Guide · Pay bands

Broadbands: When do they help?

Wide bands do not remove pay decisions. They move them to managers. Be ready for that before you switch.

Short answer: Broadbands replace many narrow pay ranges with a few wide ones. They help where jobs vary along a continuum and managers are trained to place people. They hurt where they hide differences in job size, invite very wide posted ranges and leave each pay decision to whoever sets it. Keep levels underneath and reference points inside.

From eighteen grades to five bands

Picture a 200-person company in Albuquerque that provides managed IT services to hospitals and clinics. It has 18 pay grades, inherited from an acquisition, each with a narrow range. Managers complain constantly. A strong engineer hits the top of her grade in two years and the only way to pay her more is a promotion the work does not justify. Every move between grades needs a committee.

The head of people proposes five broad bands instead: Support, professional, senior professional, lead and executive. Each band is wide, roughly two to three times the width of the old grades. Managers will place people anywhere in the band based on skill and contribution. Fewer grades, fewer arguments, more room to reward growth.

A year later, some of that has happened. Managers are happier and promotion requests have fallen. But other things have happened too. Two network engineers doing similar work are $31,000 apart, because one manager placed generously and another did not. A posted range for a senior role spanned so much that a candidate in Virginia asked whether it was a real number. And when the company ran its first pay gap analysis, the band containing both service desk leads and solution architects showed a large gap between women and men that nobody could explain by band, because the band held jobs of very different size.

This is a composite of a common situation at companies this size, not a client. The details and figures are illustrative.

Why broadbands are hard to get right

Broadbanding sets two good goals against each other. The first is flexibility. Narrow grades force artificial promotions, constant regrading and exceptions for anyone who grows in the job. Wide bands let pay follow a person's development without moving them into a different job. The second is control. A pay structure exists so that people doing similar work are paid on a similar basis and so the company can explain why. The wider a band, the less the band itself explains.

Width is relative. A compensation data provider's long-standing rule of thumb puts traditional range spreads at around 40% for hourly roles, rising to around 60% for executives [1]. That figure is older than our other sources and describes typical practice, not a rule. Broadbands are, by design, several times wider than that.

The deeper problem is where the decision goes. In a narrow grade, the structure decides most of the pay and the manager adjusts at the edges. In a broadband, the structure decides little and the manager decides most. That would not matter if judgment were consistent. Research suggests it often is not. A widely cited study of nearly 9,000 employees at one company found smaller raises for women and minorities with the same performance score, job, unit and manager as white men [2]. A study of more than 700,000 US initial salary offers found a 5.5% gap between offers to women and men after detailed controls [3]. Both gaps sat in decisions where people had discretion. Broadbands make more decisions discretionary.

None of this makes broadbands wrong. It makes them a different kind of structure, one that relies on management practice where a narrow structure relies on rules. A company with experienced managers, good pay data and a habit of reviewing outcomes can run broadbands well. A company without those will find that wide bands amplify whatever inconsistency it already has.

Two terms will help. A broadband is a pay range much wider than a traditional grade, usually covering several former grades or levels. Position in range is where a person's pay sits between the minimum and maximum of their band.

Five traps with broadbands

"Fewer bands, fewer arguments"

What it looks like: The company adopts broadbands to end the constant arguments about which grade a job belongs in and when someone can move up.

Why smart teams fall into it: Grade arguments are real, time-consuming and often petty. Removing most of the boundaries seems to remove most of the arguments.

What it costs: The arguments move inside the band. Instead of debating which grade, managers decide where in a very wide range, usually with less guidance than the old grades gave them. Generous managers place people high, strict managers place them low and the band allows both. The differences are now harder to see, because everyone is in the same band. The research on discretion suggests where this leads [2] [3]. A broadband without written placement criteria does not reduce pay decisions. It hides them.

"Promotions won't matter anymore"

What it looks like: With fewer bands, people progress within a band for years. Leaders expect that pay growth inside the band will replace the need for frequent promotions.

Why smart teams fall into it: Artificial promotions were one of the problems broadbands were meant to solve. Paying for growth without a title change seems cleaner.

