Are you ready for pay transparency?
Most companies start with the job ad. Readiness starts with the pay structure behind it. Disclosure comes last.
Short answer: Pay transparency readiness is less about the job ad than about what the ad reveals. A company is ready when every role sits in a level and band, when it can explain any person's pay in plain terms and when it knows who is paid outside the range it now shows. Posting ranges before that structure exists turns every ad into a question the company cannot answer.
This is general information, not legal advice. Laws are summarized as checked on 20 October 2026; each one links to its source below.
"Are we ready?" "Our ads have ranges."
Northwind Analytics is a fictional 120-person data company based in Denver. It hires remotely across the US and has a sales team of nine in Ireland and the Netherlands. After a board meeting, the finance lead asked the head of people a simple question: Are we ready for pay transparency?
The head of people said yes. Every open role on the careers page showed a minimum and a maximum. Recruiting had added them a year earlier and nobody had complained.
Two weeks later a customer success lead with four years at the company saw an ad for her own job. The posted minimum was $6,000 above her salary. She asked her manager why. Her manager did not know where the range came from and said he would find out.
Finding out took a month. The range had been set by recruiting, from two recent offers and a salary site, for that one requisition. Northwind had bands for engineering. It had nothing written down for customer success, sales or operations. When the head of people compared current salaries with the ranges in live ads, 14 people sat below the posted minimum for their own job. Nobody had planned or budgeted for that. Meanwhile a sales manager in Dublin had read about the new European rules and asked HR for the average pay of colleagues doing the same work.
Northwind's ads were compliant. The company was not ready. The ads had simply shown, to everyone at once, that its pay had no structure behind it.
Northwind Analytics is fictional and its numbers are illustrative.
Why readiness is harder than posting a range
A posted range looks like an external act. The company tells applicants what a job pays. In practice the first readers of a new ad are often current employees, who compare it with their own pay the same day. A posted range turns a private number into a public one. Every inconsistency that was invisible inside the company becomes visible from outside it.
Most companies are not set up for that. In Aon's 2025 Global Pay Transparency Study, 61% of organizations said they use salary ranges but do not communicate them to employees. Another 8% said they do not use ranges at all. Only 19% of the organizations in the study considered themselves ready for pay transparency. For companies headquartered in North America the figure was 25%.
The law adds a second audience. In California an employee can ask for the pay scale of their own position and the employer must provide it. Employers there cannot stop employees from disclosing their own wages. New York counts a job description made available for internal viewing as advertising. Illinois expects current employees to hear about promotion opportunities once a job is posted outside. In the European Union, the pay transparency directive gives workers a right to ask for the average pay of colleagues doing the same work or work of equal value, broken down by sex.
Two good goals pull against each other here. The business wants speed: Post compliant ranges now, because the law is in force and recruiting cannot wait. Readiness needs coherence: Ranges that come from a structure, pay that can be explained and a plan for the people the new ranges expose. Speed is easy to see and coherence is easy to postpone. Most of the pain comes from posting first and building the structure afterward, under pressure from the people who read the ads.
Five ways companies mistake compliance for readiness
Each of these starts from a reasonable belief. Each one leaves the company answering questions it has not prepared for.
"Readiness means ranges on our ads"
What it looks like: The project is scoped as a job ad project. Recruiting adds ranges, legal checks the wording and the work is marked done. Nobody looks at what the ranges say about current staff.
Why smart teams fall into it: The posting rule is the part of the law that made the news. It has a clear test, a clear owner and a visible result. Everything else is harder to define and has no deadline printed on it.
What it costs: A company that shows ranges outside but not inside has made its applicants better informed than its employees. That gap rarely lasts. Employees read the ads, compare notes and in several places have a right to ask. The first wave of questions then arrives without answers, explanations or a budget. The ad was the easy half of the work. Our guide on what a job ad pay audit finds covers the ad side in depth.
"We'll build bands later"
What it looks like: Ranges are set one requisition at a time, from recent offers, a recruiter's sense of the market or a salary website. The plan is to build proper bands once things calm down.
Why smart teams fall into it: Bands feel like a large project and a posted range feels like a small one. Hiring is happening now. A range for one job is easy to agree on in a meeting.
