How many job levels do you need?
Fewer than you think. Add a level when the work changes, not when the headcount does.
Short answer: How many job levels a company needs depends on how many real differences in work it can describe, not on its size. Most growing companies need fewer levels than the ladders they copy. Each level should mark a change in scope a manager can see. Too many levels blur those steps. Too few make pay ranges wide and promotions rare.
This is general information, not legal advice. Laws and data are summarized as checked on 20 and 21 October 2026; each one links to its source below.
A ladder built for someone else
Northwind Analytics is a fictional 120-person data company that hires remotely across the US. Its new head of engineering joined from a very large software company and brought that company's engineering ladder with her. It has twelve levels, from new graduate to distinguished engineer. She proposes adopting it as is. It is well written, people in the industry recognize it and it would save months.
The HR lead lays Northwind's 45 engineers over the twelve levels. Four levels have nobody in them and three hold one person each. The top three describe work that does not exist at a company this size: Setting technical direction for thousands of engineers, shaping an industry standard. Most of the team lands on two adjacent levels whose definitions differ by a few adjectives.
A week later, a manager asks for a new level between "Senior" and "Staff". He has a strong engineer who has outgrown Senior but is not doing Staff work yet. He wants to promote her before a competitor does. The finance lead, meanwhile, wants the opposite: Four broad levels for the whole company, so the budget model stays simple.
Then the posting question arrives. Northwind is about to advertise a senior role with a pay range. If the ad covers two levels, the range has to stretch across both. If the levels are too fine, the company will need a separate range for each title in the ad.
Three people, three answers: Twelve, thirteen, four. Each answer solves a real problem. None of them starts from the work Northwind actually has.
Northwind Analytics is fictional and its details are illustrative.
Why the number is hard to pin down
A job level describes the size of a job: Its scope, its impact and how much direction it needs. The level count is how many of those steps a company recognizes from its first professional job to its most senior one. The question sounds like it should have a standard answer. It does not, because two good goals pull against each other.
The first goal is room to grow. People want to see progress at a pace that matches how long they stay. More levels mean more frequent steps, more promotions to celebrate and smaller pay jumps between them. Managers like that: A promotion is the strongest tool they have to keep someone.
The second goal is steps people can tell apart. A level only works if a manager can look at two jobs and say which level each belongs to, for reasons someone else would accept. Every extra level makes the gap between neighbors smaller and harder to describe. Past a point, the difference between two levels becomes a matter of opinion, which means it becomes a matter of negotiation.
Room to grow pulls toward more levels. Clear steps pull toward fewer. The tension is sharper in a growing company than in a large one. A large company has enough people and enough kinds of work to fill many levels with real differences. A company of a hundred or two hundred people often does not. Its most senior jobs are still being invented. The same person may do work that spans two levels at a larger firm.
Two newer pressures raise the stakes. Pay transparency laws turn levels into public pay ranges, so the level count now shapes what candidates and employees see. And people move on quickly. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics reported in September 2026 that median tenure with the current employer was 4.1 years overall and 3.0 years for workers aged 25 to 34. A ladder whose first promotion arrives after people typically leave does not do the job a ladder is meant to do.
Five traps in setting the level count
Each of these starts from a sensible instinct. Each one leaves the company with levels that describe something other than its work.
"Copy a big company's ladder"
What it looks like: A respected large company's ladder is adopted, usually because a senior hire knows it or because it is published and widely discussed. Its level names and count come with it.
Why smart teams fall into it: The ladder is detailed, tested and recognized by candidates. Writing one from scratch looks slow and risky by comparison. Matching a well-known ladder also seems to make hiring from that company easier.
What it costs: A ladder written for tens of thousands of people describes distinctions a smaller company does not have. The empty levels at the top are the obvious cost, but the bigger one is in the middle. Where the source company needed two levels to separate kinds of work it has at scale, the smaller company has one kind of work split across two labels. Managers then place people by feel and the levels stop meaning anything. Candidates who know the source ladder also read the levels literally: A hire who was a level 5 there expects the same scope and pay here. The borrowed ladder ends up setting expectations the company cannot meet. In equal pay terms, levels that do not match the work give little support: The EEOC states that job content, not job titles, decides whether two jobs are substantially equal.
"Add a level to give a promotion"
What it looks like: A strong performer needs a step up and the next level does not fit. Rather than wait, the company creates a level in between, often with a new title such as "Senior II". It feels like a small change.
