Pay history bans: What you can ask
Asking what a candidate earns now is off limits in more places every year. Asking what they expect usually is not.
Short answer: Where pay history is banned, you may not ask what a candidate earns or base an offer on it. You can usually ask what pay they expect. Some states let you use volunteered history only to offer more. Across states, the simplest rule is never to ask.
This is general information, not legal advice. Rules differ by state and city and change often. Check the rules where you hire.
What changed
Virginia's ban took effect on 1 July 2026 and covers every employer. Employers may not seek an applicant's pay history. An applicant may volunteer it and the employer may then use it to support a higher offer [1]. HR Dive's running list, last updated in April 2026, counted 22 statewide bans and 24 local ones, though some statewide entries cover only state agencies [1]. Michigan and Wisconsin went the other way and stopped their cities from adopting bans [1].
In the EU, the pay transparency directive bars every employer from asking applicants about their pay in current or previous jobs [2]. National laws applying it are still arriving.
What you can still ask and what you cannot
The details differ by place. These points hold in most of the strict jurisdictions:
- Pay history: Do not ask. Not on the form, in the interview or through a recruiter. New York also bars asking a candidate's current or former employer [3].
- Pay history: Do not rely on it. Even where asking is allowed, many laws bar using past pay to decide whether to hire or what to offer. New York bars relying on it in either decision [3].
- Pay expectations: Usually fine. California expressly allows asking about an applicant's salary expectations for the job [4].
- Volunteered history: Use with care. New York lets candidates disclose their pay history voluntarily and without prompting. An employer may confirm it only if the candidate offers it after an offer with pay has been made, to support a higher wage [3]. Virginia lets an employer use volunteered history to support a higher offer [1].
- Declining to answer: New York bars refusing to interview, hire or promote someone because they would not disclose their pay history [3].
Federal law adds a floor everywhere in the US. Under federal equal pay guidance, prior salary cannot by itself justify a pay difference between men and women, because past pay can carry past discrimination [5].
What it means for a company of 50 to 500 people
One rule beats a map. A company hiring remotely across states will meet a different rule for almost every candidate. Never asking about pay history anywhere is simpler than tracking where it is allowed and lowers the risk that one recruiter gets it wrong.
Recruiters and agencies are part of it. A question asked by an outside recruiter is still a question asked for you. Forms, applicant tracking fields and agency briefs need the same rule.
The offer has to come from somewhere else. Without past pay, the offer must rest on the job: Its level, its range and where the candidate fits in it. Companies that relied on history to set offers often discover they have no range to fall back on.
The bans seem to work. A November 2025 review by Boston University law researchers reported that job changers in places with bans saw average pay increases of 7.9%, against 3.9% elsewhere, with larger gains for women and non-white workers [6].
Our view
We would stop asking about pay history everywhere, not only where the law requires it. Past pay imports every previous employer's decisions into yours, including the unfair ones. Ask about expectations if you need to, but share your range first, so the conversation starts from the job and not from what the candidate guesses you will pay. Our guide on offer approvals and pay inversion covers what an offer should be checked against instead.
Where we help
Our Job Ad Pay Range Audit checks your live ads, application forms and recruiter scripts against the pay range and pay history rules where you hire and tells you what to fix. To discuss your own position first, Book a free call.
Sources
- HR Dive, A running list of states and localities that have outlawed pay history questions (last updated 28 April 2026), checked 2026-10-30
- Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Article 5 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-25
- New York Labor Law § 194-a, checked 2026-10-30
- California Labor Code section 432.3, checked 2026-10-28
- US EEOC, Compliance Manual Section 10: Compensation Discrimination, 10-IV.F.2.g (prior salary), checked 2026-10-30
- HR Dive, Salary history bans shrink gender- and race-based pay gaps, researchers find (Ryan Golden, 10 November 2025), on a Boston University School of Law review, checked 2026-10-30
Changelog: 30 October 2026, first published. We refresh this note when a state adds or changes a ban.