Compa-ratio or range penetration?
Two numbers describe where someone's pay sits. They often disagree. The disagreement is useful.
Short answer: Compa-ratio shows where pay sits against the rate you chose for the job. Range penetration shows how far pay has moved through the band. Use compa-ratio for market position and pay equity checks, penetration for raises and progression. Read both before you act.
The number
0.90. Picture three employees, each paid 10% below the midpoint of their band, so each has a compa-ratio of 0.90. What that means depends on how wide each band is. The table shows the same pay in three bands, with spread measured as how far the maximum sits above the minimum.
| Band spread | Compa-ratio | Range penetration |
|---|---|---|
| 20% | 0.90 | Below the minimum |
| 40% | 0.90 | 20% |
| 80% | 0.90 | About 33% |
Same compa-ratio, three different stories. Which number you look at changes who gets the bigger raise, who looks underpaid and what you tell an employee who asks.
Two numbers, two questions
Compa-ratio is pay divided by the band midpoint, which is usually the market rate you chose to pay for the job. It answers one question: How does this person's pay compare with what we said the job is worth? Range penetration is where pay sits between the band minimum (0%) and the maximum (100%). It answers a different one: How much of the band has this person used and how much room is left?
Many teams pick one by habit. A compensation analyst at an employers' association noted in 2024 that practitioners use either one "depending on their personal preference" [1]. HR software lets a company build its merit guidelines on either [2]. The choice matters more than habit suggests.
Where each one misleads
Penetration depends on band width. Gaps measured in penetration count differently from one band to the next. For a $100,000 midpoint, 5 points of penetration is about $900 in a band with a 20% spread and nearly $2,900 in one with an 80% spread. Five points of compa-ratio is $5,000 in both. That makes compa-ratio the cleaner first screen when you compare groups across job families.
Both move when bands move, by different amounts. Raise every midpoint 4% in a band refresh. Someone paid at the old midpoint drops to a compa-ratio of 0.96 in every band. Their penetration drops from 50% to about 29% in a 20% band but only to about 42% in a 60% band. A merit matrix keyed to penetration then sends bigger raises to the narrow-band families, whether you meant it or not.
Penetration is harder to say out loud. A compa-ratio of 0.95 sounds close to target. The same pay described as a third of the way into the range can sound low to the person hearing it [3]. Under the EU pay transparency directive, workers can ask for their own pay level and the average pay for the same work or work of equal value [4]. Expect these numbers to reach staff. Pick the one you can explain.
Our view
They answer different questions, so use both. Use compa-ratio for questions about the market and fairness: Where a job family sits against your chosen rate and whether groups doing comparable work are paid alike. Use penetration for questions about the band: How much room a person has left, how fast they should move and whether a band is too narrow for the people in it. In a pay review, read both for each person before the matrix runs. When they point in different directions, the band is often the problem, not the person. Our guide Merit matrix or manager judgment? covers what a matrix keyed to position in range does over time. A compa-ratio screen is a start on pay equity, not the answer. The directive measures gaps in average pay by category of workers [4], as our guide What triggers a joint pay assessment? explains. This is general information, not legal advice.
Where we help
Our pay review cycle design builds the merit matrix on the measure that fits your bands and tests it against your payroll before managers see it. It is quoted within one business day. If the two numbers disagree because the bands themselves are off, our Pay Band Sprint rebuilds them from the market data you already have.* Book a free call.
*We don't provide market data. We use the data you have or buy. No data yet? We help you choose a survey or tool that fits your size and budget.
Sources
- HR Source, Compa-ratio and position-in-range (Joy Lynn Hyer, 29 October 2024), checked 2026-10-27
- Dayforce Compensation Guide, Performance rating and range penetration or compa-ratio matrix (release 2026.2, edition of 15 October 2026), checked 2026-10-27
- AIHR, What is salary range penetration? (Suzanne Lucas; undated, example of 95% compa-ratio and 33% penetration for the same pay), checked 2026-10-27
- Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Articles 7, 9 and 10 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-25
Changelog: 27 October 2026, first published. The table and the refresh example are worked illustrations, not survey data.