Guide · Pay transparency

What should a job ad's pay range say?

The number is only half of the pay line. The words around it tell candidates and staff what the number means.

Short answer: A pay range in a job ad should say what kind of pay it is, what moves someone within it and what sits outside it. Candidates read the top as the likely offer. Current staff read the line as a statement about their own job. A range that is legally complete but says nothing else tends to cost offers and trust.

A compliant ad that still lost the hire

Northwind Analytics is a fictional 120-person data company based in Denver that hires remotely across the US. Last spring it posted an ad for an account executive. The pay line read: "$70,000 to $160,000."

The range was accurate. The sales leader had built it from the base salary at the bottom and the on-target earnings of a strong performer at the top. Recruiting checked that it had a minimum and a maximum and posted it.

The best candidate in the process read it differently. She assumed the top was a base salary for someone with her experience. When the offer came in at an $85,000 base with $75,000 of target commission, she felt the company had moved the goalposts and withdrew. The recruiter explained the split on the phone. By then the explanation sounded like an excuse.

The same week, two current account executives saw the ad. Both earned base salaries near $80,000. Both read $160,000 as a number the company was now willing to pay new hires for their job. One asked her manager whether she was underpaid. He did not know how the range had been built.

Nothing in the ad broke a rule. It still produced a lost hire, a nervous team and a manager with no answer. The range was correct. The pay line around it said almost nothing.

Northwind Analytics is fictional and its numbers are illustrative.

Why the pay line is harder than it looks

Most companies treat the pay range in a job ad as a compliance field. Someone fills in a minimum and a maximum, legal confirms the format and the ad goes live. That view is understandable. Posting rules are written as format rules: A minimum, a maximum, a pay period, sometimes a benefits description.

Readers do not treat it as a field. For a candidate, the pay line is the most read part of the ad and the one they return to before every interview. Indeed reported that in May 2025 about 59% of US job postings on its site included salary information. It also reported that jobs with employer-provided salaries receive 3.8 times more applications. In a Monster survey of 1,000 US workers, reported in April 2026, 60% said they would not apply to a posting without a salary range. The line is read closely by people deciding whether to apply at all.

The ad also has a second audience. Current employees read it within days and compare it with their own pay. Several places give them a formal right to ask about it. Massachusetts lets an employee request the range for the job they hold, even when there is no opening. California gives employees the pay scale for their own position on request.

Two good goals pull against each other. The company wants flexibility: Room to hire a stronger or weaker candidate than planned, to pay variable compensation and to keep the ad short. Readers want clarity: What the job pays, what kind of pay it is and where they would land. A bare range serves the first goal and leaves the reader to fill in the second. Readers fill it in with the number that suits them, which is usually the top.

That is why the words around the number matter. They are how the company explains its flexibility instead of hiding it.

Five ways a correct pay range says the wrong thing

Each of these passes a basic format check. Each one leaves readers with a picture of the job the company did not intend.

"The number speaks for itself"

What it looks like: The ad shows two figures and nothing else. It does not say whether they are base salary or total pay, per year or per hour, a starting range or the full band.

Why smart teams fall into it: Inside the company everyone knows what the number means. Recruiting knows the role is salaried. The hiring manager knows the top includes a bonus. Adding words feels like padding.

What it costs: Each reader picks a meaning, usually the most generous one. A candidate who reads total pay as base feels misled at the offer. A current employee who reads a full band as a hiring range concludes new hires will earn more than they do. The posting rules leave little room for this kind of vagueness. New York defines the range as the minimum and maximum annual salary or hourly range of compensation. Massachusetts defines it as an annual salary range or an hourly wage range. Washington's guidance says that where a company uses a starting range for new hires, it may post that range but must also post the entire range. A number without its type is not only unclear. In some places it may not be the number the law asks for.

"Candidates will know where they land"

What it looks like: The range is wide enough to cover a junior and an experienced hire. The ad gives no hint of what places someone low or high within it. The answer is left to the interview.

Why smart teams fall into it: Saying what drives placement feels like a commitment. It is easier to keep the decision open and judge each candidate on the day.

What it costs: Candidates anchor on the top. When the offer lands in the middle, it reads as a lowball rather than a fair placement, because nothing in the ad prepared them for it. The result is longer negotiations, more declined offers and offers pushed upward to close. Each of those raises the pay of new hires relative to current staff. Placement language does not need to promise a number. It needs to tell the reader that the range spans different levels of experience and what the company weighs. If the range is so wide that no sentence can explain it, the problem is the range. Our guide on how wide a posted pay range can be covers that question. Illinois guidance makes a related point: "Pay starts at $50,000 depending on experience" is too vague and an extremely broad range may raise questions under its equal pay law.

