What pay mix fits each sales role?
The more a role controls the result, the more of its pay can ride on it.
Short answer: Set each sales role's pay mix by how much the person in it controls the result they are paid on. New-business roles that decide whether a deal is won can carry a large variable share. Roles whose results depend on others, on long cycles or on renewals that mostly happen anyway need more base. One split for every role pays some people for luck.
One split for everyone
Picture a 180-person software company in Columbus, Ohio. It sells route planning software to regional freight carriers. Its sales team has grown from three generalists to four roles: Sales development reps who book first meetings, account executives who close new customers, account managers who look after renewals and growth and two sales engineers who run demos and technical reviews. When the team was three people, everyone earned half their target pay as base and half as commission. The company kept that sales pay mix as it hired. It seemed fair: Everyone in sales is paid the same way.
Two years on, the pattern is hard to ignore. Sales development reps leave within a year, most of them after a quarter or two of missing a meeting target that depends on lead volume they do not control. Account managers have their best year on record, mostly from renewals that were never at risk, while two large expansion deals stall. The sales engineers, paid on the same closed revenue as the account executives, earn a large bonus in a quarter when they barely touched the deals that closed and a small one in a quarter when they worked every weekend on a bid the company lost on price.
The new head of sales asks the founder why a single split covers four jobs that do such different work. The founder's answer is honest: Nobody ever decided it. It was the split the first three hires had and changing it felt like a pay cut for someone.
This is a composite of a common situation at companies this size, not a client. The details are illustrative. The pattern is common because the base-to-variable split is usually inherited, not chosen. It stays the same long after the roles under it have changed.
Why setting the split by role is hard
The pay mix is the share of a role's target pay that is fixed base salary versus the share that is variable and paid only when results come in. On-target earnings, or OTE, is the total a person earns at full target performance. A role on a 60/40 mix earns 60% of OTE as base and 40% as variable at target. The mix does not change what the job is worth. It changes how much of that pay the person has to earn again every period.
Two good goals pull against each other. The first is motivation: A meaningful share of pay tied to results focuses effort on the outcome the company needs and lets strong performers earn well above target. The second is fairness and stability: People should not have large parts of their pay decided by things they cannot influence, such as lead volume, a long buying cycle, a product gap or a renewal that was always going to happen. The more variable a role's pay, the more of it rides on factors outside the person's control, unless the role really does control the result.
Economists who study sales pay have made this point for decades. A well-known model of sales force pay predicts that the salary share of total pay should rise as the selling environment becomes more uncertain [5]. In plain terms: When results depend more on things the rep cannot control, a large variable share mostly transfers risk to the rep rather than buying more effort. That is the logic behind the stance of this guide.
The split also sits under pressure from two directions at once. Companies are leaning further into pay for performance: In one recent industry survey, 66% of companies said they were doing so for 2026 and 97% said they had changed their sales compensation plans [2]. Yet reps already doubt the plans they have. In a 2026 survey of 500 US sales professionals published by a CRM software provider, 47% said their compensation does not always seem fair [3]. A larger variable share on top of a plan people do not trust raises the stakes of every flaw in it.
Finally, the split has a floor set by law in some cases. For reps who are not exempt from overtime, commissions count toward the regular rate used to calculate overtime pay [7]. A low base does not lower the legal floor. It only moves more of the pay into a part that is harder to get right.
Sales roles, side by side
This table shows how much each common sales role controls the result it is usually paid on and which way its pay mix tends to lean. It shows trade-offs only. It is not a plan design and the leanings are not targets.
| Role | What the person controls | What they do not control | Mix tends to lean |
|---|---|---|---|
| Account executive, new business | Whether a qualified prospect becomes a customer, at what terms | Lead volume, product fit, pricing set centrally | Toward variable |
| Sales development rep | Outreach, how many first meetings are booked and how well they are qualified | Whether the meeting turns into a deal, lead quality, territory | Toward base, with variable on meetings or pipeline |
| Account manager | Expansion, saving accounts at risk, the relationship | Renewals that would happen anyway, product changes, customer budgets | Toward base, with variable on growth and saves |
| Sales engineer | Demo and technical win quality | Price, the closing conversation, which deals they are assigned | Mostly base, a modest share tied to team results |
| Customer success manager | Adoption, health of the account, early warning on churn | The commercial decision to renew, product gaps | Mostly base, a small variable share if any |
The leanings shift with the business. An account executive selling one-call deals to small businesses controls more of the outcome than one working a nine-month enterprise cycle with a buying committee of eight. The same title can deserve a different split in two companies, or in two segments of the same company.
