Skills, performance or tenure?
Every pay system rewards some mix of the three. Pay for time served looks fair and ages badly.
Short answer: Every company pays for some mix of skills, performance and tenure, whether it says so or not. Choose the mix by job family and write it down. Lean on performance and the job's requirements. Use defined skill steps where skills can be tested. Keep tenure for recognition rather than base pay, because pay for time served stops tracking the work.
Three raises, three philosophies
Picture a 160-person company in Chattanooga that runs freight brokerage software and a support desk for trucking firms. Nobody ever decided what its raises are for. Look at a year's increases and three different answers appear.
In the support team, every agent gets a fixed raise each anniversary, a practice the first support manager started ten years ago. In engineering, raises follow ratings and the strongest people get the most. In the operations team, people get a raise when they complete a certification in the carrier compliance system, whether or not their job uses it.
Each answer made sense to the manager who chose it. Together they produce results nobody would defend. A support agent with nine years of service earns more than the support lead who manages her. An engineer who has stayed seven years and been rated "meets" every year sits below a colleague hired last year. Two operations analysts doing the same work are $9,000 apart because one collected more certificates. And when an employee asked how pay works at the company, nobody could give one answer.
This is a composite of a common situation at companies this size, not a client. The details and figures are illustrative.
Why choosing the mix is hard
The choice sets two good goals against each other. The first is predictability. People like knowing how their pay will grow and steps for time served or skills gained are easy to explain. The second is fairness to contribution. People also want pay to reflect what they do and how well, which is harder to predict and harder to explain.
Each of the three has a real case. Tenure rewards loyalty and is easy to administer. Skills reward learning and support development. Performance rewards results. Each also has a weakness. Tenure pays for time whether or not the work grows. Skills can be collected without being used. Performance depends on judgments that can be inconsistent.
The weakness of tenure is the slowest to show. Americans stay with employers a long time. In January 2026 the median wage and salary worker had been with their employer 4.1 years, up from 3.9 in 2024. 30.1% of workers aged 25 and over had been there ten years or more [1]. A tenure step that seems small in year two becomes large by year ten. Meanwhile the market moves on its own schedule. Payroll data for August 2026 showed median pay growth of 7.3% a year for job changers and 4.4% for those who stayed [2].
The patterns also differ by job. A compensation data provider's 2026 analysis of 10.2 million employees found that tenured staff were paid more than new hires in the same role by 37% across healthcare jobs and 28% in customer service, while some technology and marketing roles paid new hires up to 12% more [3]. These are the provider's own figures. One mix rarely fits every family.
Employees read the mix from results, not from statements. A company that says it pays for performance but gives everyone a similar raise each year is understood to pay for tenure. One that says it values learning but never moves pay when people take on harder work is understood not to. The real philosophy is whatever the last three pay reviews did, which is why a mix that is never written down still exists. It is just harder to defend.
Two terms will help. A step is a fixed increase triggered by an event such as an anniversary or a certification. A merit increase is a raise to base pay tied to performance.
Five traps in choosing what pay rewards
"Tenure is the fair default"
What it looks like: Raises follow years of service, either as fixed anniversary steps or as an unwritten habit of giving long-serving people more.
Why smart teams fall into it: It feels fair and loyal. It avoids difficult conversations about performance and it is simple to run.
What it costs: Pay drifts away from the work. After enough steps, a long-serving person can sit above the market for their job and above people in larger jobs, as the support agent in the opening does. The arithmetic is quiet but relentless. A 2% step every year, with no other change, adds up to about 22% after ten years, whatever happened to the job or the market in that time. New hires come in at market rates, which may be above or below tenured staff depending on the job, so the structure becomes hard to explain in either direction. And the steps are hard to stop once people count on them. Under US federal law a seniority system can justify a pay difference, but only if it is bona fide: Set in advance, communicated, applied consistently and actually the reason for the difference [4] [5]. A habit of paying long-serving people more, applied unevenly, is not that. Our guide on spotting pay compression early covers how tenure and market pay collide.