What it costs: People still want to know where they stand and what comes next. When bands absorb several former levels, the signal of progress disappears. Employees ask for new titles instead, managers invent them and the company ends up with title inflation on top of a structure with too few steps. The career path becomes harder to explain, not easier. Most companies that broadband successfully keep a level structure underneath the bands, so jobs still have defined levels even when pay ranges are wide. Our guide on how many job levels you need covers how to size that structure.

"Post the band"

What it looks like: When pay range laws require a range in job ads, the company posts the broadband for the role.

Why smart teams fall into it: The band is the company's official range for the job. Posting anything narrower feels like inventing a number.

What it costs: A posted range that spans two or three former grades tells candidates very little and current staff a great deal. It is also becoming harder to defend. Virginia's law, in force since 1 July 2026, tells a court to consider the breadth of a posted range when deciding whether it was set in good faith [4]. Delaware's law includes breadth as a factor when it takes effect in September 2027 [5]. A broadband may be the right internal structure and still the wrong number to post. Most companies with broadbands post a hiring range inside the band. Our guide on how wide a posted pay range can be covers the rules and the judgment.

"One band for very different jobs"

What it looks like: Each band holds many jobs, some of them quite different in size, because the band was defined by broad career stage rather than by job content.

Why smart teams fall into it: Grouping jobs broadly is the point of broadbanding. Fine distinctions between jobs are what made the old grades hard to manage.

What it costs: A band is not a comparison group. Under US federal equal pay guidance, job content, not titles or classifications, decides whether jobs are equal [7]. Under the EU pay transparency directive, pay structures must allow employers to assess whether workers are doing work of equal value, on objective criteria such as skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions. Pay gaps are reported by category of workers doing the same work or work of equal value. A gap of 5% or more in a category that cannot be explained by objective criteria can lead to a joint pay assessment [6]. A broadband that mixes jobs of different value gives the company no answer to either test. It still needs to know which jobs within the band are of equal value. Our guide on proving that two jobs are of equal value covers that comparison.

"The band will follow the market"

What it looks like: The company sets the bands once and expects the width to absorb market movement. With so much room in each band, there is no need for regular adjustments.

Why smart teams fall into it: The room is real. A band two or three times wider than a grade can hold several years of market movement before anyone hits the top.

What it costs: Without a reference point inside the band, nobody knows where a job should be paid now. Roles whose market moved fast drift low, roles whose market stood still drift high and the band hides both. Cost drifts too. In a wide band with no reference point, the natural direction of placement is upward, because every manager can find a reason to move a good person higher and few find a reason to hold them. Over a few cycles, average position in band rises without any change in the work. Payroll grows faster than the market and the company only notices when the budget no longer covers the raises it has come to expect. Measures that depend on a midpoint lose their meaning, because the midpoint of a very wide band is not anyone's market rate. Most companies that keep broadbands working add market reference points or zones inside each band, by job or job family. They update those each year. Our note on compa-ratio and range penetration covers which measure works when ranges are wide.

What broadbands that work look like

Broadbands can work well. They suit organizations where jobs vary along a continuum of skill, such as specialist or technical roles. They also need managers who are trained and trusted to place people. At 50 to 500 people, the broadband structures that hold up share these qualities.

Levels still exist underneath. Jobs are leveled by their content even when pay ranges are wide. The band is a pay tool. The level describes the job.

Each job has a reference point inside the band. A market rate or a zone for each job or job family tells managers where a fully competent person in that job should sit. The band gives room. The reference point gives direction.

Placement follows written criteria. Managers know what moves someone from one part of the band to the next: Skills shown, scope held, results delivered. Placement above the reference zone needs a second approval.

Posted ranges are hiring ranges. The range in a job ad is the part of the band the company expects to hire into, not the whole band.

Equal value is known within the band. The company can say which jobs inside a band are of equal value and compares pay within those groups, not across the band as a whole.

Placement is reviewed by group. Once a year, someone looks at where people sit in their bands by gender, team and manager. A manager whose people cluster at one end is a conversation, not a crisis.

The move into bands was handled openly. When grades are collapsed into bands, nobody's pay is cut and everyone learns where they sit in the new band and why. People who were at the top of a narrow grade often find themselves in the middle of a wide band. Told well, that is good news, because it means room to grow. Told badly, or not at all, it looks like a demotion. The mapping from old grades to new bands and levels is written down, so the next manager can see why each person landed where they did.

