Guide · Comp policy

Pay decisions the EU wants written down

If staff have to ask how pay works, the criteria are not accessible.

Short answer: Under the EU pay transparency directive, employers must make the criteria behind pay, pay levels and pay progression easily accessible to staff. In practice that means written down: How starting pay is set, what moves someone up a band or level and what earns variable pay. Criteria that live only in managers' heads cannot be shown, checked or defended.

Five managers, five answers

Picture a 240-person logistics software company in Denver, with 60 people in its Italian entity in Milan. It has salary bands, a level guide and an annual review. An engineer in Milan at level 3 asks HR a simple question: What does she need to do to reach level 4 and what decides the size of her raise?

HR checks what is written down. There is a band table with a minimum and maximum for each level. There is a one-line policy: "Progression is based on performance and business needs." The bonus plan says payouts are "at manager discretion". That is all.

So HR asks the managers. One says promotion takes about two years at a level. One says it depends on leading a major project. One points to a cloud certification. One says the budget decides in the end. One says he moved a person up last year to keep her after she had an outside offer. Each answer is honest. Together they show that the company has criteria, but they live in five heads and they don't agree.

Since 7 June 2026, Italy's law has required employers to make the criteria for pay and pay progression available to their staff [2]. The engineer's question is no longer a career conversation. It is a request the company has to be able to answer in writing.

This is a composite of a common situation at companies this size, not a client. The pattern is the point. Growing companies usually do decide pay on reasons. Few have written those reasons down in a form an employee could read and apply to herself.

Why written pay criteria are hard to get right

The EU pay transparency directive puts the duty in one sentence. Employers must make easily accessible to their workers the criteria used to determine their pay, pay levels and pay progression. Those criteria must be objective and gender-neutral [1]. It sounds like a documentation task. In practice it is harder for four reasons.

The criteria are spread across many decisions. Pay in the directive is not only base salary. It includes complementary and variable components [1]. So the criteria cover where a new hire lands in the band, how a person is placed in a level, what moves them within the band, what earns a promotion, how merit increases are sized and who gets a bonus and how much. Companies often have a rule for one or two of these and habits for the rest.

Known is not the same as written. In a small company, everyone knows roughly how pay works because the founder decides it. As the company grows, the knowledge spreads to managers and drifts. The directive asks for criteria workers can access, which means a document they can find without asking their manager.

The criteria have to be true. A written rule that does not match what managers actually do is worse than no rule. It invites the obvious question: If the criteria are skills and performance, why did these two people at the same level with the same rating get different raises?

The law is arriving country by country. The deadline for member states was 7 June 2026 [1]. Only a few countries met it, so the rules apply in some places now and in others later. See our note on EU pay transparency, country by country for where each stands. Italy, Slovakia and Lithuania already have laws in force and they differ in detail [2] [3]. A company with staff in several countries cannot wait for the last one.

Most employers are not there yet. A global consulting firm's survey of more than 1,600 leaders across 60 markets, run in late 2025, found that only 14% had fully implemented their pay transparency strategy. Among employers based in Europe, only 9% had fully put their plans in place [4].

Five traps in writing down pay criteria

Most of these traps come from treating the criteria as a disclosure to produce once, rather than as the rules the company actually uses to decide pay.

"Our managers know the criteria"

What it looks like: Pay decisions follow real reasons, but the reasons are passed on by word of mouth. Each manager explains them in their own terms. New managers learn them from whoever trained them.

Why smart teams fall into it: It has worked so far. Managers are trusted and writing rules feels like it takes judgment away from them.

What it costs: Criteria that exist only in managers' heads are not accessible, so they do not meet the duty as written [1]. They also drift. The Denver company had five versions of one promotion rule. In a pay claim in the EU, an employer that has not met its duty on pay criteria carries the burden of proving there was no discrimination, unless the breach was manifestly unintentional and minor [1]. "Every manager knows how it works" is hard to prove and easy to contradict.

"The band table is the criteria"

What it looks like: The company shares its salary bands with staff and treats that as the answer. Everyone can see the minimum and maximum for their level.

Why smart teams fall into it: Sharing bands is a real step and often the hardest one politically. It feels like full transparency.

What it costs: A band shows the range, not the reasons. It does not tell a person why they sit at the bottom of it, what would move them up or what it takes to reach the next level. Those are the questions staff ask once they can see the bands. The directive asks for the criteria behind pay levels and pay progression, not only the levels themselves [1]. Its recitals describe progression as how a worker moves to a higher pay level [1]. A table cannot answer that.