What it costs: Each posted range becomes a band whether anyone meant it to or not. Employees treat it as the going rate for their job. After a year of postings the company has a structure built by accident: Ranges for the same level that disagree, ranges that moved with each hire and no record of why. Building real bands then means reconciling all of that in public. The European directive points the same way. It asks employers to make the criteria used to set pay, pay levels and pay progression easily accessible to workers. Those criteria must be objective and gender neutral. Ranges invented per requisition have no criteria to show. Our guide on what a good-faith pay range is covers where each end of a range should come from.
"Nobody will notice the people below the minimum"
What it looks like: The company posts ranges without first comparing them with what current employees earn. Long-tenured staff, people hired in a cheaper market or people promoted without a matching raise turn out to sit below the posted minimum for their own job.
Why smart teams fall into it: The comparison feels like a separate exercise, close to a pay equity review, which sounds slow and expensive. It is easy to assume the gaps are few and can wait for the next pay review.
What it costs: The gaps are usually found by the employees first. Each one becomes a conversation about fairness rather than a planned adjustment. When the people below the minimum are not a random group, the gap is also an equity question. Aon's 2025 study found that 26% of organizations had run a pay equity analysis in the previous 12 to 18 months. The figure was 30% for companies headquartered in North America. Most companies, in other words, post ranges without knowing what the comparison would show. Fixing pay below the minimum costs money. Discovering it from an employee's question costs that money plus trust.
"Managers will handle the questions"
What it looks like: Ranges go live and the first employee questions go to line managers, who have never seen the bands, do not know how ranges were set and have no guidance on what they may share.
Why smart teams fall into it: Managers already talk to their teams about pay at review time. It seems natural that they will cover this too.
What it costs: A manager who cannot explain a range tends to do one of three things. They guess, promise a review they cannot deliver or tell the employee to keep their pay to themselves. The last one is the most dangerous. California's Labor Commissioner says an employer cannot prohibit an employee from disclosing their own wages. In the European Union, the directive says workers shall not be prevented from disclosing their pay to enforce equal pay. Even the careful answers go wrong when every manager improvises a different one. Our guide on how to answer an employee who asks about pay covers that conversation itself. The readiness point is earlier: Managers need the structure and the explanation before the first question, not after it.
"Our European team can wait"
What it looks like: A US company with a small team in the EU treats the European directive as a problem for later, or for large employers only. The US posting laws get all the attention.
Why smart teams fall into it: Most member states missed the transposition deadline of 7 June 2026. A law firm tracker published on 1 July 2026 listed four as fully transposed: Italy, Lithuania, Malta and Slovakia. Without a national law in force, it feels reasonable to wait.
What it costs: The same tracker reported that the European Commission has ruled out any pause or extension. Once a country's law is in force, its rules apply to employers of every size. Workers can ask, in writing, for their own pay level and the average pay of colleagues doing the same work or work of equal value, broken down by sex. The employer must answer within two months and remind all workers of the right every year. Pay gap reporting comes later and by size: Employers with 150 or more workers report from 7 June 2027 and those with 100 to 149 from 7 June 2031. For a company with nine people in Europe, the reporting duty is far away but the right to information may not be. Answering it needs the same structure the US ads need: Levels, bands and a way of saying which roles count as equal work.
What a ready company looks like
Readiness is judged by the questions a company can answer, not by how many ads it has fixed. In our view, a ready company has these qualities.
- Every role has a level and a band. Not only the families that hire often. A role without a band will one day be posted with a range someone made up.
- Posted ranges trace to the bands. Anyone can say which band a posted range came from and why it shows that part of the band.
- Any person's pay can be explained in two sentences. The explanation uses the same criteria for everyone: The level, the band and the reasons for a position within it, such as experience or performance.
- The people outside their band are known. The company has compared current pay with its bands. Each person below the minimum has a decision behind them, with a date and a budget. Each person above the maximum has an explanation the company is comfortable repeating.
- Managers know the structure before employees ask. They can say how bands are set, what they may share and where to send questions they cannot answer.
- The order of disclosure is a decision. The company chose what employees see and when, rather than letting the job ads decide for it.
- Someone owns it. One person or team answers for the bands, the posted ranges and the record of what was posted when.
The order matters more than any single item. A company that knows what it pays and why can explain it. A company that can explain its pay can show it with little risk. Reversing that order is what makes transparency feel dangerous. Our guide on how wide a posted pay range can be covers the width question that often comes up once bands exist.
The calls only you can make
Laws set a minimum. Several of the most important readiness decisions are about the kind of employer the company wants to be. No adviser can make them for you.