Why smart teams fall into it: The person is valuable and the risk of losing them is real. A new level costs nothing today, does not touch anyone else's pay and looks more principled than a one-off raise.
What it costs: A level created for one person describes that person, not a kind of work. The next manager with a similar case asks for the same level. Now it needs a definition that fits people who were placed there for retention rather than scope. Over a few years the ladder grows steps that track negotiations. Everyone below notices that the fast way up is to threaten to leave. The underlying problem is often real: The jump between two levels may be too big for the work the company has. That is a reason to look at the whole ladder, not to add one rung for one person. Our guide on grade vs band vs level describes the same pattern with pay grades.
"Fewer levels means fewer arguments"
What it looks like: To avoid fine distinctions, the company sets a handful of broad levels across all functions. Each one covers a wide spread of work and pay.
Why smart teams fall into it: Broad levels are fast to set up and easy to explain. They seem to remove the debate about whether someone is a 3 or a 4.
What it costs: The arguments do not go away. They move inside the level. When one level holds both a capable new professional and a seasoned specialist, the pay range has to be wide enough for both. Wide ranges are getting harder to defend once they are posted. Virginia's posting law, in force since 1 July 2026, tells a court to consider the breadth of a range when judging whether it was set in good faith. Delaware's law does the same from 2027. Broad levels also slow visible progress. ADP Research's analysis of payroll records for more than 51 million US workers found that nearly 75% left an employer before ever being promoted. In the same report, workers surveyed globally ranked career advancement second only to flexible scheduling as a reason to stay. A ladder with too few steps tells people that progress means leaving. Our guide on how wide a posted pay range can be covers the range side of this.
"The manager track is the only way up"
What it looks like: The individual contributor ladder stops at "Senior" or one step above it. Every level beyond that requires managing people. Strong specialists who want to keep growing become managers because there is nowhere else to go.
Why smart teams fall into it: In a young company, the most senior people do manage. A senior specialist role with no reports feels like a luxury the company cannot yet afford or describe.
What it costs: The company loses twice. It gains a reluctant manager and loses a strong specialist, often the person whose depth it most needs. Those who refuse to manage stall at the top of the specialist ladder. Their pay drifts above the band because no higher level exists to place them in. The fix is not a parallel ladder of equal length on day one. It is a specialist track that goes as high as the work the company really has for specialists, which in a growing company is often one or two levels above senior, not five.
"Half-steps fix borderline cases"
What it looks like: When someone does not fit cleanly, they are placed at "3.5", "3 high" or a similar in-between label. The company keeps the official count but quietly runs twice as many levels in practice.
Why smart teams fall into it: Placing people is hard and some people really are between levels. A half-step seems more accurate and avoids a disappointing conversation.
What it costs: Half-steps have no definitions, so the people on them have no description of what moves them up. They tend to collect around the decisions managers find hardest, which is where clear criteria matter most. When pay attaches to them, the company has extra pay levels that appear in no written structure. That is exactly what posting laws and the EU directive make visible. Washington's posting guidance, for example, expects a range for each title when one ad could be filled at several levels. A borderline case is usually information about the ladder: Either the level definitions overlap or the person is ready for the next level and the evidence has not been gathered yet.
What a sound level count looks like
There is no right number that holds across companies. A company of eighty engineers and a company of eighty people across six functions need different answers. What sound ladders share, in our view, are qualities rather than a count.
- Every level marks a change in the work. Moving up means more scope, more complexity, more impact or less direction, in a way a manager can describe without referring to the person.
- Neighbors can be told apart. Two managers placing the same job independently land on the same level most of the time. When they disagree, they disagree about the evidence, not about what the levels mean.
- The top of the ladder exists in the company. The highest level describes work someone at the company does today or will do soon. Levels for work the company may need in five years can be added when that work arrives.
- People spread across the levels. No level is empty for long and no single level holds most of a family. A crowd on one level usually means it covers two kinds of work.
- Families differ where the work differs. A family with a long path of specialist growth may need more levels than one where the work tops out sooner. All of them are tied to one shared frame so levels mean similar weight across families.
- Specialists have a path. The specialist track reaches as high as the company's real specialist work. Pay at those levels is set with the same logic as the management track.
- Progress matches how long people stay. Someone who performs well can see a realistic next step within the time people typically stay.
