What are free salary sites good for?
Your staff read them. Your candidates read them. Sometimes your managers set pay from them.
Short answer: Free salary sites are good for direction: Whether a job pays roughly what you think, what candidates will expect and where to look harder. They are unsafe for setting a pay band, because they rarely know the job's level, who answered or what "pay" includes.
The screenshot
A product manager in Atlanta sends a screenshot to their manager. A free salary site puts the median for "product manager" in the city at $118,000. Their band tops out at $112,000. The manager forwards it to HR with one line: Are we underpaying?
This conversation is getting more common. In a 2025 survey of 500 US business leaders, 72% said more employees were negotiating pay with information found online than a year earlier. Almost two in three (63%) saw more pay requests based on inaccurate or unverified data [1]. The screenshot deserves a real answer. It is not, on its own, a reason to move the band.
What free data is good for
Free sources tell you whether a job is broadly a $70,000 job or a $140,000 job. They flag roles where you may be far off and worth a proper look. They show what a candidate sees before the first call, which helps you prepare the conversation. Government data adds a method you can read. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes occupational wages from a survey of about 1.1 million establishments, collected over three years. Its May 2025 estimates came out in May 2026 [2].
Why it is unsafe for a band
No level. A band is built for one level of one job. The government series says plainly that its data does not contain pay by the level of work performed [2]. Crowdsourced sites rely on the title each person types. A "senior product manager" at a 40-person startup and at a 4,000-person company are rarely the same job.
Who answered. People choose whether to post their pay. A Federal Reserve study of one large site found its average salaries by industry and region tracked official data fairly closely. The mix of industries behind them differed substantially [3]. Averages can hold up while the slice you need, one job at one level in one city, rests on a handful of entries.
What "pay" means. One site shows base salary, another adds bonus and stock. The government series counts commissions and production bonuses but leaves out year-end bonuses, profit-sharing and stock [2]. Entries may span several years with no single date. Two numbers that look comparable often are not.
No record. A band has to be explained to staff, to auditors and sometimes to a court. Under the EU pay transparency directive, once a worker shows facts that suggest pay discrimination, the employer has to prove there was none [4]. "A website said so" is a weak answer.
Our view
Free sites are fine for direction and unsafe for a band. Use them to ask questions, not to answer them. When an employee brings a screenshot, take it seriously: Check the match on level, location and what the number counts. Then explain where your own band comes from. If the gap holds up against your real data, fix it. If your bands came from free sites in the first place, that is the bigger issue. Our guide Which salary survey should you buy? covers buying data that fits your jobs. Our guide Which salary data should you trust? covers when live data earns a place next to a survey. This is general information, not legal advice.
Where we help
Our market pricing project prices your roles one by one against the market data you have, with each match written down. It is quoted within one business day. If the bands themselves need rebuilding, our Pay Band Sprint does that from the same data.* Book a free call.
*We don't provide market data. We use the data you have or buy. No data yet? We help you choose a survey or tool that fits your size and budget.
Sources
- Payscale, 2025 Pay Confidence Gap Report press release (15 July 2025; 1,000 US employees and 500 US business and HR leaders), checked 2026-10-27
- US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics: Frequently asked questions (wage definition, level of work, sample) and OEWS home page (May 2025 estimates, released 15 May 2026), checked 2026-10-27
- Karabarbounis and Pinto, What can we learn from online wage postings? Evidence from Glassdoor, Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond Economic Quarterly, Q4 2018 (standard reference), checked 2026-10-27
- Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Article 18 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-26
Changelog: 27 October 2026, first published. The Atlanta screenshot and band are an illustration, not data.