Should you go transparent on pay early?
Going early can earn trust the law never will. It works only if the bands you show can survive the questions they will draw.
Short answer: Voluntary pay transparency is worth it when your pay structure can stand being seen. Before you share anything, check that every person's pay can be explained, that the people outside their band are known and funded and that managers can answer questions. Then go in steps, starting with how pay is set. Disclosure shows problems. It does not fix them.
An announcement before a check
Picture a 230-person software company in St. Louis, Missouri, that sells scheduling tools to home care agencies. Most of its people work in places where no law yet requires it to post pay ranges. At an all-hands meeting in the spring, an engineer asks why the company keeps pay secret when its competitors put ranges in their job ads. The chief executive likes the question. Before the meeting ends, they promise that every employee will see the full set of salary bands by the end of the quarter.
The HR lead opens the band file that evening. The bands were built three years ago, when the company had 90 people. Fourteen people sit below the minimum of their band. Two engineers hired last year sit above the maximum, because they had other offers. The customer support team is on a band that nobody can explain. Two analysts who do similar work are in different bands because they report to different departments. Most managers have never seen the bands at all.
Nothing in the file is unusual. What has changed is that it is about to be read by everyone in it. The promise has set a date. It has not set a budget for the people below their minimum, an answer for the analysts or a plan for the questions managers will get the week the bands go out.
This is a composite of a common situation at companies this size, not a client. The details are illustrative. The pattern is common because the decision to go transparent is usually made as a statement of values, while the work it needs is a review of structure.
Why going transparent early is hard
Pay transparency before the law requires it pulls a company between two good goals. One is trust. Staff and candidates now expect to see pay. A company that shares it first gets to tell the story in its own words. The other is room to move. A structure nobody sees can carry exceptions, old decisions and quiet fixes. Once it is shown, every one of those needs a reason.
The trend is clear. In a June 2025 survey of US employers, 82% said they were sharing, planning or considering sharing pay ranges with their own staff and 79% with candidates, whether or not a law required it [1]. In the UK, where no law requires ranges at all, 76% of employers in the same survey said they planned to share pay ranges with employees [3]. In a global survey of more than 1,600 organizations late in 2025, 77% said they were developing or had developed a pay transparency plan, but only 14% had fully put it in place [4].
The same surveys show what holds companies back. 70% of US employers expected sharing ranges to bring significant pay questions from managers, 68% expected them from employees and 53% expected more pay negotiations [2]. Fewer than half shared how an individual's base pay is set and how it progresses [1].
The research on what transparency does is more mixed than either side admits. A 2024 review of the evidence found that different kinds of transparency work differently [6]. Showing pay between coworkers in the same job narrowed gaps but also led to unhelpful peer comparisons and, in some settings, lower average pay, because employers bargained harder when any raise would be seen by everyone. Showing pay across levels gave people more accurate and more hopeful views of where their careers could go. A 2025 study of Colorado's job ad law found that wages rose by 1.3% to 3.6% after ranges appeared, including for people already in their jobs, with no effect on the number of jobs posted [5].
So the question is rarely whether to be more open. It is how far to go, in what order and whether the structure is ready for each step.
Five degrees of pay transparency
Transparency is not one switch. Most companies move through some version of these steps. Each one asks more of the structure underneath it. Each is also harder to take back than the one before. This table is illustrative, not a rollout plan.
| What is shared | What it asks of your structure | What usually follows | How hard to take back |
|---|---|---|---|
| How pay is set: The philosophy and the criteria | A short philosophy and criteria that match what payroll actually shows | Fewer rumors. Questions move from "is this fair?" to "where do I sit?" | Easy to refine |
| Each person's own band and position in it | Every role in a level and a band. People outside their band known, with a plan | Questions about position, progression and promotion | Hard. People remember their band |
| Ranges in job ads | Hiring ranges the company would really pay at the bottom of | Staff compare their own pay with the ads | Hard. Ads are public and copied |
| Every band, visible to every employee | Levels that hold across teams and bands that make sense side by side | Comparisons across functions and levels | Very hard |
| Individual pay, open to all | Every gap between two people explained by named criteria | Close peer comparison. Pay tends to bunch together | Close to impossible |
Most of the trouble we describe below comes from jumping to a later step before the earlier ones are solid.
Five traps in going transparent early
Each of these starts from a good instinct: A wish to be fair, to move before the law does or to answer a question honestly. The damage comes from treating disclosure as the fix rather than as the test.
"Announce it to fix a trust problem"
What it looks like: Staff complain that pay feels unfair, a bad review appears online or a strong person leaves over pay. Leaders respond with a promise to be transparent, often with a date attached.
Why smart teams fall into it: It is a visible, generous answer to a real complaint. It costs nothing on the day it is made and it usually gets applause.