"Criteria so broad they fit anything"

What it looks like: The policy says pay reflects "performance, contribution, potential and business needs". Every decision can be explained by it. None can be predicted from it.

Why smart teams fall into it: Broad words keep flexibility. Nobody wants a rule that forces a raise the budget can't afford or blocks a decision the company needs to make.

What it costs: The directive asks for criteria that are objective [1]. A criterion that could justify any outcome is not objective in any useful sense. It also fails the employee. Under the directive, a worker can ask in writing for their own pay level and the average pay of men and women doing the same work or work of equal value. If the answer needs clarifying, the employer owes a substantiated reply [1]. "Business needs" is not a substantiated reply. Vague criteria also leave the most room for uneven judgment, which is where gaps between groups tend to grow.

"Base pay only"

What it looks like: The company writes clear criteria for salary levels and merit increases. Bonuses, allowances, sign-on payments and equity stay discretionary and unwritten.

Why smart teams fall into it: Base pay is what people ask about first. Variable pay feels like a reward for the year rather than a structure. Leaders also like the freedom to use it.

What it costs: The directive defines pay to include complementary and variable components, not only base salary [1]. The EU pay gap reports also count the gap in variable pay separately [1]. A company with clear base pay rules and a discretionary bonus can show a fair salary structure and still face a gap it cannot explain in total pay. Discretionary payments are also where the hardest questions from employees tend to land, because they are the least visible.

"We'll write them when the law lands here"

What it looks like: The company tracks transposition and plans to document criteria country by country, as each law comes into force.

Why smart teams fall into it: The national laws differ, some details are still unclear and it seems sensible to write once against the final rules.

What it costs: Three things. First, the duty is already live in some countries. Italy's progression duty applies to employers with 50 or more employees and can be met through the written information employees receive or by reference to the collective agreement [2]. Slovakia requires pay decisions to be supported by objective, gender-neutral criteria [3]. Lithuania gives employers until 31 December 2026 to align their pay systems [3]. Second, criteria cannot be written backward. A rule written next year will not explain decisions made this year and those decisions shape the first pay gap reports. Third, collective agreements may not be enough. One law firm's review of the first laws notes that the job classifications in Italian collective agreements may be too broad to compare jobs, so internal criteria may still be needed [3].

What sound written pay criteria look like

Sound criteria are not long. They are the rules the company already uses, made clear enough that an employee could apply them to herself and a manager could not apply them differently. Several qualities set them apart.

They cover every pay decision. Starting pay, level placement, movement within the band, promotion, merit increases, bonuses and other variable pay. Each decision has its criteria written down, even if the criterion is "set by the collective agreement".

They are specific enough to be checked. An employee reading them can tell what would move her pay and roughly how. A manager reading them would reach the same answer as a colleague. Discretion is allowed, but its limits are stated.

They rest on the work, not the person's history. The directive's own factors for comparing jobs are skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions [1]. Criteria for pay levels should trace back to how jobs are valued, which is why written criteria and job evaluation come as a pair. Criteria such as performance, skills development and seniority are named in the directive's recitals as valid for progression [1].

They are gender-neutral in effect, not only in wording. A criterion can be neutral on paper and still fall harder on one group. Rules that reward uninterrupted tenure, constant availability or full-time hours can disadvantage people who work part time or took leave. Each criterion should be checked against the actual pay data, not only read for neutral words.

They match what happens. Before publishing, test them against last cycle's decisions. Take ten raises and promotions and ask whether the written criteria explain them. Where they don't, either the criteria or the decisions need to change.

They are easy to find. One place staff can reach without asking, in plain language, with a date and an owner. Not a clause buried in each employment contract and not a document sent only on request, unless the local law allows that and the company has chosen it.

They are kept current. Criteria change when the structure changes. Each version carries a date so the company can show which rule applied to which decision.

A quick check: Give the document to three managers and ask each to explain, using only what is written, how a person moves from one level to the next and how a raise is sized. If the three answers match, the criteria work. If they don't, the criteria are still in their heads.

The calls only you can make

Writing the criteria forces decisions that are not about documentation. They are about how the company wants to pay.

How much discretion do you keep? A formula is easy to explain and hard to live with. Pure judgment is the reverse. A workable middle is clear criteria with a stated range of manager judgment inside them. Where that range sits is your call.