"One mix for every job"
What it looks like: The company adopts one philosophy, such as pure pay for performance. It applies that rule the same way to every team.
Why smart teams fall into it: One rule is simpler to explain and seems fairer than different rules for different people.
What it costs: Jobs differ in how much performance varies and how easily it can be seen. In a support role with clear, testable skill levels, defined steps can be fairer and more motivating than ratings. In an engineering role, contribution varies widely and ratings carry more information. The market also treats families differently [3]. A company with both a support desk and an engineering team usually needs both kinds of answer. Forcing one mix on every family leaves some of them with a system that measures the wrong thing. The consistent part should be the principles and the process, not the formula.
"Pay for every certificate"
What it looks like: Raises follow courses completed or certifications gained, whether or not the job uses them.
Why smart teams fall into it: It encourages learning and looks objective. A certificate is easy to verify.
What it costs: The company pays for skills it does not use and the people who gain most are those with the time to collect them. Skill steps work where the skills are defined, tested and required by the job, such as a technician moving from one certified level of work to the next. They do not work as a general reward for learning. Federal guidance says a skill the job does not require should not be considered when comparing jobs. A qualification justifies a pay difference only if it relates to job performance or business need [5]. Our guide on skills-based job architecture covers where skills belong and where they do not.
"Let each manager choose"
What it looks like: Nobody states what raises are for. Each manager applies their own weighting of loyalty, skills and results.
Why smart teams fall into it: Managers know their teams and a stated philosophy feels bureaucratic at a small company.
What it costs: The company ends up with several pay philosophies, one per manager. Employees can see the differences. Two people with the same job and similar results get different raises because their managers value different things. It also weakens the company's defenses. A merit or seniority system is a defense to an equal pay claim only if its criteria are set in advance and communicated [5]. In the EU, the criteria used for pay progression must be easily accessible to workers and objective [6]. An unwritten mix that varies by manager meets neither test. It also makes every pay review harder than it needs to be. Without a shared answer to what raises are for, each manager has to argue their case from first principles and the loudest argument wins. A written mix does not remove judgment. It gives judgment a common starting point.
"Experience means time with us"
What it looks like: The company treats years at the company as the measure of experience. A new hire with eight years elsewhere starts below an internal colleague with three years here.
Why smart teams fall into it: Internal experience is visible and trusted. External experience is harder to judge.
What it costs: Relevant experience is what the job requires, wherever it was gained. Federal guidance measures skill by the experience, ability, education and training required to perform the job [5]. A rule that counts only internal years undervalues people who joined later, which often means people who took career breaks or changed careers. It also makes external hiring at the right level very hard, so the company either loses candidates or makes exceptions that break the rule. Over time those exceptions become the real policy and the internal rule only binds the people who never asked.
What a sound pay mix looks like
A sound mix does not pick one of the three. It says what each is for, where it applies and how it is measured. At 50 to 500 people, the approaches that hold up share these qualities.
The mix is written down. One page says what base pay rewards, what raises reward and what other tools recognize. Managers and employees can read it. It names the families where the mix differs and why, so a difference between teams is a decision anyone can see rather than a habit someone inherited.
It differs by family where the work differs. Defined skill steps in roles where skill levels are clear and testable. Performance-led raises where contribution varies widely. The principles are the same everywhere.
Position against the market matters. Raises consider where a person sits in the range for their job, so pay moves toward the right place over time, not only upward.
Promotions carry the big moves. Large changes in pay come from a larger job, not from accumulating small steps. That keeps base pay tied to the work and gives people a clear way to earn more.
Market adjustments are separate. When the market for a job moves, the range moves and people in it are reviewed. That is not a reward for anything and is not mixed into merit.
Tenure is recognized outside base pay. Service awards, development, first choice of projects or a share of equity recognize loyalty without compounding into base pay that no longer tracks the work.
Skills count when the job uses them. A skill step requires the skill to be needed and demonstrated, not only certified.