What it costs: If pay feels unfair, some of it probably is. Transparency puts that unfairness in front of everyone at once, with a date the company chose before it looked. The people who were already unhappy now have the numbers to show why. The fix is still needed and now it is needed in public, on a deadline. The order that works is the reverse: Find and fix the problems, then share the structure, then say what changed. Our guide on pay transparency readiness covers why structure comes before disclosure.
"Go all the way or not at all"
What it looks like: The debate is framed as secret pay against open pay. One side points to companies that publish every salary. The other side says the company is not ready, so nothing is shared at all.
Why smart teams fall into it: Bold examples are easy to point to. A middle path sounds like a compromise and nobody wants to defend half a value.
What it costs: Either extreme can hurt. Going straight to open individual pay brings the strongest peer comparison, which the research links to bunching and tougher bargaining over raises [6]. Sharing nothing leaves people to fill the silence with job ads, pay sites and guesses about colleagues. Most companies of 50 to 500 people get the benefit of transparency from the early steps: Explaining how pay is set and showing each person their own band. Each later step should be a separate decision, taken when the structure can carry it.
"Our bands are fine because nobody has complained"
What it looks like: The company assumes its bands are sound because there have been few complaints. Nobody checks who sits outside them, how recent hires compare with longer-serving staff or whether the levels mean the same thing in every team.
Why smart teams fall into it: Secrecy hides problems from the company as well as from staff. Without questions, there is no signal that anything is wrong.
What it costs: The absence of complaints is a result of secrecy, not evidence that the bands are fair. The common findings are the ones in our St. Louis example: People below the minimum, recent hires above longer-serving staff in the same job and two similar jobs in different bands for reasons nobody remembers. Each one becomes a question the week the bands are shared. Our guides on pay above the range maximum and on funding pay equity fixes cover what to do with those findings. The point here is timing. The bill for fixing them arrives with the disclosure whether or not it was planned.
"Managers will handle the questions"
What it looks like: The bands go out in an email or a document. Managers learn about them on the same day as their teams and are expected to answer whatever comes next.
Why smart teams fall into it: Managers handle hard conversations every day. Pay feels like one more topic.
What it costs: Pay questions are different, because the manager often did not make the decision being questioned and does not know the reason for it. In the global survey, only 38% of organizations focused on educating managers and only 12% had set rules for answering pay questions that came from outside the company [4]. A manager who guesses, promises a raise or blames HR sets the tone for every later conversation. Our guide on when an employee asks about pay covers that first answer. Managers need to see the bands, the reasons for the outliers and what they can and cannot say before their teams do.
"Design our own version and adjust it when the law arrives"
What it looks like: A company with no legal duty yet designs its own transparency program. It shares bands by department, uses its own idea of which jobs are comparable and leaves out what it finds awkward. The plan is to adjust once a law applies.
Why smart teams fall into it: Without a law, there is freedom to choose and it feels efficient to share only what helps.
What it costs: The laws coming into force ask for specific things. Some of them are not what a company would choose to share. The EU pay transparency directive gives staff the right to ask for their own pay level and the average pay, broken down by sex, of people doing the same work or work of equal value, with an answer due within two months. Employers must tell staff about that right every year [7]. Work of equal value can cut across departments, so a program built on department bands may need to be rebuilt. A voluntary program that does not match the law's shape gets done twice and the second version can contradict the first. Companies with people in the EU can check where their countries stand in our country-by-country note.
What a sound move to early transparency looks like
Good early transparency is not the most open version on offer. It is the version the company can explain line by line and will not need to take back.
Every person's pay has a reason. Before anything is shared, someone has checked that each person's pay can be explained by the role, the level and the criteria the company says it uses.
The outliers are known and funded. People below their minimum have a date and a budget for moving up. People above their maximum have a recorded reason and a plan. Neither group finds out about its position from a document sent to everyone.
The step fits the structure. The company shares as much as its structure can carry today. Where the levels are not yet consistent across teams, it explains how pay is set and shows each person their own band, rather than publishing every band at once.
Managers go first. Managers see what their teams will see, learn the reasons for the outliers in their own teams and know what they may say, before anything goes out.
What is shared matches what the law will ask for. The criteria, the comparison groups and the pay figures are the ones a future legal duty would require, so the voluntary program becomes the compliant one without being rebuilt.
The promise has no fixed date until the check is done. Leaders can commit to transparency in principle. The date comes after the structure has been reviewed, not before.
The company knows what it will do when the questions come. There is an agreed answer for the most likely questions, a way to escalate the hard ones and a record of what was asked, so the next review learns from it.
The calls only you can make
Some of this is method. The choices that shape it belong to the company.
How far do you want to go? Explaining how pay is set and showing each person their own band is enough for many companies. Publishing every band is a larger cultural choice. Open individual pay suits very few. The right stopping point depends on what the company wants staff to be able to compare.
How fast do you fix what you find? Bringing everyone up to their minimum at once may be expensive. Spreading it over two cycles is cheaper, but the people waiting will know they are waiting. The company has to decide which cost it would rather carry.
