What triggers a joint pay assessment?
The 5% gap is only the trigger. Whether it fires depends on categories and records you set before you file.
Short answer: An EU employer that reports its pay gap must run a joint pay assessment with workers' representatives when three things meet. A category of workers shows an average gap of at least 5% between women and men. The gap is not justified by objective, gender-neutral criteria. It is not fixed within six months of reporting. The categories you draw largely decide whether it fires.
This is general information, not legal advice. The directive and national laws are summarized as checked on 25 October 2026; each point links to its source below.
A dry run in October
Picture a 300-person software company headquartered in Boston. Its European entity employs 180 people in one EU country: Engineers, a support team, a sales team and a small finance and people group. The country has now passed its version of the EU pay transparency directive. Under the directive's own dates, an employer of this size files its first pay gap report by 7 June 2027, covering the 2026 calendar year [1].
In October the head of people runs a dry run. The company-wide gap between the average pay of women and men comes out at 9%. That number worries the CFO, but the head of people knows it is not the number that matters. The report also has to show the gap inside each category of workers, meaning groups doing the same work or work of equal value [1].
So she groups the 180 people by the job family and level fields in the HR system and gets 16 groups. In three of them the gap is above 5%. Senior engineers show 6.8%, because two women hired in 2025 came in on lower offers. Account executives show 12%, almost all of it commission. Support specialists show 5.4%, driven by a weekend allowance that only men currently receive.
Then the questions start. Are job family and level really the right way to group people for this purpose? Would anyone accept "she negotiated less" as a reason? Does the company need to agree the groups with someone, given that it has no works council? And if the gaps are still there next June, what happens in the six months after filing?
This company is a composite of situations common at this size. It is not a client and the numbers are illustrative.
Why the 5% trigger is harder than it looks
The rule itself fits in one sentence. An employer that has to report must carry out a joint pay assessment with its workers' representatives when three things are all true. The report shows a difference in average pay between women and men of at least 5% in any category of workers; the employer has not justified that difference on objective, gender-neutral criteria; and it has not remedied the difference within six months of submitting the report [1].
The joint pay assessment is a formal review. It covers the share of women and men in each category, their average pay and variable pay, the reasons for any differences, pay progression after family leave, the measures to close unjustified gaps and whether earlier measures worked [1]. It goes to all workers and their representatives and to the national monitoring body. The labor inspectorate and the equality body can ask for it [1]. Fixing the gaps it finds must include a review of the company's job evaluation system, or building one if none exists [1].
Three things make the trigger harder to manage than the single sentence suggests.
The company draws the lines. A category of workers is a group doing the same work or work of equal value, grouped "in a non-arbitrary manner" using criteria that include skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions [1]. The directive does not hand anyone a list of categories. Each employer builds its own, with its workers' representatives where they exist. Where the lines fall largely decides whether a gap appears.
Two good goals pull against each other. The first is comparability: Groups narrow enough that the people in them really do similar work, so a gap means something. The second is reach: Groups broad enough to put different jobs of equal value side by side, which is the whole point of the law. A support lead and a junior engineer may do work of equal value even though no job title links them. Narrow groups make gaps less likely but can look arbitrary. Broad groups are easier to defend as principled but surface more gaps.
Small numbers move averages. At 180 people, many categories hold five to twelve people. One senior hire, one commission spike or one parental leave can push a category's gap past 5% and back. The directive measures pay as gross annual and hourly pay, including variable and complementary components [1]. So bonuses, commissions and allowances count, not just base salary.
Underneath sits a timing problem. The report looks back at a full calendar year [1]. For a company of 150 to 249 workers, under the directive's own dates, that year is 2026. It ends in nine weeks.
Five ways the trigger catches mid-size employers
Each of these is a reasonable choice from inside a busy people team. Each looks different to workers' representatives, an equality body or a court.
"We'll sort out the categories when we file"
What it looks like: The first report is treated as a data exercise. In May someone exports pay data, groups people by whatever fields the HR system holds and runs the numbers. The categories are whatever falls out.
Why smart teams fall into it: The report feels like the deadline, so the work is planned backwards from June. Categories look like a technical detail inside the report rather than a decision in their own right.
What it costs: The category gaps are not a private working file. They go to every worker and to their representatives. The labor inspectorate and equality body can ask for them [1]. Workers and their representatives can then ask for explanations of any gap. The employer has to give a substantiated reply within a reasonable time [1]. Once a set of categories has been shared, quietly redrawing them next year looks like an attempt to make gaps disappear. The first set of lines tends to become the set the company has to live with. In the dry run above, the 16 groups came from a field nobody had designed for this purpose.
"We'll reuse the grades we already have"
What it looks like: The company uses a structure built for another job. It might be HR system job codes, a recruiter's level ladder or the grades of a collective agreement.
Why smart teams fall into it: Reuse is efficient and it feels safe. The structure already exists, people already sit in it and nobody has to argue about it.