Experience is judged by relevance. Internal and external experience both count to the extent the job needs them. A career break or a change of field is not held against someone whose experience fits the job. Long service is not counted as experience the job does not use, however loyal it was.
The result is checked by group. Each year, someone looks at how the mix plays out by gender and team. A tenure rule that mostly benefits one group, or a skill step that one group rarely reaches, is visible early.
Existing steps are wound down fairly. If a company moves away from tenure steps, nobody's pay is cut and the change is explained before the next anniversary.
The calls only you can make
The weight of performance in raises. Strong differentiation rewards results and asks a lot of managers. Lighter differentiation is easier to run and rewards less. The right weight can differ by family, as long as the reason is written down.
Where skill steps belong. Only roles where skills can be defined and tested, or none. The answer depends on your jobs, not on a trend.
What happens to existing tenure steps. Keep them for current staff, freeze them, or replace them with recognition outside base pay. Each has a cost in trust or money.
How loyalty is recognized. Awards, development, equity refreshes or nothing formal. Saying nothing is also a message.
Whether leaders follow the same mix. Senior roles often lean more on variable pay tied to company results. Whatever the difference, it should be stated, so the rest of the company does not assume a different set of rules applies at the top.
How much to publish. The principles only, or the steps and criteria too. More detail is easier to trust and harder to change.
The data and the law
- Tenure. In January 2026 median employee tenure was 4.1 years, up from 3.9 in January 2024. 30.1% of wage and salary workers aged 25 and over had ten or more years with their current employer [1].
- Stayers and changers. ADP's National Employment Report for August 2026 showed median year-over-year gross pay growth of 7.3% for job changers and 4.4% for job stayers [2]. These are national payroll figures, not pay for matched jobs.
- Tenure and new-hire pay by job. A compensation data provider's 2026 analysis of HR system data on 10.2 million employees found tenure advantages of 37% across healthcare jobs and 28% in customer service. Some roles paid new hires up to 12% more [3]. These are the provider's own figures.
- United States, equal pay. The Equal Pay Act allows pay differences based on a seniority system, a merit system, a system measuring quantity or quality of production or a factor other than sex [4]. Federal guidance says such a system is a defense only if it was set in advance, communicated, applied consistently and is in fact the basis for the difference. Skill is measured by what the job requires. Qualifications justify a difference only if related to job performance or business need [5].
- European Union. The criteria used to set pay, pay levels and pay progression must be easily accessible to workers, objective and gender-neutral (Article 6) [6].
This is general information, not legal advice. Rules and their national versions differ. Check the rules where you employ people.
Our view
We think every company should decide its mix on purpose, by job family. Then it should write the mix down. Most of the problems in the opening came from three good intentions applied without a shared rule.
For most companies of this size we would lean on the job's requirements and performance for base pay, use defined skill steps only where skills can be tested and the job needs them. Tenure we would recognize in other ways. Tenure pay looks fair in year two and hard to defend in year ten. A mix built on the work keeps making sense as people stay. It also lets the company tell anyone who asks why their pay moved the way it did.
Where we help
Our pay policy work writes down what your pay rewards, family by family. It also checks how the current mix plays out by group, including any tenure steps or certificate raises already in place. The starting point is compensation policy, quoted within one business day. If a conversation would help first, Book a free call.
Sources
- US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employee Tenure in January 2026 (news release, 24 September 2026), checked 2026-10-30
- ADP, National Employment Report for August 2026 (2 September 2026), checked 2026-10-29
- Payscale, 2026 Flight Risk Report, press release (16 June 2026; 4,500 organizations and 10.2 million employees, data effective May 2026), checked 2026-10-30
- 29 U.S.C. 206(d)(1), Equal Pay Act (Cornell Legal Information Institute), checked 2026-10-30
- US EEOC, Compliance Manual Section 10: Compensation Discrimination, 10-IV.E.2.a, 10-IV.F.1 and 10-IV.F.2, checked 2026-10-30
- Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Article 6 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-28