How often should you review pay equity?
Before every pay cycle, not after it.
Short answer: Run a light pay equity check before every annual pay review, so the fixes can come out of that year's budget. Run a full review at least every three years and whenever the pay structure changes. Two US states reward an analysis done within the last three years. The EU sets reporting cycles by employer size.
This is general information, not legal advice. Laws are summarized as checked on 27 October 2026; each one links to its source below.
One cycle late
A 180-person ecommerce company in Salt Lake City runs its first pay equity review in March, right after its January raises. It finds eleven people paid well below peers in similar roles. Seven of the gaps grew in the cycle that just closed, because the merit matrix gave the same percentage to everyone with the same rating. The budget for the year is spent. The fixes wait until next January, so the company spends ten months knowing about gaps it has not closed.
Asking how often to review pay equity matters less than asking when. The company and its figures are an illustration, not data.
What employers do now
Many employers review, but not on a fixed rhythm. In SHRM research on 2024 practices, based on more than 2,000 US HR professionals, 61% of HR leaders said they audit to find pay inequities, but only 54% review pay each year [1]. A review that happens when someone has time tends to happen after a complaint, a resignation or a pay review that has already gone wrong.
What the law rewards
Massachusetts. An employer has a defense to pay claims under the state's equal pay act if it completed a good faith self-evaluation of its pay practices within three years before the claim was filed and can show reasonable progress on the gaps it found. A December 2025 appeals decision upheld the defense for an employer whose review had led to raises for seven people [2].
Oregon. An employer cannot be ordered to pay compensatory or punitive damages if it completed a good faith equal pay analysis within three years before the claim and has made reasonable and substantial progress on the gaps. The analysis must be reasonable in detail and scope for the employer's size. The employer still owes back pay [3].
EU. Under the pay transparency directive, employers with 250 or more workers report their pay gaps every year. Those with 100 to 249 report every three years, starting in 2027 or 2031 depending on size. A gap of 5% or more in any category of workers that the employer cannot justify and does not fix within six months triggers a joint pay assessment [4]. Our note on EU pay gap reporting covers who files when.
In each case, an old review protects less than a recent one and a review with no follow-up protects very little.
What it means for a company of 50 to 500 people
Three rhythms fit together. A light check before each pay review looks at people paid below peers in similar roles and at last cycle's new hires and promotions. It feeds the merit budget, so fixes are paid for in the same cycle. A full review every three years tests how jobs are grouped, which factors explain pay and whether the explanations hold up. It also keeps you inside the three-year windows above. A trigger review follows any big change: New bands, an acquisition, a hiring wave or a new country.
The common mistake is running the review right after the pay cycle. It finds the gaps the cycle just created, when the money is already gone. Our guide Which pay gaps can you defend? covers what to do with what the review finds.
Our view
Review before every cycle, not after. A light yearly check timed to the pay review costs little and turns findings into fixes the same year. A full review every three years keeps the method honest. Whatever the rhythm, write down what you found and what you fixed. That record is what the law looks at.
Where we help
Our standalone pay equity review can be timed to land before your pay review, with a list of gaps to fix in that cycle. Book a free call.
Sources
- SHRM, Pay equity gets more attention, but gaps still remain (Aaron Teitelbaum, 25 March 2025; research on 2024 practices, more than 2,000 US HR professionals), checked 2026-10-27
- Duane Morris, Massachusetts Appeals Court affirms power of pay equity self-evaluations (2 February 2026; on G.L. c. 149, s. 105A(d) and Woodward v. Board of Registration in Nursing, 31 December 2025), checked 2026-10-27
- Oregon Revised Statutes 652.235, Equal-pay analysis, checked 2026-10-27
- Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Articles 9 and 10 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-25
Changelog: 27 October 2026, first published. The Salt Lake City company and its figures are an illustration, not data.