"Variable pay is a detail"

What it looks like: A sales ad shows on-target earnings with no base. Or it shows the base with no word on commission. A role with a meaningful bonus or equity grant shows the salary only, or the salary plus the word "competitive".

Why smart teams fall into it: Variable pay is complicated. Plans change each year, quotas differ by territory and equity values move. A single figure feels cleaner.

What it costs: For roles where variable pay is a large share of the package, the split between fixed and variable is the job. It tells a candidate how much risk they carry. Hiding it attracts people who do not want that risk and puts off people who do. Several laws also reach variable pay directly. California says a pay scale for a commission or piece rate role must include a good-faith estimate of the expected range of those amounts. Massachusetts asks for the commission range the employer reasonably expects to pay. Washington's guidance asks for the commission rate or rate range, with a percentage of the net sale price per unit as its example. Illinois asks the posting to state that the role is eligible for tips, commissions or bonuses, though not the amounts. New York accepts a general statement for jobs paid solely on commission. Rules differ, so a remote ad has to meet the strictest one it reaches. The Northwind ad above did not break any of these rules on its face. It still failed the reader, because one combined figure hid the split that defined the job.

"The benefits line is boilerplate"

What it looks like: Every ad ends with the same sentence: "Competitive benefits, great culture, flexible working." It is the same for an hourly support role and a director.

Why smart teams fall into it: Benefits feel like company information, not job information. Writing one line and reusing it is efficient.

What it costs: A generic line wastes the part of the ad where a company can show what it offers beyond base pay. It also may not meet the rules where they apply. Washington asks for a general description of all benefits and other compensation for the specific position. Its guidance names health care, retirement, paid time off and holidays as examples. Illinois asks for the same and allows a link only if the linked page shows the key benefits without more clicks. California does not require bonuses, tips or benefits in the pay scale at all. A single sentence cannot satisfy the strictest of these and read well for every role. Our guide on what a job ad pay audit finds covers how often the benefits line is the part that fails.

"The title will do the explaining"

What it looks like: The ad says "Data Analyst" with a range broad enough for three levels of analyst. The level is not named. Neither is the job description behind it. The company plans to decide the level after interviews.

Why smart teams fall into it: Leaving the level open keeps the pool wide. It also avoids an internal argument about what level the role really is.

What it costs: Without a level, the range has nothing to attach to. Candidates cannot tell whether they are applying for a junior or a lead role. Current analysts cannot tell whether the range describes their job or the one above it, so they assume the most generous reading. Washington's guidance takes a clear view: An ad that can be filled at different titles should list a range for each title. New York requires the job description in the ad if one exists. The level and title are part of the pay line, because they tell the reader which job the number belongs to.

What a good pay line does

A good pay line is judged by what a careful reader understands after reading it once. In our view, a strong one has these qualities.

  • The reader knows what kind of pay it is. Salary or hourly, base or total, starting range or full band. No reader has to guess.
  • It names the job the number belongs to. The title and level are clear enough that a current employee can tell whether the range describes their own job.
  • The spread is explained. A short phrase says what moves someone up or down within the range. A candidate offered the middle is not surprised.
  • Variable pay is visible and honest. Fixed and variable pay are shown separately where variable pay is a real part of the package. Commission is described the way the law where the role can be filled asks for it.
  • The benefits line belongs to the role. It describes what this position receives, not the company in general.
  • It reads the same everywhere it appears. The careers page, job boards and agency copies say the same thing.
  • It survives the internal read. Before posting, someone has asked how the people already in this job will read it and is ready to answer them.

None of these is a format. Two ads can meet all of them and look quite different. They share a test: Would a candidate and a current employee reach the same understanding of what the job pays? If not, the ad is saying two things at once. Our guide on what a good-faith pay range is covers where each end of the range should come from.

The calls only you can make

The law sets a floor for what the pay line must say. Several choices above that floor are about the employer the company wants to be.

Base or total in the headline. For sales and other incentive-heavy roles, a company can lead with base pay or with on-target earnings. Leading with base is more conservative and attracts people who value security. Leading with total pay is more attractive and puts more weight on the company's quota being realistic. Either can work if the other figure sits right beside it.