How much employees see. Some companies show each employee only their own range. Others publish every range internally. Aon's 2025 study found 23% of organizations let employees see the range for their own job and 8% let them see the ranges for all jobs. Each choice is defensible. What matters is that it is made on purpose and explained.
How fast to fix pay below the minimum. Moving everyone at once is clean and expensive. Phasing it over two pay cycles is cheaper and leaves some people waiting. Either way, the timing and the budget should be set before the ranges go up, not after the first complaint.
Whether to go beyond the law. A company can post ranges only where required or everywhere. In Aon's study, 48% posted only where required, 21% on all postings and 31% not at all. Posting everywhere is simpler to run and harder to reverse.
What to say about people above the maximum. Some will be stars, some will be legacy hires and some will be mistakes. Deciding whether to freeze, cap or simply explain their pay is a values call as much as a cost one.
The law and the numbers
As of 20 October 2026, these are the rules we checked that reach current employees, not only applicants. Each links to its source in the list below.
| Where | What it gives current employees | What it asks of the employer |
|---|---|---|
| California | The pay scale for their own position, on request. The right to disclose their own wages [1] | Keep each employee's job title and wage rate history for the length of employment plus three years [1] |
| New York | Pay information on internal postings: "Advertise" includes a written job description made available for internal viewing [2] | Show the range on internal postings as well as public ones [2] |
| Illinois | Notice of promotion opportunities when a job is posted outside the company [3] | Tell current employees within 14 calendar days of the external posting [3] |
| European Union | Their own pay level and the average pay, by sex, for the same work or work of equal value, on written request. The right to disclose their pay to enforce equal pay [4] | Make the criteria for pay and pay progression easily accessible. Answer within two months. Remind workers of the right every year [4] |
The EU rules apply once each country's national law is in force. The deadline was 7 June 2026 [4]. A law firm tracker published on 1 July 2026 listed four member states as fully transposed and reported that the Commission has ruled out an extension [5]. Pay gap reporting starts by 7 June 2027 for employers with 150 or more workers and by 7 June 2031 for those with 100 to 149 [4]. Member states may exempt employers with fewer than 50 workers from the pay progression part of the criteria rule [4].
More US states keep arriving. Virginia's posting law took effect on 1 July 2026 [6] and Delaware's takes effect on 26 September 2027 [7]. Each new law reaches more of a remote company's ads and, through them, more of its employees.
On readiness itself, Aon's 2025 Global Pay Transparency Study of more than 1,400 organizations found 19% considered themselves ready, 58% said their approach was increasingly structured and 23% reported a low level of readiness [8]. Among organizations headquartered in North America, 25% considered themselves ready [8].
Our view
We think pay transparency readiness should be built in a fixed order: Structure first, explanation second, disclosure last. The job ad is the last step, not the first. Companies that start with the ad end up building their pay structure in public, one employee question at a time.
For a company with 50 to 500 staff, that order is less work than it sounds. Most already have the pieces: Some levels, some bands, a sense of who is underpaid. What they lack is the link between those pieces and the ranges they post. Making that link before the next ad goes up is what readiness means in practice.
We would also argue that readiness is a cost decision as much as a compliance one. The money to fix pay below the minimum will be spent either way. Spending it on a plan is cheaper than spending it on a complaint.
Where we help
Our pay transparency work starts with where a company stands: Which rules reach its employees and ads, whether its bands can support what it posts, who sits outside them and what to do first. The entry point is our Pay Transparency Readiness Scan, which needs no employee data and gives you a readiness scorecard and a 90-day roadmap. If you would like to talk it through first, Book a free call.
Sources
- California Labor Commissioner, Equal Pay Act FAQ (questions 46, 53, 77 and 83), checked 2026-10-20
- New York Labor Law § 194-b (New York State Senate), checked 2026-10-20
- Illinois Department of Labor, Equal Pay Act salary transparency FAQ (questions 23 and 23A), checked 2026-10-20
- Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Articles 6, 7, 9 and 34 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-20
- Lewis Silkin, EU Pay Transparency Directive: 2026 employer compliance (1 July 2026), checked 2026-10-20
- Code of Virginia § 40.1-28.7:12 (Virginia Legislative Information System), checked 2026-10-20
- Delaware Laws, Volume 85, Chapter 228 (formerly HB 105), § 709C, checked 2026-10-20
- Aon, 2025 Global Pay Transparency Study (global and North America figures), checked 2026-10-20