Do you show people where they sit in the band? Position in the band is the number staff care about most. Sharing it invites the hardest conversations. Holding it back invites the guesswork transparency was meant to end.
Do you move ahead of the law where you have people in the EU? Most EU countries have not yet finished turning the directive into national law. A company can wait for each country or apply one standard everywhere. One standard is simpler to explain and may mean doing more, sooner, in some places.
What will you say about the past? When the structure is shared, some people will see that they were underpaid for a time. The company has to decide how it will talk about that. It also has to decide whether anything beyond a forward fix is owed.
The law and the numbers
- Most employers say they are moving toward sharing ranges. In WTW's June 2025 survey, 82% of 388 US employers said they were sharing, planning or considering sharing individual pay ranges with employees and 79% with external candidates, regardless of legal mandates. Fewer than half shared how individual base pay is set and progresses [1]. 70% expected significant pay questions from managers, 68% from employees and 53% expected more pay negotiations [2].
- The UK has no range law and most employers plan to share anyway. In the same survey, 76% of UK employers planned to share pay ranges with employees and 70% with external candidates. 73% feared more questions from employees and managers [3].
- Plans run ahead of practice. Mercer's 2025 Global Pay Transparency Report, based on more than 1,600 organizations in 60 markets surveyed in September and October 2025, found 77% developing or having developed a transparency plan, but only 14% fully in place. 38% focused on educating managers and 12% had set rules for answering outside pay questions. The share of organizations disclosing pay ranges in job postings was expected to rise from 60% in 2024 to 94% by the end of 2026 [4].
- Ranges in job ads raised pay modestly. A November 2025 study of Colorado's posting law found the share of job ads with pay information rose by 30 percentage points and wages rose by 1.3% to 3.6% across three data sets, with spillovers to people already in their jobs and no effect on the number of postings or on employment [5].
- Different kinds of transparency work differently. A 2024 review of the research found that showing pay between coworkers narrowed gaps but could lower average pay and lead to unhelpful comparisons, while showing pay across levels and across employers tended to help workers [6].
- Staff can often share their own pay already. In California, an employer may not require staff to keep their wages secret or punish them for disclosing them [8]. In Great Britain, a contract term cannot stop an employee from discussing pay to find out whether it is linked to a protected characteristic such as sex [9]. The EU directive requires countries to ban contract terms that stop workers disclosing their pay [7].
- European Union. Job applicants are entitled to know the initial pay or the range for the post (Article 5). Employers must make the criteria for pay, pay levels and pay progression easily accessible to staff, though countries may exempt employers with fewer than 50 workers from the progression part (Article 6). Workers may request their own pay level and the average pay levels by sex for workers doing the same work or work of equal value, with an answer within two months. Employers must tell staff of this right every year (Article 7). Countries had until 7 June 2026 to transpose the directive (Article 34) [7].
This is general information, not legal advice. Pay transparency rules differ by state and country and change over time. Have an employment lawyer review what you plan to share.
Our view
We think most companies of 50 to 500 people should go transparent before the law makes them, because the law is coming and going first lets them choose the order. But going early works only if the bands can survive being read by the people in them.
So we would check before promising. Find everyone outside their band, explain or fix every gap that cannot be explained and brief managers first. Then share in steps: How pay is set, then each person's own band, then ranges in job ads. Publish every band only when the levels mean the same thing across teams. Very few companies need to go further than that.
And we would design the voluntary version to match what the law will ask for, so it is done once.
Where we help
Our pay transparency work helps companies decide how far to go and in what order: Checking whether the bands can be shared, finding the people outside them and planning the steps and the answers to staff questions. The Pay Transparency Readiness Scan is a fixed-price place to start. See pay transparency for how it is scoped and priced. If a conversation would help first, Book a free call.
Sources
- HR Dive, reporting WTW's 2025 Pay Transparency Survey of US employers (11 August 2025; 388 US respondents, June 2025), checked 2026-10-28
- CFO.com, US employers coming around to pay transparency (13 August 2025; reports the same WTW survey), checked 2026-10-28
- HR Review, Most UK employers plan to reveal pay ranges despite no legal requirement (12 August 2025; reports WTW's 2025 Pay Transparency Survey, UK), checked 2026-10-28
- Mercer, 2025 Global Pay Transparency Report, press release (16 February 2026; more than 1,600 organizations in 60 markets, September to October 2025), checked 2026-10-28
- Arnold, Quach and Taska, The Impact of Pay Transparency in Job Postings on the Labor Market, NBER Working Paper 34480 (November 2025), checked 2026-10-28
- Cullen, Is Pay Transparency Good?, Journal of Economic Perspectives 38(1), Winter 2024, checked 2026-10-28
- Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Articles 5, 6, 7 and 34 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-28
- California Labor Code section 232, checked 2026-10-28
- Equality Act 2010, section 77: Discussions about pay (legislation.gov.uk), checked 2026-10-28