Five traps when setting the sales pay mix
Most of these traps start the same way. The split is set by habit or by a number heard elsewhere, not by asking what each role actually controls.
"50/50 is the standard for sales"
What it looks like: Every quota-carrying role is put on a 50/50 split because that is what the company believes sales pay looks like. The number comes from a previous employer, a hiring conversation or a benchmark page that described new-business account executives in software.
Why smart teams fall into it: The number is real for some roles. Experienced account executives recognize it and expect it, which makes hiring easier. A single split is also simple to run and easy to defend as equal treatment.
What it costs: The split that fits a closer rarely fits a role that sets up deals, protects renewals or supports someone else's sale. Published figures show how far the roles sit apart. In a 2025 report covering 351 B2B companies, the median sales development rep was paid on a 68:32 base-to-variable split, not 50/50 [1]. Putting supporting roles on a closer's split either pays them for results others produced or takes pay from them for results they never controlled. Equal treatment of unequal jobs is not fairness.
"A low base keeps them hungry"
What it looks like: The company sets a lean base and a rich variable share, especially for junior reps and new hires, on the belief that financial pressure drives effort. Pay at target looks competitive on the offer letter. Pay in practice depends on hitting a number in the first quarters of a new job.
Why smart teams fall into it: It looks cheap and self-correcting: Low performers cost little and high performers pay for themselves. Founders who sold successfully on commission-heavy plans themselves often believe it worked for them, so it will work for everyone.
What it costs: When many reps miss target, a rich variable share is a pay cut that nobody announced. In the same 2025 report, only 60% of sales development reps were at quota, the lowest share in the history of the study [1]. Under a lean base, the other 40% are paid well below what they were offered as on-target pay, which shows up as turnover and as hiring costs. There is a legal edge too. The federal exemption for outside sales reps applies only to people whose primary duty is making sales and who work customarily away from the employer's place of business [6]. Many reps who sell by phone and video from an office or from home do not meet it. If they are not exempt on some other basis, overtime rules apply and commissions count in the overtime rate [7]. A plan that assumes otherwise can create back pay claims on top of the turnover.
"Pay account managers like hunters"
What it looks like: Account managers are put on the same mix as new-business reps and paid commission on everything their accounts renew and add. Their variable pay becomes the largest line in the plan.
Why smart teams fall into it: Account managers do sell. Expansion revenue is real revenue and can be a large share of growth. A rich variable share seems like the way to tell account managers that growth matters.
What it costs: Much of what a renewal-heavy book pays depends on customers who would have renewed with no help. Paying a large variable share on that revenue pays for luck and inheritance. It also rewards the account manager who was handed the strongest book over the one who saved three difficult accounts. That raises a fairness question beyond sales. US equal pay guidance treats commissions as pay and asks whether lower-paid employees were given less support, such as weaker accounts or territories, to produce revenue [9]. Who is handed which book matters more when more of the pay rides on it. Our guide on which pay gaps you can defend explains why that kind of difference needs a reason. The work that only an account manager can do, rescuing an account at risk or opening a new buying group, often earns the least under such a plan.
"Give everyone in the deal a slice so they care"
What it looks like: Sales engineers, customer success managers and solution specialists are given a variable share tied to closed revenue or renewals so they feel part of the sale. Over time the share grows, because each year someone argues their role deserves more of the upside.
Why smart teams fall into it: It feels inclusive and builds a team culture around winning. People who support the sale do affect it and asking them to care about the result is reasonable. A small share of variable pay can do that.