What it costs: A structure built for payroll or recruiting rarely groups work by value. Job codes often split one role into several, which hides equal work behind different labels. A level ladder usually runs inside each job family, so it never compares a support lead with an engineer. Italy shows the opposite risk. Its transposing decree makes the national collective agreements the main framework for judging same work and work of equal value. Internal job evaluation can add to that framework but cannot replace it [4]. Commentators warn that those classifications may be too broad in practice and can produce larger gaps. Employers may need an internal overlay [5]. Either way the company inherits lines it did not choose and may not be able to defend.
"We can explain the gap if anyone asks"
What it looks like: A gap shows up and the explanation arrives afterwards. "He was hired when the market was hot." "She didn't push for more." "He's a stronger performer." None of it was written down when the pay was set.
Why smart teams fall into it: Managers usually do have reasons and most of them are honest. At this size pay decisions are made quickly, often by the founder or a hiring manager. Nobody expected to defend them in writing.
What it costs: The test is objective, gender-neutral criteria. The directive's own view is that these should be agreed with the workers' representatives [1]. A reason reconstructed a year later is weak on both counts. Some reasons fail on their face. Negotiation outcomes often track gender. The directive now bars employers from asking applicants about their pay history [1], which makes "we matched their last salary" hard to rely on. Performance only works where there is a performance record that predates the pay decision. Law firm guidance on the directive puts it simply: Document objective justifications at the time the decision is made [6]. The stakes rise in a dispute. Where an employer has not met its transparency duties, including reporting and the joint pay assessment, the burden shifts to the employer to prove there was no pay discrimination [1].
"Six months is plenty of time to fix it"
What it looks like: The company files the report, sees a gap in two categories and plans to deal with it at the next pay review.
Why smart teams fall into it: Six months sounds generous. Many companies of this size run one pay review a year and expect to fix pay there.
What it costs: The six months start on the date the report is submitted [1]. For a June filing, the window closes in December. Many companies' pay reviews fall in the first quarter, outside that window. A remedy usually means real pay changes, so it needs a budget that was not in the year's plan and approvals that take time at a US parent. National laws can also move faster than the directive. Slovakia's law requires the joint pay assessment to be completed within two months once the duty arises [3]. A company that uses the six months to start its analysis will usually end up in the assessment anyway. The next report then shows whether its fixes worked, because a joint pay assessment must evaluate the measures taken after the last one [1].
"We have no works council, so the joint part doesn't apply"
What it looks like: A company without employee representatives assumes the assessment is something it can run alone, or not at all.
Why smart teams fall into it: Many US-owned companies in Europe have never had a works council. Words like "joint" and "representatives" sound like they belong to larger, unionized employers.
What it costs: The directive's recitals say that where there are no workers' representatives, workers should designate them for the purpose of the assessment [1]. The duty to work with representatives runs through the whole process. Management confirms the accuracy of the report after consulting them. They get access to the methods the employer used [1]. The criteria for comparing jobs are meant to be agreed with them where they exist [1]. A company that meets its first representatives during a formal assessment is negotiating with people who have just seen its gaps for the first time. That is a hard first conversation to recover from.
What a sound position looks like before the first report
No set of categories or explanations makes a gap disappear if it is real. That is not the aim. The aim is a position where any gap the report shows is either explained by criteria the company would defend in public or already being fixed. In our view a sound position has these qualities.
- The categories come from an evaluation of the work, not from a system field. Jobs are compared on the criteria the law names: Skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions [1]. The grouping can be explained in a paragraph to someone who does not work in HR.
- One structure serves every purpose. The same categories drive pay ranges, the answers to individual pay requests, the report and any assessment. When an employee asks how their pay compares, the answer uses the same lines as the report. Our guide on whether you are ready for pay transparency looks at those individual questions.
- Every pay placement has a recorded reason. Starting pay, promotions and exceptions each carry a short note in neutral terms, written at the time. A gap can then be read person by person rather than defended as an average.
- Small categories are known in advance. The company knows which groups are small enough for one person to move the average. It can say before the report why a gap there does or does not reflect a pattern.
- Variable pay is looked at on its own. Commission, bonus and allowances often carry most of a category gap. Each has rules that say who is eligible and why. The weekend allowance in the dry run is a fair example: Paying for weekend work is a working-conditions reason, but only if the weekend rota is open to everyone.
- Representatives are in place before they are needed. Where none exist, the company has a way for workers to choose them. They have seen the method before they see the numbers.
- A dry run happens while the year can still change. The company runs the numbers on current data well before the reporting year closes. It fixes what it cannot explain then, rather than in the six months after filing.
None of this is a procedure to copy. Each quality is a test a reviewer can put to the company's own records. A company that passes them may still show a gap above 5% in some category. The difference is that it will be able to say why, or show what it is already doing about it.