How much of the band to show. Some companies post the full band for the role. Others post the part they expect to hire into and say so. Posting the full band invites questions about why no one is hired at the top. Posting a hiring range invites questions about where the rest of the band is. Both are defensible if the company can explain its choice in one sentence.

How specific to be about equity and bonuses. Where the law only asks for a general description, a company can name the plan, give a typical value or simply say the role is eligible. More detail builds trust and also creates expectations the company has to meet.

How the pay line sounds. Pay lines can be bare figures or a short, plain explanation. The tone tells candidates and staff how comfortable the company is talking about pay. That tone is a choice.

The law and the numbers

As of 20 October 2026, these are the rules we checked on what a posted pay line must contain. Each links to its source in the list below. Coverage thresholds differ: 15 or more employees in California and Washington and 25 or more in Massachusetts, for example.

WhereWhat the pay line must showWhat else the ad must carry
CaliforniaA good-faith salary or hourly range. For commission or piece rate roles, the expected range of those amounts. In the posting itself, not behind a link or QR code [1]Bonuses, tips and benefits are not required [1]
WashingtonLowest to highest pay set before posting, with no open ends. A range for each possible title. The commission rate or rate range. The full range beside any starting range [2]A general description of all benefits and other compensation, which may link to more detail [2]
IllinoisAn hourly or salary range for the specific position, with no open ends [3]A general description of benefits and other compensation, in the posting or one click away. A statement of eligibility for tips, commissions or bonuses [3]
New YorkThe minimum and maximum annual salary or hourly range. A general statement for jobs paid solely on commission [4]The job description, if one exists [4]
MassachusettsThe annual salary or hourly wage range. The commission or piece rate range where pay depends on it [5]No benefits description in the rules we checked [5]

Remote roles widen the reach of each rule. California applies its rule to any position that may ever be filled in California, including remotely [1]. Washington covers remote work that could be done by a Washington-based employee and says a posting cannot avoid the rule by excluding Washington applicants [2]. Massachusetts covers positions whose primary place of work is in the state, including remote ones [5]. A single remote ad often has to meet the strictest of all of them.

On practice, Indeed reported that 57.8% of US postings on its site included some salary information in September 2024 [6] and about 59% in May 2025 [7]. Indeed also reported that jobs with employer-provided salaries receive 3.8 times more applications, a figure from its own platform [7]. A Monster survey of 1,000 US workers, reported in April 2026, found 60% would not apply to a posting without a salary range [8].

Our view

We think the pay line deserves the same care as the job title. It is the part of the ad most candidates read twice and most employees read first.

The common approach treats the range as a number to get right and the words around it as optional. We would reverse that emphasis. A correct number with no explanation invites readers to supply their own. They rarely supply the one the company intended. A short, plain explanation of what kind of pay it is, what moves someone within it and how variable pay works removes most of the surprises that cost offers.

The best test is simple to state. A candidate and a current employee should reach the same reading of the pay line. When they do, the ad is honest about the job. When they don't, the company will find out at the offer stage or in a one-to-one, usually both.

Sources

  1. California Labor Commissioner, Equal Pay Act FAQ (questions 77, 79, 83, 85, 87 and 89), checked 2026-10-20
  2. Washington L&I, Administrative Policy ES.E.2, Job Posting Requirements (issued 3 December 2025), checked 2026-10-20
  3. Illinois Department of Labor, Equal Pay Act salary transparency FAQ (questions 12, 13, 14 and 16), checked 2026-10-20
  4. New York Labor Law § 194-b (New York State Senate), checked 2026-10-20
  5. Massachusetts Attorney General's Office, Pay Transparency in Massachusetts (guidance and FAQs 5, 6 and 9), checked 2026-10-20
  6. Indeed Hiring Lab, Salary transparency: Growth slows, but momentum continues (23 October 2024), checked 2026-10-20
  7. Indeed, Pay transparency across high-earning sectors (2 July 2025), checked 2026-10-20
  8. CFO Dive, report on Monster's Job Search Deal-Breakers survey (22 April 2026), checked 2026-10-20

How wide can a posted pay range be?

Virginia now weighs range width in good faith and Delaware will from 2027. Five ways posted ranges go wrong and what a defensible range looks like.

What is a good-faith pay range?

Good faith means you would really hire at the bottom. How US laws judge a posted range, five ways it slips and what a defensible range looks like.

What does a job ad pay audit find?

Most ads that fail have a range. They fail on forgotten copies, unmapped remote roles, one job with several ranges and missing benefits lines.

See Resources for every guide and the self-check.