Do you use the small-employer option? Member states may exempt employers with fewer than 50 workers from the progression part of the duty [1]. Italy has done so [2]. Using the exemption is lawful. It also means a small team abroad works under different rules from the rest of the company.

One set of criteria or one per country? One global set is simpler and fairer to compare. Local versions fit local law and collective agreements. A middle path is one core set with country notes. The trade-off is consistency against local fit.

Who agrees the criteria? Where workers' representatives exist, the directive expects pay structures to be built on criteria agreed with them [1]. Even where it is not required, testing the draft with a few employees before launch tends to surface what is unclear.

How much do you say about the why? Criteria tell people what moves pay. A compensation philosophy tells them why the company pays the way it does. Publishing both makes the criteria easier to accept.

The law and the numbers

  • The duty. Employers must make easily accessible to workers the criteria used to determine pay, pay levels and pay progression. The criteria must be objective and gender-neutral. Member states may exempt employers with fewer than 50 workers from the progression part (Article 6) [1].
  • What progression means. The recitals describe pay progression as how a worker moves to a higher pay level. They name individual performance, skills development and seniority as possible criteria and allow small employers to give progression criteria on request (Recital 35) [1].
  • What pay covers. Pay includes the ordinary basic wage or salary and any other consideration, including complementary or variable components (Article 3) [1].
  • How jobs are compared. Pay structures must let employers assess whether jobs are of equal value on skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions, agreed with workers' representatives where they exist (Article 4) [1].
  • Employee requests. Workers can ask in writing for their pay level and average pay levels by sex for workers doing the same work or work of equal value. Employers must answer within two months, remind workers of the right each year and give a substantiated reply when asked to clarify. Pay secrecy clauses are not allowed (Article 7) [1].
  • Burden of proof. Where an employer has not met its duties on pay transparency, including pay criteria, it must prove there was no discrimination, unless the failure was manifestly unintentional and of a minor character (Article 18) [1].
  • Timing. Member states had to transpose the directive by 7 June 2026 (Article 34) [1].
  • Italy. Legislative Decree 96/2026, in force since 7 June 2026, requires criteria for pay and progression to be made available, through the written information given to employees or by reference to the collective agreement. The progression duty applies to employers with 50 or more employees [2].
  • Slovakia and Lithuania. Slovakia requires pay decisions to be supported by objective, gender-neutral criteria. Lithuania gives employers until 31 December 2026 to align their pay systems [3].
  • Readiness. In a survey of more than 1,600 leaders in 60 markets, fielded in September and October 2025, 14% had fully implemented their pay transparency strategy and 9% of Europe-based employers had fully put plans in place [4].

This is general information, not legal advice. National laws differ in detail and are still changing. Check the rules in each country where your people work.

Our view

We think accessible criteria means written criteria. If an employee has to ask her manager how pay works, the criteria are known, not accessible. The test is simple: Could a person read the document and work out what would move her pay?

We would write criteria for every pay decision now, including bonuses, not country by country as laws arrive. One core set with short country notes is enough for most companies of 100 to 500 people. It takes weeks, not months, when the structure underneath is sound.

And we would test the criteria against last year's decisions before anyone sees them. Written criteria that don't match what happened are the fastest way to turn a pay question into a dispute.

Sources

  1. Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Articles 3, 4, 6, 7, 9, 18 and 34 and Recital 35 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-26
  2. Littler, Italy implements the EU Pay Transparency Directive: A guide to the final decree (4 June 2026; Legislative Decree 96/2026), checked 2026-10-26
  3. Jackson Lewis, EU pay transparency: Lessons for employers from the first three member states' legislation (June 2026), checked 2026-10-26
  4. Mercer, 2025 Global Pay Transparency Report, press release (16 February 2026; fieldwork September to October 2025), checked 2026-10-26

What triggers a joint pay assessment?

A 5% gap in any category of workers can trigger an EU joint pay assessment. Five ways mid-size employers get caught and what a sound position looks like.

Who approves a pay exception?

Every pay exception is a precedent. Five traps in approving offers, raises and counteroffers outside the rules and what sound approval looks like.

EU pay gap reporting: When and what?

The first EU pay gap reports cover 2026 pay. Who files when, what the seven figures count and why the data year is already almost over.

See Resources for every guide and the self-check.