What it costs: When the variable share is large and tied to results the person does not control, pay becomes noise. A sales engineer's bonus rises and falls with deals they were never assigned or with a price the company set. People learn that their pay has little to do with how well they did their job, which is the opposite of what an incentive is for. The real cost shows up in behavior: Support staff start choosing which deals to work by how likely they are to close soon, not by where their help matters most. A modest share tied to a team result is usually enough to keep everyone looking at the same goal without turning a support role into a commission job.
"Move the split to fix last year"
What it looks like: After a missed year, leadership shifts pay toward variable to push results. Or, after a year of turnover, it shifts pay toward base to keep people. The change is announced with the new plan, effective at once, in the same total on-target pay.
Why smart teams fall into it: The split is the most visible lever in the plan and it costs nothing at target. Plans change every year anyway: Almost every company in the recent industry survey changed its plan for 2026 [2]. Moving the split feels like a natural part of that change.
What it costs: At the same OTE, shifting toward variable cuts pay for everyone who will be below target, which is often the people the change was meant to motivate. Shifting toward base without changing what the role is expected to deliver weakens the link to results for the people who were earning well above target. Either way, people read a split change as a statement about their pay, because it is one. In some places it is also a change to written terms. In New York, the terms for commission salespeople must be in writing, signed by both sides and include how commissions are calculated [8]. A split that moves every year, for reasons that differ every year, makes those terms harder to write and harder to believe.
What a sound pay mix looks like
A sound split is not the one that matches a benchmark. It is the one each role's people would recognize as fair for the work they do, set on purpose and explained in a sentence. Several qualities set it apart.
It follows control, role by role. Each role's split reflects how much the person in it decides the result they are paid on. Roles that win or lose deals on their own work carry more variable pay. Roles that set up, support or protect revenue carry more base. Where a role's control differs by segment, the split can differ by segment too.
The variable part is paid on something the role moves. A sound split pairs the right share with the right measure. A sales development rep is paid on meetings or pipeline they create, not on deals they never touch. An account manager is paid on growth and saves, not on renewals that were never at risk. Our guide on which commission base to use covers how the measure itself is chosen.
Pay at target is realistic. The split assumes that a typical, competent person in the role reaches target in a typical year. If many people miss target year after year, the variable share is too large for the role, the targets are wrong or both. Either way, people are being paid less than the offer told them.
OTE is set against the market for the role, not the split. The total is set first, from the market the company competes in for each role. The split then divides it. Our guide on which market percentile to target covers that choice. A company that sets the split first and lets the total follow often ends up with base salaries that are too low to hire and too high to motivate. Where benchmarking is part of the work, we do not provide market data. We use the data the client has or buys.
The base holds up on its own. The base pays for the parts of the job that are never paid as variable: Training, internal work, deals that take longer than a quarter. It also clears every legal floor where the person works, without relying on commissions to get there.
It changes rarely and for a stated reason. The split is reviewed when a role changes, such as when an account executive moves from small deals to enterprise ones, not every year to fix the last one. When it does change, the reason is written down and the people affected hear it before the plan takes effect.
None of this needs a large sales operations function. It needs someone to ask, for each role, what the person in it actually controls and to set the split from that answer.
The calls only you can make
Some of the decisions behind a pay mix are not technical. They are choices about the kind of sales team you want.
How much pay risk do you want your people to carry? A company that wants a team of self-starters who expect big upside can lean variable for its closers and accept higher turnover. A company that wants steadier, longer-tenured relationships leans base. Both are legitimate. The choice should sit in your compensation philosophy, not in a spreadsheet nobody revisits.
Who owns the account after the first sale? If the closer keeps the account, their split carries expansion. If an account manager takes over, the closer's variable pay should stop at the first deal and the account manager's should start. Unclear ownership produces two people paid for one result, or nobody paid for the hard one.
How much will you pay for luck? Every variable plan pays some people for windfalls and penalizes others for bad breaks. Some companies accept that as part of a sales culture. Others add protections, such as caps on windfall deals or a floor for new hires while they ramp. The more variable the split, the more these choices matter.
Will support roles share in the result at all? A small team bonus keeps everyone pointed at the same goal. A large individual share turns a support role into a sales role. Decide which you want before someone asks for a bigger slice.