The bands were chosen for a reason. Where jobs are uniform and grow slowly, such as some operational roles, narrower ranges may still serve better. A company can use both.

The calls only you can make

Broad or narrow, by job family. Broadbands suit some families better than others. A single answer for the whole company is rarely right.

The reference points inside each band. Market rates by job, zones by experience or both. Each gives managers different guidance and different freedom.

Approval for placement. Who signs off when someone is placed above the reference zone. That is the point where the decision leaves the manager.

The number you post. A hiring range inside the band, the band itself or a narrower zone. The answer depends on the laws where you hire and how much you want candidates to see.

How people move across. Whether everyone is mapped at once or family by family. Whether anyone's place in the new band changes their pay in the first cycle. A quiet switch saves effort now and costs trust later.

The title structure. Whether progress inside a band carries a title change. Without one, people may feel stuck. With too many, titles inflate.

The law and the numbers

  • Range widths. A compensation data provider's long-standing rule of thumb puts traditional range spreads at about 40% for hourly roles, rising to about 60% for executives [1]. This guidance is older than our other sources. We cite it as a common reference for traditional ranges.
  • Discretion in raises. A study of nearly 9,000 employees at one company found smaller raises for women and minorities with the same performance score, job, unit and manager as white men [2].
  • Discretion in offers. A study of more than 700,000 US initial salary offers from 2017 to 2020 found a 5.5% gap between offers to women and men after detailed controls [3].
  • Virginia. A posted range must be set in good faith and a court considers the breadth of the range in deciding whether it was [4].
  • Delaware. Breadth is one factor in judging whether a posted range was set in good faith, from September 2027 [5].
  • European Union. Pay structures must allow assessment of equal value on objective, gender-neutral criteria including skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions (Article 4). Pay gaps are reported by category of workers (Article 9). An unexplained gap of 5% or more in a category can lead to a joint pay assessment (Article 10) [6].
  • United States, equal work. Job content, not job titles or classifications, determines whether jobs are equal under federal equal pay guidance [7].

This is general information, not legal advice. Rules and their national versions differ. Check the rules where you employ people.

Our view

We think broadbands are a reasonable choice for some job families and a risky one for a whole company. Their benefit is real: Fewer artificial promotions and more room to pay for growth. Their cost is easy to miss: The decisions a narrow structure made now sit with managers and the structure no longer shows whether they are consistent.

So we would keep levels underneath, put a reference point inside each band, write down what moves someone through it and post hiring ranges rather than bands. Then we would look each year at where people sit by group and by manager. With those in place, wide bands give flexibility without giving up control. The company can also show anyone who asks why a person sits where they do. Without them, they mainly make inconsistency harder to see.

Sources

  1. Payscale, salary range widths by profession (updated 2018; cited as a long-standing rule of thumb), checked 2026-10-20
  2. Castilla, Gender, race and meritocracy in organizational careers, American Journal of Sociology 113(6), 2008, checked 2026-10-25
  3. Sterling and Wang, Setting Up the Gap? Gender Differences in Initial Salary Offers in Hiring, Organization Science (19 May 2025), checked 2026-10-26
  4. Code of Virginia § 40.1-28.7:12, subsection B(6) (Virginia Legislative Information System), checked 2026-10-20
  5. Delaware Laws, Volume 85, Chapter 228 (formerly HB 105), § 709C, checked 2026-10-20
  6. Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency, Articles 4, 9 and 10 (EUR-Lex), checked 2026-10-28
  7. US EEOC, Compliance Manual Section 10: Compensation Discrimination, 10-IV.E.2 (comparison of work), checked 2026-10-30

Grade vs band vs level: What does each one do?

Grade, band and level sound alike but decide different things. Five ways the three get mixed up and what a structure you can explain rests on.

How wide can a posted pay range be?

Virginia now weighs range width in good faith and Delaware will from 2027. Five ways posted ranges go wrong and what a defensible range looks like.

How many job levels do you need?

How many job levels a company needs depends on the work, not the headcount. Five traps in setting the count and what a sound ladder looks like.

See Resources for every guide and the self-check.