly raises one group may be correcting a real pattern. It should be a pattern the company understands and can explain.
Each person hears their own position from their manager. They hear where they sit, why and what changes. Early employees hear it first and from someone they trust.
The founder's role changed. The founder sets the principles and steps back from individual numbers. That is visible to everyone, because it is the clearest sign the old system has ended.
The calls only you can make
How fast to close the gaps. One cycle is cleaner and more expensive. Two or three cycles are affordable but leave people waiting. The answer depends on your cash, your retention risk and how visible the gaps already are.
Which promises to keep. Some were reasonable and should become policy. Some were made to one person and should be honored for that person. Some cannot be kept and someone has to say so. Only the company can decide how much of the founder's word it is willing to carry forward.
How much equity counts. Whether a larger grant justifies a salary lower in the range is a philosophy call, as is for how long. Whatever you decide, apply it to everyone with a similar grant, not only to the people who raise it.
How much to share. Telling each person their range makes the cleanup easier to trust and commits you to ranges you are ready to defend. In the EU, the criteria for setting pay and pay progression must be accessible to workers anyway [9].
What the founder still decides. Some founders keep approval of senior hires. Some keep nothing beyond the principles. Either can work if it is stated and kept.
The data and the law
- New hires and tenured staff. A compensation data provider's 2026 analysis of HR system data covering 4,500 organizations and 10.2 million employees, effective May 2026, found new-hire premiums of up to 12% over tenured peers in some roles. Across roles where new hires had the advantage, the average gap was 3.6%. Across roles where tenured staff had the advantage, it was 6.1% [1]. These are the provider's own figures.
- What people believe about their pay. The same provider's analysis of 327,583 salary survey responses from 2021 to 2025 found that 63% of people paid at market and 47% of those paid above market believe they are paid below market [2].
- Process and trust. A study of 217 employees' reactions to pay raise decisions found that the fairness of the amount explained more of their satisfaction with pay, while the fairness of the process explained more of their trust in their supervisor and their commitment to the organization [3]. This study is older than the others here. We cite it because its finding is the basis of most later research on pay fairness.
- Structure at companies this size. A survey of 525 organizations fielded from November to December 2025 found that only half have a formal job architecture. Nearly 75% of HR professionals believe employees are paid fairly, but only 44% believe employees see it that way [4].
- Startup salaries. In one equity management platform's data on the companies that use it, median salaries for individual contributors rose 6.4% from January 2024 to February 2026 [8].
- United States, equal pay. The Equal Pay Act bars paying men and women differently for equal work unless the difference rests on seniority, merit, production or a factor other than sex. An employer paying an unlawful difference may not reduce anyone's wage to comply [6]. Federal guidance says market value counts as a factor other than sex only if the employer proves it assessed the market, that prior salary cannot by itself justify a disparity and that investigators should consider whether an employer bargains differently with men than with women [5].
- California. On request, an employer must give an employee the pay scale for their position [7].
- European Union. The pay transparency directive requires the criteria used to set pay, pay levels and pay progression to be easily accessible to workers, objective and gender-neutral (Article 6). Member states may exempt employers with fewer than 50 workers from the pay progression part. Workers can ask in writing for their own pay level and average pay levels by sex for workers doing the same work or work of equal value (Article 7) [9].
This is general information, not legal advice. Rules and their national versions differ. Check the rules where you employ people.
Our view
We think founder-set salaries should be fixed as a system before they are fixed as cases. Every salary in a founder's spreadsheet had a reason. The problem is that the reasons were different for each person and nobody can see them. Fixing individual cases first keeps that problem alive, because each fix becomes one more deal.
So we would build the levels and ranges from the jobs, place everyone against them, sort the cases into a few kinds and decide one rule for each. Then we would turn to people, starting with the early employees, in conversations that explain where each person stands and what happens next. The founder's promises get collected and answered, not forgotten. Done in that order, most people come out of a cleanup trusting pay more than they did before it, even those whose salary barely moved.
Where we help
Our pay bands work builds levels and ranges from your jobs, places every current salary against them and sorts the gaps into a few kinds with a proposed rule and cost for each, checked by gender and by team. The starting point is pay bands and structures, quoted within one business day. If a conversation would help first, Book a free call.
Sources
- Payscale, 2026 Flight Risk Report, press release (16 June 2026; 4,500 organizations and 10.2 million employees, data effective May 2026), checked 2026-10-30
- Payscale, 2025 Fair Pay Impact Report (327,583 salary survey responses, January 2021 to January 2025), p. 3, checked 2026-10-29
- Folger and Konovsky, Effects of procedural and distributive justice on reactions to pay raise decisions, Academy of Management Journal 32(1), 1989, pp. 115 to 130 (abstract), checked 2026-10-29
- Salary.com, 2026 State of Pay and Compensation Practices (525 organizations, November to December 2025), checked 2026-10-30
- EEOC Compliance Manual, Section 10: Compensation Discrimination, 10-IV.F.2.g (market factors and prior salary), checked 2026-10-30
- 29 U.S.C. 206(d)(1), Equal Pay Act (Cornell Legal Information Institute), checked 2026-10-30
- California Labor Commissioner, Equal Pay Act FAQ (questions 46 and 77; Labor Code § 432.3), checked 2026-10-30
- Carta, State of Startup Compensation H2 2025 (Ashley Neville and Kevin Dowd, 4 May 2026), checked 2026-10-28
- Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Articles 6 and 7 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-21