What will you say when the split changes? Moving pay between base and variable is a statement about how the company values a role. Decide in advance who explains it and how much notice people get.
The data, the law and the numbers
- Sales development reps lean base. A 2025 report covering 351 B2B companies found a median on-target pay of $80,000 for sales development reps, on a 68:32 base-to-variable split. Only 60% of reps were at quota, the lowest share in the study's history [1]. These are the publisher's own figures.
- Plans change every year. An industry survey of hundreds of companies across 11 industries reports that 97% changed their 2026 sales compensation plans and 66% are leaning further into pay for performance [2].
- Reps doubt the plans. A CRM software provider's 2026 report, based on a survey of 500 US sales professionals from August to September 2025, found 47% say their pay does not always seem fair and 74% want more transparency in how it is calculated [3].
- Base has been rising. In the most recent public edition of WorldatWork's survey of sales compensation programs (693 responses, fielded June 2022), 50% of organizations said they had offered higher base pay for sales roles [4]. A newer edition was not publicly available when we checked.
- Uncertainty favors base. A widely cited model of sales force pay predicts that the salary share of total pay rises with uncertainty in the selling environment [5]. It is theory, but it matches what practitioners see.
- Outside sales. The US outside sales exemption needs a primary duty of making sales and work customarily and regularly away from the employer's place of business. The salary requirements do not apply to it [6].
- Commissions count in overtime. For non-exempt employees, commissions are payments for hours worked and must be included in the regular rate used for overtime [7].
- New York. Terms for commission salespeople must be in writing, signed by both sides and describe how commissions are calculated [8].
- Commissions are pay for equal pay purposes. US equal pay guidance treats commissions as compensation and looks at whether employees were given equal support to earn them [9]. The EU pay transparency directive also defines pay to include variable components, so a role's commissions count in the pay gap figures employers will report [10].
This is general information, not legal advice. Wage and hour rules differ by state and country and change over time. Check the rules where your reps work.
Our view
We think the pay mix should follow control. Roles that decide whether a deal is won can carry a large variable share. Roles that set up, support or protect revenue should carry more base, with variable pay tied to the part of the result they really move. One split for every sales role is the most common mistake we would expect to find in a sales plan at a growing company, because it is the one nobody chose.
We are cautious about lean bases used to create pressure. When many people miss target, a rich variable share becomes an unannounced pay cut. It costs more in turnover and risk than it saves.
And we would argue against moving the split every year to fix last year's problem. A split that changes rarely, for a reason people can repeat, will do more for results than a clever one nobody trusts.
Where we help
Our incentive and sales compensation work designs commission and bonus plans for growing companies: The split each role is paid on, the measures behind its variable pay and plan documents written so people can follow their own pay. See incentive and sales compensation for how a project is scoped and priced. If a conversation would help first, Book a free call.
Sources
- The Bridge Group, 2025 SDR Models and Metrics Report (6 February 2025; 351 B2B companies), checked 2026-10-27
- Alexander Group, 2026 Sales Compensation Trends research briefing (hundreds of companies across 11 industries), checked 2026-10-27
- Salesforce, 2026 Trends in Sales Compensation report (500 US sales professionals, surveyed 7 August to 24 September 2025), checked 2026-10-26
- WorldatWork, 2022 Sales Compensation Programs and Practices Survey, press release (22 August 2022; 693 responses), checked 2026-10-27
- Basu, Lal, Srinivasan and Staelin, Salesforce Compensation Plans: An Agency Theoretic Perspective, Marketing Science 4(4), 1985, checked 2026-10-27
- US Department of Labor, Fact Sheet #17F: Exemption for Outside Sales Employees under the FLSA (revised August 2024), checked 2026-10-27
- 29 CFR § 778.117, commission payments (Cornell LII), checked 2026-10-27
- New York Labor Law § 191(1)(c), commission salespersons (NY Senate), checked 2026-10-26
- US EEOC, Compliance Manual Section 10: Compensation Discrimination, 10-IV.C and 10-IV.F.2.f, checked 2026-10-26
- Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Article 3 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-25