Note · Comp policy · Updated on

Do we need a compensation committee?

Below about 200 people, the gap is rarely a missing committee. It is that no one checks the person who decides.

Short answer: Usually not yet. A formal compensation committee is a listed-company requirement. Below about 200 people, a private company needs one named person who decides pay, one person who checks the decisions that matter and a written record. Executive pay and equity stay with the board.

Who has to have a compensation committee?

US listed companies. SEC rules require stock exchanges to set standards for listed companies' compensation committees: Members sit on the board, are independent and can hire their own advisers. Smaller reporting companies and controlled companies are exempt from that rule [1].

Private companies. No rule requires one. Under Delaware law, which governs many US startups, the board manages the company and may set up committees of one or more directors to use its powers [2]. Investor agreements sometimes ask for a committee. The law does not.

Equity is still a board decision. A Delaware board can hand option grants to a person or body, but only within limits it sets: A maximum number of shares, a time window and a minimum price. No one can grant options to themselves [3]. So the board stays in charge of equity whether or not a committee exists.

US nonprofits are different. Executive pay is presumed reasonable, unless the IRS shows otherwise, when a body with no conflicts approves it in advance, relies on comparable pay data and documents its reasons at the time [4]. That body is a committee in all but name and is worth setting up early.

What it means for a company of 50 to 500 people

A committee of the people who decide is not a check. If the committee is the CEO and a cofounder, it approves their own decisions. What matters is one person outside the decision who sees it before it is final.

The board already decides the big things. Executive pay, the option pool and grants go to the board. A separate committee earns its place when the board's agenda is too full to look at pay properly, usually after outside investors join and the leadership team grows.

The gap is usually below the board. Offers, raises and exceptions for everyone else are where small companies lose consistency. Our guide on who approves a pay exception covers that layer.

Founders setting their own pay is the clearest case for a check. When founders set salaries for themselves and each other, an outside view protects them as much as the company. Our guide on cleaning up founder-set salaries covers what usually needs fixing.

The signs it is time: Independent directors on the board, a leadership team whose pay the CEO cannot judge alone, a listing or sale in view, or a headcount past 200 or so.

Our view

Below about 200 people, a founder or CEO who decides plus one advisor who checks is enough: An investor director, an outside compensation advisor or a finance lead with no stake in the decision. It works only if the rules are written down, with who decides, who checks and what goes to the board. Our guide on what belongs in a pay policy covers where that line sits. Form a committee when independent directors join or a listing comes into view, not because a template has a section for one.

Sources

  1. 17 CFR 240.10C-1, Listing standards relating to compensation committees (Legal Information Institute), checked 2026-10-31
  2. Delaware Code, Title 8, §141(a) and §141(c)(2), Board of directors and committees, checked 2026-10-31
  3. Delaware Code, Title 8, §157(c), Rights and options respecting stock, checked 2026-10-31
  4. 26 CFR 53.4958-6, Rebuttable presumption that a transaction is not an excess benefit transaction, paragraph (a) (Legal Information Institute), checked 2026-10-31

Who approves a pay exception?

Every pay exception is a precedent. Five traps in approving offers, raises and counteroffers outside the rules and what sound approval looks like.

What belongs in a pay policy?

A pay policy states decisions. Five ways policies go wrong, from templates to reassuring promises. What belongs in one and what lives elsewhere.

Cleaning up founder-set salaries

Founder-set pay is inconsistent, not wrong one by one. Five traps in the cleanup and why the system has to come before individual fixes.

See Resources for every guide and the self-check.