The calls only you can make
Some of the choices behind the 5% test are not legal questions. They are about what the company believes work is worth and how open it wants to be.
What counts as equal value. Is a senior support lead's work worth the same as a mid-level engineer's? The market may pay them differently, but the law asks about the work. Where the company draws that line is a statement of its values. Once drawn, it is hard to move.
Whether market premiums are a reason you will defend. Many companies pay more for hard-to-hire skills. That can be a legitimate reason. It becomes a weak one when the premium sits mostly with one sex and nobody can show the market evidence that justified it at the time.
Whether to close gaps before the first report. Nothing stops a company from raising pay in a category before it files. That costs money now and removes the gap from the record. Waiting keeps the money for longer but puts the gap in front of every worker.
How much to publish. The national monitoring body publishes the company-wide figures in a form that allows comparison between employers. The company may also publish them on its own site and add its own explanation [1]. Saying something first, in your own words, is a choice about trust and reputation, not a legal duty.
How far to involve employees. The law sets a floor for consultation. Some companies go well beyond it and treat representatives as partners in the pay structure. Others keep to the minimum. The choice shapes how the first difficult conversation goes.
The law and the numbers
The directive had to be in national law by 7 June 2026 [1]. As of late October 2026, five member states have finished that work: Italy, Lithuania, Malta, Slovakia and Greece. The rest are late. Our note on EU pay transparency, country by country tracks each one. A law firm briefing reports the Commission's position: No pause and no extension at EU level [2].
| Workers in the EU employer | First report under the directive | Data year | Then |
|---|---|---|---|
| 250 or more | By 7 June 2027 | 2026 | Every year [1] |
| 150 to 249 | By 7 June 2027 | 2026 | Every three years [1] |
| 100 to 149 | By 7 June 2031 | 2030 | Every three years [1] |
| Fewer than 100 | No duty under the directive; member states may add one | n/a | n/a [1] |
The joint pay assessment applies only to employers that have to report [1]. National laws are already adding detail. Slovakia sets a two-month deadline for completing the assessment and fines of EUR 4,000 to EUR 8,000 for reporting failures. Its first reports cover August to December 2026 [3]. Italy ties categories to collective agreements [4]. Germany has no bill yet and its ministry expects reporting no earlier than June 2028 [7]. Dates will differ by country. The 5% test, the six months and the content of the assessment come from the directive itself.
Two numbers set the scale. Across the EU, the unadjusted gap between women's and men's average hourly pay was 11.1% in 2024 [8]. That is an economy-wide average, not a category gap. It still suggests that gaps above 5% will be common rather than rare. And readiness is low. In a survey of more than 1,600 HR and reward leaders fielded in late 2025, only 9% of Europe-based employers said their pay transparency strategy was fully in place [9].
Our view
We think the 5% trigger is a test of a company's categories and records more than of its pay. Most mid-size employers will show a gap somewhere. The ones that avoid a joint pay assessment will be those that can explain each gap with criteria they set before they saw the numbers, or that fixed it before they filed.
So we would treat the six months after filing as a window to finish work, not to start it. The categories should come from an evaluation of the work, agreed with representatives, a full pay cycle before the reporting year closes. For a company of 150 to 249 workers under the directive's dates, that year is already almost over.
We would argue hardest against one habit: Building categories from whatever the HR system holds and explaining the gaps afterwards. It is the quickest route to an assessment and the hardest position to defend once workers have seen the numbers.
Where we help
Our pay equity work runs the dry run before the report does. We group roles into categories using a documented evaluation of the work and measure the gap in each, including variable pay. We separate the gaps your records explain from the ones they don't and cost the fixes. The starting point is a standalone pay equity review, priced by the employees in scope. If a conversation would help first, Book a free call.
Sources
- Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Articles 3, 4, 5, 9, 10, 18, 29 and 34 and recital 43 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-25
- Lewis Silkin, EU Pay Transparency Directive 2026: No EU-level delay (1 July 2026), checked 2026-10-24
- Lewis Silkin and Nitschneider & Partners for Ius Laboris, Slovakia's transposition of the EU Pay Transparency Directive (22 September 2026), checked 2026-10-25
- Littler, Italy implements the EU Pay Transparency Directive: A guide to the final decree (4 June 2026; Legislative Decree 96/2026), checked 2026-10-25
- Jackson Lewis, EU pay transparency: Lessons for employers from the first three member states' legislation (June 2026), checked 2026-10-25
- Mayer Brown, EU Pay Transparency Directive: Practical briefing for international employers (30 June 2026), checked 2026-10-25
- Baker McKenzie, Germany: Missed Pay Transparency Directive implementation deadline (24 September 2026), checked 2026-10-24
- Eurostat, Gender pay gap statistics (data extracted February 2026; 2024 figures provisional), checked 2026-10-25
- Mercer, 2025 Global Pay Transparency Report, press release (16 February 2026; fieldwork September to October 2025), checked 2026-10-25