- Levels change only when the work does. A new level needs a new kind of work, described in writing, not one person who needs a promotion.
A useful sign is how people talk about the ladder. If managers can explain a level without naming who is on it and employees can say what would move them to the next one, the count is probably close to right.
The calls only you can make
A method can lay these choices out. Only the company can make them.
How much progress to promise. More levels mean more frequent promotions and smaller steps. Fewer levels mean bigger steps that come less often. Neither is wrong. The choice says what kind of company this is to work for and it should match how long the company expects people to stay.
Whether specialists can match managers. Some companies let their most senior specialists earn what senior managers earn. Others cap the specialist path lower. The answer decides whether strong specialists stay specialists.
Whether to level every family at once. Starting with the one or two families where the arguments are loudest is faster. Doing all families together makes the shared frame consistent from the start. Companies with EU employees have a reason to think about the second: The EU directive asks employers to make the criteria for pay progression easily accessible to workers.
How visible the levels are. Levels can be an internal tool for HR and managers or a published ladder every employee can read. Publishing them makes promotion criteria clearer and arguments over placement more public. Both are consequences of the same choice.
What to do when someone's level is lower than their title. A new ladder often shows that past titles ran ahead of the work. Whether to change the titles, freeze them or let them fade over time is a call about trust as much as structure.
The law and the numbers
As of 20 and 21 October 2026, these are the points we checked that bear on how many levels a company sets.
People stay about four years. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics reported on 24 September 2026 that median tenure with the current employer was 4.1 years in January 2026 for all wage and salary workers and 3.0 years for workers aged 25 to 34 [1].
Most people leave before a promotion. ADP Research's People at Work 2025 report describes an analysis of 2023 payroll records for more than 51 million US workers: Nearly 75% left an employer before ever being promoted and, among those who stayed, fewer than 1% were promoted by their third year. Its global survey of nearly 38,000 workers in 34 markets ranked the opportunity for career advancement second only to flexible scheduling as a reason to stay [2]. Both figures are ADP's own.
The EU directive asks for clear progression criteria. Directive (EU) 2023/970 requires employers to make the criteria used to determine pay, pay levels and pay progression easily accessible to workers. The criteria must be objective and gender neutral. Member states may exempt employers with fewer than 50 workers from the pay progression part (Article 6). The directive also requires pay structures that allow jobs to be compared on skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions (Article 4) [3].
US equal pay law looks at the work. The EEOC states that jobs need not be identical to be compared but must be substantially equal. Job content, not job titles, decides that [4].
Posting rules reach the levels. Washington's guidance asks for a pay range for each title when one job posting covers several, with a range set before posting [5]. Virginia's law, in force since 1 July 2026, has a court consider the breadth of a posted range when judging good faith [6]. Delaware's law includes the same factor from 26 September 2027 [7].
Our view
We think most growing companies need fewer levels than they first draw and fewer than the ladders they admire. The right count is the number of real differences in work the company can describe today, plus a path upward for the specialists it already has.
The trigger for a new level should be new work. When a company starts needing people to set direction across teams, or to own a whole area alone, that is a new level. When a manager needs a way to promote one person, it is not.
A ladder that matches the work makes the rest of the structure easier. Pay ranges can be narrower because each level covers one kind of job. Promotions mean something because each step is visible. And when someone asks why they sit where they do, the answer is about the work, which is the answer pay laws increasingly expect.
Where we help
Our job architecture work sets a level count that fits your company: We look at the work you have, write level definitions with your leaders, decide the specialist path with you and place today's roles on the ladder. The smallest starting point is our Leveling Starter Kit, which writes levels for up to three job families. If you would like to talk it through first, Book a free call.
Sources
- US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employee Tenure in 2026 (news release, 24 September 2026), checked 2026-10-21
- ADP Research, People at Work 2025: A Global Workforce View, checked 2026-10-21
- Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Articles 4 and 6 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-20
- US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Equal Pay/Compensation Discrimination, checked 2026-10-20
- Washington L&I, Administrative Policy ES.E.2, Job Posting Requirements (issued 3 December 2025), checked 2026-10-20
- Code of Virginia § 40.1-28.7:12, subsection B(6) (Virginia Legislative Information System), checked 2026-10-20
- Delaware Laws, Volume 85, Chapter 228 (formerly HB 105), § 709C, checked 2026-10-20